SCOTUS rules in favor of the 2nd Amendment

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • joshh
    replied
    Originally posted by Ryan Stewart
    No criminal is knowingly going to take the fall for someone else. The gun is traced and the person who bought the gun in the straw sale is fucked. That ISNT how criminals get guns. I sold the things for 3 years and only one came back as used in a crime, second hand. It was involved in a crime of passon. That wasnt one out of all of the guns I sold, that was for our entire dealer for 11 years.

    Im sure straw purchases happen every day. What law do you propose will prevent them? Dunno if you know this but they are already illegal. The typical straw purchase is to get around residency requirements, not to conceal the original of a gun to be used in a crime (because its a shitty way to do it).

    Criminals use stolen, imported or shaved guns. They dont buy them from dealers, prove otherwise or your entire argument is garbage.

    My sole argument is that gun laws, like any ban, do jack shit to slow the influx of anything to criminals. At most they just raise the price.

    Handguns are banned in England if I am not mistaken. So you mean to tell me that criminals dont have access to handguns?

    But I thought you said criminals don't follow the law so why bother make laws for criminals?? Straw sales are the law, why would they care? Just using your own words against you. People even go as far as getting a FFL so they can sell the guns to criminals. But wait, that's against the law as well.
    Yes it is.

    http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontl...ocon/guns.html





    James Brady was shot by a gun from a straw sale.

    Common Dreams has been providing breaking news & views for the progressive community since 1997. We are independent, non-profit, advertising-free and 100% reader supported. Our Mission: To inform. To inspire. To ignite change for the common good.


    http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpag...55C0A9629C8B63







    Is it the only way criminals are getting guns, no. But it is a very easy way to get them.
    And like I said before, it;'s not the criminals we should only be focusing on.
    Many laws are made to keep honest people honest.

    Wrong, current gun laws do jack shit because they were designed poorly.

    I can't believe you're outright saying criminals don't get guns this way.
    It's pretty obvious you have done very little reading on this subject.
    People don't speed either because then they'd get a ticket.
    Last edited by joshh; 07-02-2008, 06:37 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ryan Stewart
    replied
    Originally posted by joshh
    Yeah because MY friends aren't criminals. Criminals friends don't give a shit.
    Straw sales are a fact and are being done this minute and the gun is used in a crime. Just because you see the flaw in why they shouldn't doesn't mean it's not happening. Straw sales are a huge problem here. That is a fact.

    I want gun laws that at least slow the influx of arms to criminals. And it can be done. With some laws that are half way smart unlike the ones we have now.
    But I will also push the same point again. Just because someone doesn't have a felony doesn't mean they are honest or can be trusted with a firearm.
    Laws need to be passed to protect people that are responsible with they're firearms.
    No criminal is knowingly going to take the fall for someone else. The gun is traced and the person who bought the gun in the straw sale is fucked. That ISNT how criminals get guns. I sold the things for 3 years and only one came back as used in a crime, second hand. It was involved in a crime of passon. That wasnt one out of all of the guns I sold, that was for our entire dealer for 11 years.

    Im sure straw purchases happen every day. What law do you propose will prevent them? Dunno if you know this but they are already illegal. The typical straw purchase is to get around residency requirements, not to conceal the original of a gun to be used in a crime (because its a shitty way to do it).

    Criminals use stolen, imported or shaved guns. They dont buy them from dealers, prove otherwise or your entire argument is garbage.

    My sole argument is that gun laws, like any ban, do jack shit to slow the influx of anything to criminals. At most they just raise the price.

    Handguns are banned in England if I am not mistaken. So you mean to tell me that criminals dont have access to handguns?

    Leave a comment:


  • Vedubin01
    replied
    though that sounds good and might be used in the future. The problem is that the government now knows who owns what. Thats a bad thing. The fathers of this country were against big government and left England for that reason (religious as well) The law was so that the government could not inslave its people. And with a tracking system, storm troopers could storm in and remove and disarm its people changing the government as it is today.

