911 Funnies
Collapse
X
-
You "engineers" are all the same,you think whats written on paper is always correct than real life. -
Dear God, this is painful to watch, and nothing you "Truthers" have said has made the slightest bit of sense. What you're failing to notice here is that no single structural failure event happens in a vaccuum. The plane hits 6 floors, with the force of the impact ripping apart reinforcements within the structure and placing huge loads on the skeletal structure itself. This alone might not have been enough to topple the floors, but the atomized fuel would then ignite and burn, with much more intensity than flaming piles of jet fuel. If anything, the atomization of burning fuel increased the amount of structural damage. Jet fuel burns at a certain temperature, which then causes huge pressure changes across the floors. While you might not think that simple pressure changes could be as destructive as the physical aircraft impact, keep in mind that it is exactly these kind of pressure changes that are responsible for upwards of 90% of damage caused by an explosion, i.e. bomb/weapon. Lastly, keep in mind that these events don't happen simultaneously, or instantaneously, and many of them would have had a certain frequency response related to them. (for example, the plane hits- steel bends one way. It springs back- steel now has to resist the other way. Or, Pressure expands the floors outward-pressure releases and expands the floor inward. Yes, it's a real effect and is counted on in weapons design. How much it had an effect here, I don't know.) This, combined with the weakened state of the steel from the intense heat generated by the burning fireball of jet fuel, could have caused enough fatigue in the steel to allow one floor to collapse. The impulse from the floor collapsing would almost certainly been enough to collapse an already damaged floor beneath it, which would have doubled the impulse on the stronger floor above it. This continues, creating the "pancake" effect you saw.
And as for the designers saying they did the math to make sure it wouldn't happen, Math is an approximation of reality. There is no way they could have taken into account every variable, every exact temperature, every possible resonant frequency, etc. that occurred in the towers. And simply because it was "designed" to withstand such a theoretical impact does not mean it was tested. Given the conflicting design requirements that go into a building like this, I'm sure Jihad via 757 resistance was studied but put on a back burner.
This is not to say the math they did was wrong, or that the engineers lied. But, it's much easier to say "it should not have failed, we did the math" instead of "uuhhhhhhh... we didn't think it could happen." Simply that, in the real world, how structures behave is often much different than what is simulated mathematically. To say otherwise is to say entire industries are unnecessary. There's test pilots, operational testers, even the UL laboratories for exactly this reason.Leave a comment:
-
the fact we are even discussing this is ridiculous. i wonder if those columns were wrapped in blue painters tape if they would have held up better?Leave a comment:
-
Had the nerve? Ok let me say this. Skyscrapers weigh a lot...we all know this. When a plane impacts 9 floors of a building, or even 6, the building's structural integrity is severly weakend. The way the WTC towers were designed was with a central core shaft and the outside surfaces of the building taking most of the weight. When the planes impacted they created very large holes in the side of the buildings, where did the weight of the upper part of the buildings go? I was redistributed. This meant that all sections of the buildings now had far more tonnage on them. The building was designed to deal with this. That is why they didnt collaspe immediately.
Now then, back to my main point in the matter. The fireproffing on many floors was stripped off, this made the already weakedned due to impact damage and increased load buildings even more subceptable to the heat of a fire. Fair enough the fuel atomized, but it still ignited blazes throughout the building.
And now its back to the trellis desgin of the floors. I would imagine that the collaspe started here as it is the only thing that makes sense. When the top of the building began to accelerate it generated great stress at the location on the building that held up the most weight...that would be the base. The increased stress caused the base of the building to fail...not explosives.
But then again my family is only a group of engineers...so what do we know anyway?Leave a comment:
-
-
-
-
-
This issue isn't whether I believe it. The engineers who designed them didn't believe even two impacts could take one of them down.
I don't see in my post where I mentioned explosives.
Again, I didn't bring up explosives, but since you did, in buidlings this size, there are constantly various maintenance/physical plant types coming and going. There are also many areas not accessible by the general public. The presence of additional/unfamiliar personnel alone would not necessarily get anyone's attention.
