Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Skinning Sunroof - weight reduction

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Skinning Sunroof - weight reduction

    If you are considering this, you will have or are considering removing the sunroof hardware -> metal frame, motor, rails, cables etc etc. This thread is my experience about Lightening the Sunroof and mounting it back in place. Mounting was not so trivial IMO. I had a hard time finding examples, even on e30tech :? so i made my own way with no hardware needed.

    DIY Sunroof cassette/frame removal here:


    Now you have a heavy sunroof panel on your hands and two options. Use it, or get a composite one ($250+). The sunroof itself is heavy!! Weights about 13-14lbs. If you skin it, it weights about 6. The composite one weights around 4-5lbs... go figure.

    I will upload pics later. I did all this last night. I tried searching the web and found techniques such as welding mounting tabs (welded or to bolt sunroof if you want to remove it) and some even welded a bar completely across the panel and then ligned up and welded it to the roof skin.

    To skin the sunroof.
    *Dremel or use your favorite cutting tool (i used a 4.5" cutoff wheel).
    *Remove the sunroof seal (slides right off)
    *Cut what eq to 1/16" steel, about 1/2" from the inner lip of the sunroof all the way around.
    *The sunroof is also held by adhesive inside, but you can pry it off by hand. Be carefull not to bend the skin of the sunroof panel.

    Tips: I had a water bottle next to me to cool the metal off and keep the paint from bubbling up. It was relatively easy to do this. It took me a solid 35min to do this (at my pace)

    Prepping Panel.
    I wire wheeled all the adhesive, rust, sound deadening, etc off and sprayed the inside black with hammerite paint.
    Then i metal prepped (wire wheeled/grinded) the places where i was going to make my welds. These are 3 in the front, 2 on each side, 2 on the back.

    Prepping the car.
    *Instead of mounting tabs, i decided to use the left over sunroof lip on the roof skin as my "tabs".
    *I used pliers and bent them outwards like 1/2" on the front and sides (you can't on rear, there's no lip).
    *BE CAREFUL WITH YOUR ROOF SKIN HERE... -.-
    *I then test fitted (many times actually = bend test, bend test) and tacked my mounting spots in place.
    *The sunroof is now on the car, i made ~ 1.5" welds at the aforementioned places. The rear is tricky, because of the gap (~1/16") you need to fill it in a bit.

    Remember, its thin metal, heat will deflect it. It will also chaulk up your paint. So take your time and make sure you get good welds and do as little deflecting on your roof as possible. I say this because i have a deflection right over the driver's seat.

    Last step. Seal it. Either caulking, bondo or metal fill it.

    You just removed about 40lbs from the top of the car. Oh, and make sure you remove the interior (you shouldn't have any left if you are considering this)... i imagined my new sparco seat catching on fire from welding right above it.


    -etxx
    No more e30s for me.
    88 black BMW OBDII 332is dedicated track [sold]
    88 BMW OBDII bronzit 332is [RIP 03/08]
    91 BMW 325i [sold]
    86 Corolla 'Ae86' HB 20v trd [sold]
    http://youtube.com/watch?v=pTj7Hn9v5Rs

    #2
    Excellent info, I will be doing this soon, thanks!

    Build, break, repair, repeat.
    91 300zx TT
    03 540i Msport
    91 318is track
    89 Isuzu Imark/lotus 24hr Lemons car

    Originally posted by george graves
    R3v is a very different kind of forum - don't come here with your bull shit - we'll actually take the time to call you on it.

    Comment


      #3
      A couple of the SpecE30 types have also elected to skin their sunroof and it ended up looking very nice. It's tricky to do tho. The entire effort is a little tricky. Cutting the sunroof cassette out isn't the easiest thing in the world. There's just a lot of ways for this to go wrong so you have to procede carefully.

      When you remove the cassette, don't cut thru the B piller, and watch out that it doesn't droop down and put too much force on the roof near the A pillar. There's some spot welds there and if the cassette is allowed to droop it will bend the roof.

      If you use a grinder, cover the inside of the windows or the hot metal spray will screw them up. Which is what I did.

      Skinning the sunroof itself, without damaging it, takes some careful work.

      Welding the skinned sunroof to the roof (or anything else to the roof) without hosing the paint has to be pretty dicey. Most folks just slapped a piece of sheetmetal on top, riveted it to the roof and called it a day.
      www.Gress.org

      All that is necessary for the triumph of evil, is for good men to do nothing. -E. Burke

      NASA SpecE30 #6, BMWCCA #161
      sigpic

      Comment


        #4
        ^^ i believe i've read a couple posts from you across boards on this topic... and i also think i've met you at RRR in darkside events... hmm

        It all depends on the person doing it. I used the biggest, badass metal grinder i have with a cutoff disk for skinning the sunroof. I was able to trace even the turns tightly and i hardly scarched the inside sunroff skin.

        Used the same grinder for removing the cassette/frame. I was too lazy to drill out most spot welds (specially the 5 front and 2 side ones) so i just cut it off about 1/2" down from the top. I only drilled the b-pillar ones which i agree, be careful!

        I'm sealing it as we speak. It looks hella nice.


        on another side of things. driving with no sunroof and no cassette/frame, you're asking to bend the roof . Between 55-65mph the roof flapped like a flag in the wing. It shook my car so bad i though i'd blown my diff or both rear tires. Above it aerodynamics keep it from doing this. I experienced no damage, bends or anything though. I thought i'd document this for r3v purposes.

        Happy Moddin,

        -etxx
        No more e30s for me.
        88 black BMW OBDII 332is dedicated track [sold]
        88 BMW OBDII bronzit 332is [RIP 03/08]
        91 BMW 325i [sold]
        86 Corolla 'Ae86' HB 20v trd [sold]
        http://youtube.com/watch?v=pTj7Hn9v5Rs

        Comment


          #5
          Good job on getting that done! I guess this just makes the slick top cars just a little better for this purpose alone ;)
          Mtech1 v8 build thread - https://www.r3vlimited.com/board/sho...d.php?t=413205



          OEM v8 manual chip or dme - https://www.r3vlimited.com/board/sho....php?p=4938827

          Comment


            #6
            I gutted my sunroof already, and rivetted sheet metal to cover the hole :) It works, it's just a bit ugly. I want to take the sunroof tray out. Before I take it out, is the tray and cassette/frame the same thing?

            My sunroof is already noisey, I need to find a way to reinforce the center so it doesn't shake. lol. How would I go about reinforceing the tray/cassette/frame so it doesn't get anymore noisey?
            I got a fender roller now! LMK if you need me to roll your fenders or want to rent the tool from me locally.

            Paypal: vdang5@gmail.com

            Delta Auto Care
            2875-C Towerview Road
            Herndon, VA
            703.435.1375

            My Feedback Thread: Evil_Twin

            Comment


              #7
              Also, could plasma cut the cassette/frame/tray out so that way you can keep some reinfocement in the roof?
              I got a fender roller now! LMK if you need me to roll your fenders or want to rent the tool from me locally.

              Paypal: vdang5@gmail.com

              Delta Auto Care
              2875-C Towerview Road
              Herndon, VA
              703.435.1375

              My Feedback Thread: Evil_Twin

              Comment


                #8
                Great writeup thanks. Im a bit confused. If the stock pannel weighs 13ish and the skin is 6, then then it is about a 7 lb savings. But then at the end of the writeup you say that you have removed 40 lbs. What am i missing?

                Also, do you know if the composite sunroofs have the same flapping issues as the modified oem unit?

                Once again thanks for the writeup, Im looking forward to doing this.
                My LS1 swap thread:
                http://www.r3vlimited.com/board/showthread.php?t=160030

                Comment


                  #9
                  Originally posted by Blip Bavarian View Post
                  Great writeup thanks. Im a bit confused. If the stock pannel weighs 13ish and the skin is 6, then then it is about a 7 lb savings. But then at the end of the writeup you say that you have removed 40 lbs. What am i missing?

                  Also, do you know if the composite sunroofs have the same flapping issues as the modified oem unit?