    Today government already has to much power. They are already trying to dictate what you do and how you do it. We come from the land of the free and though we live free'r than others its not what this country was meant to be.


    When you were forced to have a Social Security number, many said it was the mark of the beast. A way that government can track you. Now not only does the government use that number your also tracked with your credit. Tracking guns is a bad thing because its the only way to be able to over power our government if need be. Remember the Government is to be working for us and not the other way around as it is today.

    Leave a comment:


  • Hallen
    replied
    I am a gun advocate for the most part. However, there are just too many irresponsible people out there when it comes to taking responsibility for the protection, use, and sale of their weapons.

    I know there are ways around just about every security device out there, but something like an RFID signature chip embedded in every gun would help. All guns would need to be sold only through authorized dealers. Dealers would have to take the responsibility of either providing consignment services or outright purchase of "used" guns. That would be the only way to disassociate that gun from me, the person who bought it originally. If a gun gets used in a crime, and that gun can be traced back to me, then there would be some serious questions if the gun hadn't been reported as stolen. This might help keep people more aware of the disposal and storage of unwanted weapons. I think it would also help with straw sales.

    Of course dirty dealers and possibly some other technology to disable the RFID would be able to get around these safeguards. But, it is one idea that would allow honest and responsible people to own guns, while taking some measures to control those guns getting to the bad guys.

    I currently don't own weapons because I don't feel the need to do so. However, I do know how to handle and fire just about any weapon out there. I have had that training. I have also had some pretty good shooting lessons and I enjoy shooting as a sport. If I did own weapons, then I would also own a gun safe. I don't want my stuff stolen and a safe is a good way to prevent that.

    I also have an antique weapon that was collected by my great grandfather and passed down to me by my grandfather. I would love to hang it on the wall of my front room, but since you could see into that room from the street, I don't do it. It would be too tempting for some moron to try and steal, even though the gun is a muzzle loader and not in a condition to ever be fired again. Sad.

    Leave a comment:


  • Vedubin01
    replied
    Straw purchases are illegal and you can face some serious time for it.

    You are not allowed to purchase a gun for anyone other than yourself. If your caught you can face 10 years and up to $250k in fines.

    I am not really worried about that as much as the guns that are already in the hands of the criminals. The big time drug dealers and such are guys that might live right next door to you and me. They have no criminal record. Thus current laws would not screen them out. The gang bangers steal guns from houses and cars that were not properly stored.

    I feel if a gun is used in a criminal act, such as armed robbery, murder (proven- not self defense) and any violent act, the death penalty would be enacted.

    I am all for public executions in town square. People need to understand that life is fragile. And people need to see someone die, to understand that its not a game and there are serious consequences for ones actions.

    Hold the parents and family responsible for their kids actions. Take away all benefits and social security to all family members. People just need to be accountable and the only way to do that is Stern punishment for their actions!



    Just remember an armed society is a polite society.

    Leave a comment:


  • CleanAzzE30z
    replied
    Originally posted by joshh





    Problem here is the criminal isn't the only one to worry about. Straw sales are made by what the Right call "honest" owners.
    So it's not just the criminal we have to worry about.
    Hey man you dont have to tell me. I know.




    Mariano

    Leave a comment:


  • joshh
    replied
    Originally posted by CleanAzzE30z
    Its that new thing, I think its called sarcasm. Dont know if its gotten around to you over there yet. ;) jk man.



    T

    Missed that...



    Originally posted by CleanAzzE30z
    Exactly. There is the crux of the argument. How does one take the guns away from the people that really shouldnt have them. These people will find a way to get them no matter what the laws are since its not governed by the laws seeing as its illegal. You have a point here.




    Mariano
    Problem here is the criminal isn't the only one to worry about. Straw sales are made by what the Right call "honest" owners.
    So it's not just the criminal we have to worry about.

    Leave a comment:


  • joshh
    replied
    Originally posted by Ryan Stewart
    You arent listening/reading.

    I said:

    straw sales are shit for criminals because if you are using them in a crime you fuck the guy buying it for you. Black market = nobody gives a shit what you do.

