Bent Rod

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Jean
    replied
    This whole thing sounds sketchy.

    Leave a comment:


  • JTapper
    replied
    Originally posted by xxx-Lost-Soul-xxx
    He is getting the compression tested this weekend.
    If he's got a bent rod, compression will be low, but the leakdown will be fairly normal.

    If they didn't do a compression test already, how do they know it was a bent rod?

    Leave a comment:


  • xxx-Lost-Soul-xxx
    replied
    Originally posted by Jean
    Doubt it's a nikasil issue, it would be loosing compression and not bending a rod.
    He is getting the compression tested this weekend.

    Leave a comment:


  • Jean
    replied
    Doubt it's a nikasil issue, it would be loosing compression and not bending a rod.

    Leave a comment:


  • xxx-Lost-Soul-xxx
    replied
    The Motor Never went threw the Nikisi Recal program.

    And the Motor never had the Timing chain tensioner redone,I Stressed Getting that done to the buyer after it was sold.

    So My Guess is that the NikIsi finnally caught up with the Block,as i was using 93 in my possession,and the new owner was using 87. Or the Tensioner went.

    Leave a comment:


  • slammin.e28
    replied
    Timing chain tensioner got weak, allowed slack in chain enough so piston met valve, bent valve. After a while of kissing, then the guide/spring pressure trying to straighten the valve out, the valve finally broke off (think bending a paper clip back and forth, then it breaks). This piece wedged between the piston and head and bent the rod, also it destroyed the piston, cylinder, and combustion chamber bouncing around in there.

    Basically what happened to this S38.

    http://www.mye28.com/viewtopic.php?t=116217

    With the lack of info, and info contrary to driving through a puddle, etc, I propose this extreme scenario.

    Leave a comment:


  • xxx-Lost-Soul-xxx
    replied
    Originally posted by Holland
    Lol, you never told me about the fan. Methinks it probably overheated.

    On a M60 i dont think so? Ive seen some wacked cooling stuff and the motors were still good. The guy who bought it from me isnt that dumb, He would have know better. "atleast i hope so"

    Leave a comment:


  • Holland
    replied
    Originally posted by xxx-Lost-Soul-xxx
    The guy isnt asking for anything except some help.

    About two weeks ago i get a call telling me. That since ive sold it he had the fan blow up and put a dent in the hood. Then last week he called me to tell me the car runs like poo.

    I Tell him, i cant diagnose it as im 1000 miles away. That he should prob take it to a mechanic in town. So today i get a call telling me the shop came back with a Bent Rod.

    I have an idea why it happened,but before i share what i think. Iwanted to see if what i think is logical or outof space.
    Lol, you never told me about the fan. Methinks it probably overheated.

    Leave a comment:


  • MonkeyMadness
    replied
    Fan blew up and dented the hood? Why? Back story on this may lead you to the problem he is now dealing with....!?!

    Leave a comment:


  • Komzorz
    replied
    I sold a car (corolla w/ 90k miles) once and less than six months later it bent a rod / spun a bearing or something.

    Dude would fire the car up cold and immediately nail the gas backing up a substantial hill in reverse every morning.

    Methinks it simply wasn't treated right.

    Leave a comment:


  • xxx-Lost-Soul-xxx
    replied
    The guy isnt asking for anything except some help.

    About two weeks ago i get a call telling me. That since ive sold it he had the fan blow up and put a dent in the hood. Then last week he called me to tell me the car runs like poo.

    I Tell him, i cant diagnose it as im 1000 miles away. That he should prob take it to a mechanic in town. So today i get a call telling me the shop came back with a Bent Rod.

    I have an idea why it happened,but before i share what i think. Iwanted to see if what i think is logical or outof space.

    Leave a comment:


  • JTapper
    replied
    So what I'm going to assume here, is that you sold this car four months ago, and since then, it has developed a bent rod.

    Is the new owner pushing blame on you for this? It's not like they bend over time, really. The bend, they're bent, and the engine runs like shit. Run it like shit for long enough and it'll spit the rod through the crankcase.

    I'd tell them to pound sand.

    Leave a comment:


  • rhE-30
    replied
    Sold 4 months ago? The problem with the engine... is not yours.

    Leave a comment:


  • Jean
    replied
    1995 540i/6 is your story? LOL

    D E T A I L S...... what happened etc...

    Leave a comment:


  • xxx-Lost-Soul-xxx
    replied
    Originally posted by jtapper
    also, piston to valve contact will not bend a rod.

    Detonation (lean condition) or water.

    What's the backstory?
    1995 540i/6 Car Was in very good shape before being sold 4 months ago.

    Leave a comment:

Working...