Uhhh, I am asking for an explanation, one that doesn't require such a willing suspension of disbelief. Please note-the documents I refer to are not from so-called "Truther" sites, but from the Official reports.
No one yet has convincingly explained how WTC 7, not hit by a plane, with fires over a few floors, and part of one side structurally damaged didn't topple, but fell straight down, like WTC 1 and 2 despite different construction techniques.
Here's the NIST report. I've read the whole bloody thing. In addition to the entire 9/11 Commission Report. In addition to most of the other "official" accounts.
You "burning pools of jet fuel" believers may take particular interest in page 51, where the investigators state the first plane was going (only) 440MPH, and the damage spanned 6 floors, and that the second plane, going 100MPH faster created damage over 9 floors. Given the obvious fireball from the initial impact, and the extreme forceful dispersion of that jet fuel, can anyone tell me with any amount of veracity that the remaining amount of fuel spread over 6-9+ floors was enough to soften the steel?
Even the NIST doesn't seem to think so. <shrugs shoulders> That's just them. What about FEMA?
Page 21 of the FEMA report states:
Pools of flaming jet fuel? Fema continues:A review of photographic and video records show that the aircraft fully entered the buildings prior to any visual evidence of flames at the exteriors of the buildings. This suggests that, as the aircraft crashed into and plowed across the buildings, they distributed jet fuel throughout the impact area to form a flammable "cloud". Ignition of this cloud resulted in a rapid pressure rise, expelling a fuel rich mixture from the impact area into shafts and through other openings caused by the crashes, resulting in dramatic fireballs"
So, no pools of flaming jet fuel, according to the official report.The time to consume the jet fuel can be reasonably computed. At the upper bound, assuming that all 10,000 gallons were distributed evenly across a single building floor, it would form a pool that would be consumed in less than five minutes (emphasis mine) provided sufficient air for combustion was available. In reality, the jet fuel would have been distributed over multiple floors, and some would have been transported to other locations......accounting for these factors, it is believed that almost all the remaing jet fueled was consumed in the first few minutes of the fire.
chadthestampede:
Made me smile....Last edited by Old'n'Slow; 09-14-2009, 09:00 AM.Leave a comment:
-
So........you're saying Tom Clancy organized it?
Really, it concerns me that our major cities are apparently so vulnerable, when we have continually been assured they are not. Tom Clancy presaged such an attack in his 1995 book "Debt of Honor" where a lone Japanese pilot who manages to lie his way past ATC flies his 747 into the Capitol in an attempt to kill the President and destroy the US Government.Leave a comment:
-
I'm a research scientist myself. Here's something you quickly learn when you're in the business of trying to convince people of things: It's not enough to say "this explanation doesn't make sense." You've got to go ahead and propose an alternative explanation that does make sense. Otherwise, you're just noise. Anyone can say "that's doesn't sound right to me." OK, so give me something better.First, I've no agenda besides curiosity, so try not to make any assumptions, mkay?
So..... it doesn't strike you as a little odd that even the NIST analysis stated that given the inputs, the buildings shouldn't have failed?
It doesn't strike you as odd that two different impacts caused two identical failures?
Just saying....the designers said those buildings could withstand (more than one) jet impacts. Yet no one has ever conclusively demonstrated why they failed. In an age where we continue to build skyscapers where planes can hit them, were I one of the engineers, I think I'd want to know!
Again: NIST stated: "We are unable to provide a full explanation of the total collapse".
It is of course, your perogative whether you are completely OK will all that, but you cannot dismiss out-of-hand the numbers of very well-versed engineers who think it's malarky, and who have paid for it dearly. A top researcher with UL, for example. Probably not a complete idiot to rise to that posting, he was canned because he dared suggest that they had seen no evidence to suggest there was a raging inferno capable of the required temperatures to soften the types of steels that were used in those buildings. Others in the field of aviation further had the nerve to suggest that during the crash itself, the wings (where the fuel is) would have been torn to shreds and the fuel therein atomized, hence the fireballs, which would have consumed said fuel. In other words, it is very, very unlikely that there were pools of burning aviation fuel lying about cooking the steel, as some "reverse" conspiracy theorists (the "yep, happened just like the gov't said, screw anyone who thinks different" types) would like to believe.