    0 of those 10 people wouldnt buy a gun for you if they knew you were going to use it for a criminal act.

    And you are disproving your own point. You want gun laws but you are saying you know firsthand to get around them. GREAT! That means, like I said, the only people affected by them are those who already FOLLOW THE RULES.

    Yeah because MY friends aren't criminals. Criminals friends don't give a shit.
    Straw sales are a fact and are being done this minute and the gun is used in a crime. Just because you see the flaw in why they shouldn't doesn't mean it's not happening. Straw sales are a huge problem here. That is a fact.

    I want gun laws that at least slow the influx of arms to criminals. And it can be done. With some laws that are half way smart unlike the ones we have now.
    But I will also push the same point again. Just because someone doesn't have a felony doesn't mean they are honest or can be trusted with a firearm.
    Laws need to be passed to protect people that are responsible with they're firearms.

    Leave a comment:


  • CleanAzzE30z
    replied
    Originally posted by Vedubin01
    The problem will always be that there are guns on the street. You and the Government will never be able to remove those guns. The "bad" guys will never turn them in and you would only be disarming the law abiding citizen. Thus crime rates would go up, when the "Bad" guy have no fear of getting shot.
    Exactly. There is the crux of the argument. How does one take the guns away from the people that really shouldnt have them. These people will find a way to get them no matter what the laws are since its not governed by the laws seeing as its illegal. You have a point here.




    Mariano

    Leave a comment:


  • Ryan Stewart
    replied
    Originally posted by joshh
    You're saying two different things at the same time.
    On one hand you're saying we are trying to stop criminals from owning guns and on the other you're saying the Brady bill didn't work. That's called not trying. It's called bad legislation because neither side will compromise at all.
    It was a horrible piece of law that didn't work because it was bad from the start.

    A straw sale is way easier. I can name 10 people right this minute that would be willing to buy a gun for me. Same goes for any criminal. All they need is a person with a clean record.

    http://findarticles.com/p/articles/m...47/ai_67717300
    You arent listening/reading.

    I said:

    straw sales are shit for criminals because if you are using them in a crime you fuck the guy buying it for you. Black market = nobody gives a shit what you do.

    0 of those 10 people wouldnt buy a gun for you if they knew you were going to use it for a criminal act.

    And you are disproving your own point. You want gun laws but you are saying you know firsthand to get around them. GREAT! That means, like I said, the only people affected by them are those who already FOLLOW THE RULES.

    Leave a comment:


  • Vedubin01
    replied
    Originally posted by CleanAzzE30z
    Thats cool. I see your point of view, but I personally dont think the advantage of putting guns in the hands of more people outweigh the disadvantages of doing such a thing.

    Im not saying more people should own guns. Its a constitutional right as founded by the fathers that build the United States. Now if people can not respect that, then there are other countries that have laws maybe ment for them.

    Again I feel that one must have military training or have to go though a gun course (at least 80 hour classroom and field shooting) to be able to own them.

    The problem will always be that there are guns on the street. You and the Government will never be able to remove those guns. The "bad" guys will never turn them in and you would only be disarming the law abiding citizen. Thus crime rates would go up, when the "Bad" guy have no fear of getting shot.

    Its a hard battle but it has to fall all the way back to what the founders of our country wanted. And we just have to deal with the consequences of the few.

    Just dont put you or your family in harms way, be aware of your surroundings and be ready to defend if necessary because no one else is going to do that for you. And most likely you would never have a problem with this gun issue. If one lives in a neighborhood that is bad, simply move to another town that would better suit you and your families needs and safety.

    Leave a comment:


  • CleanAzzE30z
    replied
    Originally posted by joshh
    Of course, lets keep arming the criminals as well.
    Its that new thing, I think its called sarcasm. Dont know if its gotten around to you over there yet. ;) jk man.

    Originally posted by Vedubin01
    Mariano, you come from a different side of life where you've seen guns that have killed (assuming on my behalf knowing a bit about you) I for one come from a walk of life where guns were always in the family and we were brought up understanding the use and the respect of a firearm. But because guns can kill people its not fair to ban them for people like me that use them for recreation and hunting. You have to understand there are people that are responsible and do not intend to kill others with a firearm.

    Don't mean to single you out either, this thread is long. But just trying to use an example that some could relate.


    V
    Thats cool. I see your point of view, but I personally dont think the advantage of putting guns in the hands of more people outweigh the disadvantages of doing such a thing.

    Originally posted by Ryan Stewart
    I detect sarcasm, I shall add to it.

    Well, minorities (including latinos) make up the majority of the prison population. Maybe minorities are responsible for violent crime. If we disarm we should whiten up the nation too. That should solve the problem.
    Thats exactly what I was getting at. Fucking Mexicans, haha. ;)

    Leave a comment:


  • joshh
    replied
    Originally posted by Ryan Stewart
    How are we not even trying? We spend billions, institute border controls and even go into other countries to enforce.

    What didnt the brady bill try and do except require a specific license for an automatic weapon? It failed at that

    Im not even sure I should be arguing with you if you honestly think that a straw sale is easier than the black market. For starters, a straw sale means your friend is fucked if your intention is to commit a crime with that gun.

    You're saying two different things at the same time.
    On one hand you're saying we are trying to stop criminals from owning guns and on the other you're saying the Brady bill didn't work. That's called not trying. It's called bad legislation because neither side will compromise at all.
    It was a horrible piece of law that didn't work because it was bad from the start.

    A straw sale is way easier. I can name 10 people right this minute that would be willing to buy a gun for me. Same goes for any criminal. All they need is a person with a clean record.

    http://findarticles.com/p/articles/m...47/ai_67717300

    BATF statistics indicate that more than 26,000 illegal firearms were purchased in straw-man transactions between July 1996 and December 1998.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ryan Stewart
    replied
    Originally posted by CleanAzzE30z
    We are headed in the right direction. We need more guns in this country. Its probably the one thing that will surely promote less crime in general. It makes perfect sense!!



    Mariano
    I detect sarcasm, I shall add to it.

    Well, minorities (including latinos) make up the majority of the prison population. Maybe minorities are responsible for violent crime. If we disarm we should whiten up the nation too. That should solve the problem.

    Leave a comment:


  • Ryan Stewart
    replied
    Originally posted by joshh
    Who said anything about being intentionally robbed?? You leave your gun out where it can be robbed and it makes you an irresponsible owner (unless they ripped your gun safe out of the house).
    No that's not the only solution. You make gun owners be responsible for gun ownership. And if they can't be, you don't let them own guns. It's that simple.


    Access to narcotics? the "war on drugs"? Have you done much research on that subject? We aren't even trying. That's why it's not working. Same goes for controlling criminals from getting guns.

    Ban?? Who said anything about a ban? Wrong subject, wrong guy to point the finger at on bans. Are you reading what I've written already? I'm against bans.

    Jesus Christ man, your examples are exactly what I was pointing out is wrong with legislation on gun control. The Brady Bill was a total joke. You're going to have to think much broader than the Democrats who pushed that into effect.

    And there you go taking about stolen guns from owners...LMFAO. I already gave a solution for part of that problem.
    You do realize the Black market is not as easy as just having a friend buy the gun for you. And that is one of our biggest problems right there. Straw sales. One of the others is irresponsible gun owners many call "honest".
    You don't think we can come up with a solution for Straw sales either I take it?

    Any "gun control" (which is defined as anything stopping ANYONE from getting a gun) is bad gun control.
    How are we not even trying? We spend billions, institute border controls and even go into other countries to enforce.

    What didnt the brady bill try and do except require a specific license for an automatic weapon? It failed at that

    Im not even sure I should be arguing with you if you honestly think that a straw sale is easier than the black market. For starters, a straw sale means your friend is fucked if your intention is to commit a crime with that gun.

    Leave a comment:

Working...