                  Once again thanks for the writeup, Im looking forward to doing this.
                  You forget he removed the whole cassette that the sunroof rides in as well.
                  '89 325i track sloot
                  '01 530i daily

                  -Enginerd

                  Comment


                    #10
                    i gotta take some pics of what i did, man it looks good. I welded the skin in place. Bondo'd it flush and spray painted it. I also tracked it this weekend, reached into the 130s mph, no flappin as some of you worried.
                    Originally posted by Blip Bavarian View Post
                    Great writeup thanks. Im a bit confused. If the stock pannel weighs 13ish and the skin is 6, then then it is about a 7 lb savings. But then at the end of the writeup you say that you have removed 40 lbs. What am i missing?

                    Also, do you know if the composite sunroofs have the same flapping issues as the modified oem unit?

                    Once again thanks for the writeup, Im looking forward to doing this.
                    as stated above, the cassette/frame/sunroof motor/sunroof components etc is where the weight savings are at. I do not get wind flapping with the modified unit though. I used to, without a sunroof in place the roof line is basically a huge flap open to wind force.

                    good luck and happy moddin!
                    Originally posted by evil_twin View Post
                    Also, could plasma cut the cassette/frame/tray out so that way you can keep some reinfocement in the roof?
                    sure. i doubt that structurally that frame provides any benefits. The riveted solution you mention is pretty ugly, but the spec e30 guys do it all day long. Lastly, skinning the sunroof and maintaining the cassette/frame/tray is a waste of effort IMO ; /
                    No more e30s for me.
                    88 black BMW OBDII 332is dedicated track [sold]
                    88 BMW OBDII bronzit 332is [RIP 03/08]
                    91 BMW 325i [sold]
                    86 Corolla 'Ae86' HB 20v trd [sold]
                    http://youtube.com/watch?v=pTj7Hn9v5Rs

                    Comment


                      #11
                      One trick that we've found that helps is to use a small piece of round steel bar (really small, like 1/8", maybe 3/16" diameter)- take the bar and carefully bend it around the perimeter of the roof panel, tack weld it in place, THEN install the whole thing into the hole in the roof and carefully tack it into place. This really helps fill the gap between the roof panel + the roof itself that is made worse by removing the rubber weatherstrip around the panel.

                      We've done a couple of E30 sunroofs, and this makes the best fit of any other method we tried. The only downside is that you will burn some paint, but that's almost impossible to avoid using any method.

                      Comment


                        #12
                        Time to pull the tray down then :)
                        I got a fender roller now! LMK if you need me to roll your fenders or want to rent the tool from me locally.

                        Paypal: vdang5@gmail.com

                        Delta Auto Care
                        2875-C Towerview Road
                        Herndon, VA
                        703.435.1375

                        My Feedback Thread: Evil_Twin

                        Comment


                          #13
                          Originally posted by Rigmaster View Post
                          One trick that we've found that helps is to use a small piece of round steel bar (really small, like 1/8", maybe 3/16" diameter)- take the bar and carefully bend it around the perimeter of the roof panel, tack weld it in place, THEN install the whole thing into the hole in the roof and carefully tack it into place. This really helps fill the gap between the roof panel + the roof itself that is made worse by removing the rubber weatherstrip around the panel.

                          We've done a couple of E30 sunroofs, and this makes the best fit of any other method we tried. The only downside is that you will burn some paint, but that's almost impossible to avoid using any method.
                          well, the left over tab that held the sunroof frame in place itself can be bent outwards(inwards) and make this frame that you're talking about. That is exactly how my sunroof is held in place. It took a good amount of time to get the sunroof to sit right. then i tacked in place. Once tacked i made a couple 1" welds (3x front, 2x sides (2), 2 rear). Filled it with bondo to bled the sunroof into the roof and voila. I should post pics ; /
                          No more e30s for me.
                          88 black BMW OBDII 332is dedicated track [sold]
                          88 BMW OBDII bronzit 332is [RIP 03/08]
                          91 BMW 325i [sold]
                          86 Corolla 'Ae86' HB 20v trd [sold]
                          http://youtube.com/watch?v=pTj7Hn9v5Rs

                          Comment


                            #14
                            Originally posted by etxxz View Post
                            i should post pics
                            +1
                            My LS1 swap thread:
                            http://www.r3vlimited.com/board/showthread.php?t=160030

                            Comment

                            Working...
                            X