Me, I just want to know what really happened. Given the US Government track record of forthrightness throughout its 200+ year history, which frankly sucks, I am curious.
Really, it concerns me that our major cities are apparently so vulnerable, when we have continually been assured they are not. Tom Clancy presaged such an attack in his 1995 book "Debt of Honor" where a lone Japanese pilot who manages to lie his way past ATC flies his 747 into the Capitol in an attempt to kill the President and destroy the US Government.
Lastly, do you know anything about "Fan Death"? Many Koreans believe that leaving a fan on overnight can kill you. They cannot be bothered to investigate why this happens, it just does. It's so rampant that fans come with warning labels! Beliefs like these are created when a simple, black and white answer, which humans love, BTW, is substituted for a more messy reality: People who are generally healthy sometimes die with no apparent reason. Let's not go down the path of fan-death type beliefs when it comes to 9/11. Cut and dried don't cut it.
As for the topic at hand, you don't believe flying a fully fueled Boeing 757 can destroy a building. OK, then what do you think did destroy the building? Outline your alternative hypothesis.
9/11 conspiracy theorists will say the building was demolished by "explosives." Do you know how much C4 you need and how many months it takes to demo a building? You need literally tens of thousands of pounds of explosives and it takes several months and a huge crew to wire it all up. You can't just pile it all in the basement. It's a massive job.
How do you think "the government" was able to install 10,000+ lbs of explosives in each WTC tower over the course of several months while the buildings were being used everyday by thousands of people...and no one noticed?
Provide an explanation to that question, and people will listen. Otherwise, you're just noise.Leave a comment:
-
First, I've no agenda besides curiosity, so try not to make any assumptions, mkay?
So..... it doesn't strike you as a little odd that even the NIST analysis stated that given the inputs, the buildings shouldn't have failed?
It doesn't strike you as odd that two different impacts caused two identical failures?
Just saying....the designers said those buildings could withstand (more than one) jet impacts. Yet no one has ever conclusively demonstrated why they failed. In an age where we continue to build skyscapers where planes can hit them, were I one of the engineers, I think I'd want to know!
Again: NIST stated: "We are unable to provide a full explanation of the total collapse".
It is of course, your perogative whether you are completely OK will all that, but you cannot dismiss out-of-hand the numbers of very well-versed engineers who think it's malarky, and who have paid for it dearly. A top researcher with UL, for example. Probably not a complete idiot to rise to that posting, he was canned because he dared suggest that they had seen no evidence to suggest there was a raging inferno capable of the required temperatures to soften the types of steels that were used in those buildings. Others in the field of aviation further had the nerve to suggest that during the crash itself, the wings (where the fuel is) would have been torn to shreds and the fuel therein atomized, hence the fireballs, which would have consumed said fuel. In other words, it is very, very unlikely that there were pools of burning aviation fuel lying about cooking the steel, as some "reverse" conspiracy theorists (the "yep, happened just like the gov't said, screw anyone who thinks different" types) would like to believe.
Me, I just want to know what really happened. Given the US Government track record of forthrightness throughout its 200+ year history, which frankly sucks, I am curious.
Really, it concerns me that our major cities are apparently so vulnerable, when we have continually been assured they are not. Tom Clancy presaged such an attack in his 1995 book "Debt of Honor" where a lone Japanese pilot who manages to lie his way past ATC flies his 747 into the Capitol in an attempt to kill the President and destroy the US Government.
Lastly, do you know anything about "Fan Death"? Many Koreans believe that leaving a fan on overnight can kill you. They cannot be bothered to investigate why this happens, it just does. It's so rampant that fans come with warning labels! Beliefs like these are created when a simple, black and white answer, which humans love, BTW, is substituted for a more messy reality: People who are generally healthy sometimes die with no apparent reason. Let's not go down the path of fan-death type beliefs when it comes to 9/11. Cut and dried don't cut it.Leave a comment:


Leave a comment: