Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

my 24v build, slightly different than the norm. Now with dyno numbers!

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    A little premature 1 year update. Ive successfully put 24k miles on this thing and I honestly can say now that it was all worth it. When the deadlines werent met, I bitched like a spoiled child, but once I let go of the situation and let it work itself out, I now have reaped the benefits and have enjoyed the car. I have had a few issues, but most could've been prevented up front:

    -Fan issue couldve been prevented if I used a Spal from the beginning

    -Blew an ignition coil and subsequently the coil driver (might've been t he other way around though??). This probably couldve been avoided if I had bought new coils when I built my new engine. Either way, 1 new ignition coil and a new ECU and that was fixed

    -VANOs is making the typical rattling noise. This was something I overlooked while I was building the engine. Would've and should've done it while the engine was apart, but will be fixed soon.

    Other than that, I love this setup. My cars power/ weight ratio is awesome (2450lbs will full interior, full tank, 12" lukebox, etc) and I am constantly embarrassing a lot of newer cars with WAY more power than mine.

    I hope to report back in a year with more miles and more smiles.

    Peace

    -Simon




    Last edited by 2mAn; 05-06-2015, 12:01 PM.
    Simon
    Current Cars:
    -1999 996.1 911 4/98 3.8L 6-Speed, 21st Century Beetle

    Make R3V Great Again -2020

    Comment


      I had the same dips in power. After hooking up the VSS they were gone. Try resetting your Ecu and see if they disappear. Probably a VANOS related issue.

      Comment


        Just read the entire thread... Wow, you went through a lot! good job on keeping faith!

        I'm presently looking at the possibility of an aluminium 24v. still debating. But the story you went through is guiding me to just droping a complete good running engine...
        E30 now S52
        2008 Suburban LTZ (Family and TT hauler)
        325xiT (Sold)

        sigpic

        Comment


          This isnt the exact same motor, but heres your chance to get both goals done

          Simon
          Current Cars:
          -1999 996.1 911 4/98 3.8L 6-Speed, 21st Century Beetle

          Make R3V Great Again -2020

          Comment


            Thanks for the ongoing updates OP, it's really great to see feedback from someone who's battled through this process successfully, as well as reading your reflections now that you've put some mileage into the motor :up:

            I was hoping you might remember some of the details on the timesert-ing process;

            I've been considering this process for my N/A aluminium M52B30 build, but I've been seeing a fair bit of conflicting info in terms of timesert type to use, and the compatibility with ARP studs - what combo did you use?

            ARP's own website only shows cylinder head kits for the iron blocks, nothing for the Euro M52 (alu).
            And my understanding was that those ARP studs are too long for the threads created by the timeserts, when installed in the alu blocks


            Originally posted by 2mAn View Post
            ok so I spent the last two days working on the engine. yesterday I spent drilling and timesert-ing the block, then today my goal was to get the head and oil pan on so it looked like a long block, more or less...

            my timesert setup.


            Last edited by NufnSus; 09-22-2016, 09:20 PM.

            Comment


              Originally posted by NufnSus View Post
              Thanks for the ongoing updates OP, it's really great to see feedback from someone who's battled through this process successfully, as well as reading your reflections now that you've put some mileage into the motor :thumbsup

              I was hoping you might remember some of the details on the timesert-ing process;

              I've been considering this process for my N/A aluminium M52B30 build, but I've been seeing a fair bit of conflicting info in terms of timesert type to use, and the compatibility with ARP studs - what combo did you use?

              ARP's own website only shows cylinder head kits for the iron blocks, nothing for the Euro M52 (alu).
              And my understanding was that those ARP studs are too long for the threads created by the timeserts, when installed in the alu blocks
              Why do you need ARP's for NA engine. Or even the timeserts if the threads are fine? The stock bolts are fine even in mild boosted engines.

              Comment


                Originally posted by pazi88 View Post
                Why do you need ARP's for NA engine. Or even the timeserts if the threads are fine? The stock bolts are fine even in mild boosted engines.
                I don't know the history/ mileage of the block, and from what I've read, stripping threads is possible if the alloy has softened due to excess heat cycles. Seems like a worthwhile 'while I'm in there' job...
                Plus supposed possibility of using ARP bolts, which can be re-used

                Comment


                  I'd skip the ARP stuff personally unless you're building some turbo monster you should just use an iron block.

                  Time-serts, on the other hand, serve a real purpose on the aluminum block motor. My mechanic told me it was a factory recommended repair when removing the head on a high mileage motor. The concern was behind torquing down a head on an aluminum block that it might pull the threads rather than stretch the bolts.

                  Your results may vary, but I had a motor with an unknown history so I chose the insurance policy of doing them.
                  Last edited by 2mAn; 09-15-2016, 09:25 AM.
                  Simon
                  Current Cars:
                  -1999 996.1 911 4/98 3.8L 6-Speed, 21st Century Beetle

                  Make R3V Great Again -2020

                  Comment


                    Originally posted by 2mAn View Post
                    I'd skip the ARP stuff personally unless you're building some turbo monster you should just use an iron block.

                    Time-serts, on the other hand, serve a real purpose on the aluminum block motor. My mechanic told me it was a factory recommended repair when removing the head on a high mileage motor. The concern was behind torquing down a head on an aluminum block that it might pull the threads rather than stretch the bolts.

                    Your results may vary, but I had a motor with an unknown history so I chose the insurance policy of doing them.
                    I agree. Don't use ARP or any other non-stretching bolts with alu-block. if you have to, use iron block.

                    But I have experience on several alu-blocks and if the threads look fine, there is no need for timeserting. But for example if you see aluminium in the head bolt threads when you remove them or strange corrosion in the threads in block, then you need to timesert them.

                    But If you need to timesert the threads I have video showing how you can do it without buying that ridiculously priced thread repair set for m52 engine:

                    Comment


                      Don't do ARPs. I would timecert though. If the motor has ever gotten hot at all the threads will pull on the 3rd torque stage and then you have to pull the head back off and timecert anyway.

                      Check Us out on Facebook
                      Needing a harness adapter or wiring help? Check it out: also have 24v motor mounts, E30 M3 covers and E36 ECU mounts!
                      Full Product Line Tuning
                      OBD2 Tuning Available! OBD2 E36, S54 Swap, S62 Swap, etc: tuning@MarkertMotorWorks.com Dyno Thread

                      Comment


                        Originally posted by pazi88 View Post
                        I agree. Don't use ARP or any other non-stretching bolts with alu-block. if you have to, use iron block.
                        One certainly *CAN* use ARP's in an aluminum engine... they just need to be used with the right torque sequence.

                        What *will* result in disaster is using a factory torquing sequence when either bolt or head gasket material is significantly different than stock.
                        E.g.'s: replacing aluminum bolts with steel OR replacing a composition head gasket with MLS.

                        Comment

                        Working...
                        X