Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Which tranny would u use ??

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Which tranny would u use ??

    M50 is ready to go in my 91' 318i ..I have a good e36 tranns(or at least I hope so) and i have the 240 getrag from the 318i ..which one would you guys go with and why....will the stock driveshafts work with the 240 getrag??,but then the shifter wont line up correctly huh!!...OR go with e36 250 getrag? the shifter will line up ,but not sure about driveshaft. :???:

    ...any help,thoughts
    NASA
    BMWCCA member
    PCA member 25yrs




    1991 318IS slick top
    1997 M3 sedan
    2001 325CI DD

    “whoever turns the wheel the least, wins"

    #2
    use the e36 tranny and e36 driveshaft. it works perfectly. thats whats in my car.

    Comment


      #3
      Originally posted by mrhinton View Post
      use the e36 tranny and e36 driveshaft. it works perfectly. thats whats in my car.
      yes, just make sure you use the csb from your year e30 on the e36 ds
      ______________________
      ex-Chief Operating Officer
      Blunt Tech Industries
      West Coast and Pacific Rim

      Comment


        #4
        Originally posted by mrhinton View Post
        use the e36 tranny and e36 driveshaft. it works perfectly. thats whats in my car.

        thats what I was leaning towards! I have the e36 drive shafts but they are not the best of shape..i can find more

        ..so what flywheel did you end up useing..... M20? starter??
        NASA
        BMWCCA member
        PCA member 25yrs




        1991 318IS slick top
        1997 M3 sedan
        2001 325CI DD

        “whoever turns the wheel the least, wins"

        Comment


          #5
          im useing a getrag 240 + e36 2door driveshaft... ive been rapping it for a 1 3/4 of a year and no problems...

          Comment


            #6
            what clutch package did you use with the 240/
            NASA
            BMWCCA member
            PCA member 25yrs




            1991 318IS slick top
            1997 M3 sedan
            2001 325CI DD

            “whoever turns the wheel the least, wins"

            Comment


              #7
              He used an M20 flywheel and clutch.
              BimmerHeads
              Classic BMW Specialists
              Santa Clarita, CA

              www.BimmerHeads.com

              Comment


                #8
                I use the G240, no problems as of yet.

                It'sprobably one of the easier trannys to use if you're not going FI or any power over about 250 crank hp.

                Benefit is you get to keep your stock ratios, you already have the tranny and mounts, you just need a shift linkage, DS, CSB, and clutch setup.

                Sam
                1985 325e 2.8 Turbo VEMS

                Comment


                  #9
                  Originally posted by SamE30e View Post
                  I use the G240, no problems as of yet.

                  It'sprobably one of the easier trannys to use if you're not going FI or any power over about 250 crank hp.

                  Benefit is you get to keep your stock ratios, you already have the tranny and mounts, you just need a shift linkage, DS, CSB, and clutch setup.

                  Sam
                  stock tranny and mounts work w/ the 250 too. The 250 is stronger and was made for the motor. Which do you think you should use?
                  ///Alpinweiß II 24v 91' 318is, Alpinweiß III 99' 323i, 04' Yamaha R6 SE for sale, 00' VW GTi, 83' El Camino BURNED, 01' P71sold, 92' Miatasold

                  Comment


                    #10
                    Originally posted by SamE30e View Post

                    It'sprobably one of the easier trannys to use if you're not going FI or any power over about 250 crank hp.

                    Sam

                    I assume this figure was pulled completely out of your ass?

                    Comment


                      #11
                      ..both are in great shape,I was hoping to use the one that is the easiest (and cheapest)..I assume the 240's linkage will be 10-15% askew ! and the 250 should bolt up with the shifter staright ..... I also take it that both can use the m20 flywheel!??
                      NASA
                      BMWCCA member
                      PCA member 25yrs




                      1991 318IS slick top
                      1997 M3 sedan
                      2001 325CI DD

                      “whoever turns the wheel the least, wins"

                      Comment


                        #12
                        Originally posted by e30s50dan View Post
                        ..both are in great shape,I was hoping to use the one that is the easiest (and cheapest)..I assume the 240's linkage will be 10-15% askew ! and the 250 should bolt up with the shifter staright ..... I also take it that both can use the m20 flywheel!??
                        Ok, I am tired and need to be up in 5hrs. but here goes:

                        The 240 and 250 are pretty much identical on the outside. They mount the same and you need to use the same linkage with both of them. The difference lies within the transmission strength and gear ratios.

                        240 = Over-driven tranny (.81 5th)
                        250 = close-ratio/non over-driven tranny (1:1 5th)

                        When you use either one of these transmissions, you also need an E36 325i driveshaft, shift carrier and selector rod. I believe you can use E30 your 318i tranny brace, and you may even be able to use E30 325i shift console and linkage too, but I have no idea.

                        If I have to go into explaining what needs to be done to fit the Getrag 260, I am going to recommond you sell your E30 and buy a honda.

                        Hth.
                        Originally posted by BillBrasky
                        E36's are the Stephen Baldwin of the 3 series family. They barely hold everything together and they only sold a lot because of the popularity of their older sibling.
                        1991 318i Alpine II - S50/5-lug swapped - track car
                        1989 325i Cirrusblau - Daily
                        1970 2500 - Malaga over Grey Cloth
                        2012 F350 6.7PSD

                        Comment


                          #13
                          Originally posted by BenM View Post
                          Ok, I am tired and need to be up in 5hrs. but here goes:

                          The 240 and 250 are pretty much identical on the outside. They mount the same and you need to use the same linkage with both of them. The difference lies within the transmission strength and gear ratios.

                          240 = Over-driven tranny (.81 5th)
                          250 = close-ratio/non over-driven tranny (1:1 5th)

                          When you use either one of these transmissions, you also need an E36 325i driveshaft, shift carrier and selector rod. I believe you can use E30 your 318i tranny brace, and you may even be able to use E30 325i shift console and linkage too, but I have no idea.

                          If I have to go into explaining what needs to be done to fit the Getrag 260, I am going to recommond you sell your E30 and buy a honda.

                          Hth.

                          how the hell you can say that the 240 and 250 are identical from the outside..they look completely different ..anyone can tell that from 50ft away
                          NASA
                          BMWCCA member
                          PCA member 25yrs




                          1991 318IS slick top
                          1997 M3 sedan
                          2001 325CI DD

                          “whoever turns the wheel the least, wins"

                          Comment


                            #14
                            Originally posted by BenM View Post
                            Ok, I am tired and need to be up in 5hrs. but here goes:

                            The 240 and 250 are pretty much identical on the outside. They mount the same and you need to use the same linkage with both of them. The difference lies within the transmission strength and gear ratios.

                            240 = Over-driven tranny (.81 5th)
                            250 = close-ratio/non over-driven tranny (1:1 5th)

                            When you use either one of these transmissions, you also need an E36 325i driveshaft, shift carrier and selector rod. I believe you can use E30 your 318i tranny brace, and you may even be able to use E30 325i shift console and linkage too, but I have no idea.

                            If I have to go into explaining what needs to be done to fit the Getrag 260, I am going to recommond you sell your E30 and buy a honda.

                            Hth.
                            with the 240 trans use the e36 m3 zf shift linkage/carrier for a perfect fitment

                            Comment


                              #15
                              Originally posted by Dominic49 View Post
                              with the 240 trans use the e36 m3 zf shift linkage/carrier for a perfect fitment
                              really!! no fabrication to the shift linkage/carrier??
                              NASA
                              BMWCCA member
                              PCA member 25yrs




                              1991 318IS slick top
                              1997 M3 sedan
                              2001 325CI DD

                              “whoever turns the wheel the least, wins"

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X