S50 Valve Retainers

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Mstngcobr761
    E30 Addict
    • Apr 2008
    • 557

    #1

    S50 Valve Retainers

    Read in the thread thats stickied at the top that pre 10/95 S50s have had valve retainers have had some problems. Have any of you guys experienced it? Did you upgrade your retainers or just let it go? With my engine coming together w/ alot of money into it would hate to have these fail

    Thanks in advance
  • FredK
    R3V OG
    • Oct 2003
    • 14745

    #2
    I pulled the retainers in a 7/95 S50, and they looked fine. I replaced them with the updated pieces. I'm not sure what you've put into your engine, but if you already have the tools, replacing the top spring plates and collets costs around $150 in parts.

    I'd rather not drop a valve. The best case scenario is an HG job, and R&Ring the dropped valve and seat, if the valve doesn't hit the cylinder wall by some miracle.

    Comment

    • Mstngcobr761
      E30 Addict
      • Apr 2008
      • 557

      #3
      I can do them if its only 150 dollars I woud like to know I dont have to worry bout them

      Comment

      • lennon
        E30 Fanatic
        • Jun 2008
        • 1416

        #4
        i bought the 'updated' ones for my motor. the motor had well over 100k on it and the 'old style' hadnt failed yet, i just did it for peace of mind just like a hundred other things on the motor.

        Comment

        • Mstngcobr761
          E30 Addict
          • Apr 2008
          • 557

          #5
          Originally posted by lennon
          i bought the 'updated' ones for my motor. the motor had well over 100k on it and the 'old style' hadnt failed yet, i just did it for peace of mind just like a hundred other things on the motor.
          yea the more i get into my motor i feel like I need to do everything for peace of mind hah

          Comment

          • lennon
            E30 Fanatic
            • Jun 2008
            • 1416

            #6
            yes ive spent plenty on peace of mind. do you have a build thread? what are you doing to the s50?

            Comment

            • e30s52
              R3V Elite
              • Oct 2007
              • 5235

              #7
              Originally posted by Mstngcobr761
              Read in the thread thats stickied at the top that pre 10/95 S50s have had valve retainers have had some problems. Have any of you guys experienced it? Did you upgrade your retainers or just let it go? With my engine coming together w/ alot of money into it would hate to have these fail

              Thanks in advance

              Its 150 bucks for piece of mind. Just do them. It will be alot cheaper then dropping a valve.

              www.gutenparts.com
              One stop shopping for NEW, USED and EURO PARTS!

              Comment

              • mazur
                Mod Crazy
                • Jan 2006
                • 731

                #8
                Retainers fail catastrophically. So the people saying that they looked okay means nothing.

                Just go ahead and replace them.

                Comment

                • jrdeamicis
                  E30 Modder
                  • Nov 2008
                  • 956

                  #9
                  I replaced mine with the updated parts. I see no reason to NOT replace them.
                  Past Car : E30 S50 6 Speed 5 Lug 3.73
                  Current : Z3 S50 OBD2 (Smog Legal) 6 Speed BBS RN Dual Ear Diff
                  ___________________________________________
                  BNB Designs
                  Engine Swaps, Fabrication, Innovation, General Repair
                  Richmond CA
                  Julian 848-248-8029

                  Comment

                  • AlarmedBread
                    E30 Mastermind
                    • Sep 2006
                    • 1510

                    #10
                    Does anyone have a side by side of the two types? Easy way to identify if they are updated or not?
                    Thanks

                    Comment

                    • jrdeamicis
                      E30 Modder
                      • Nov 2008
                      • 956

                      #11
                      Originally posted by AlarmedBread
                      Does anyone have a side by side of the two types? Easy way to identify if they are updated or not?
                      Thanks
                      Not really. No.
                      Past Car : E30 S50 6 Speed 5 Lug 3.73
                      Current : Z3 S50 OBD2 (Smog Legal) 6 Speed BBS RN Dual Ear Diff
                      ___________________________________________
                      BNB Designs
                      Engine Swaps, Fabrication, Innovation, General Repair
                      Richmond CA
                      Julian 848-248-8029

                      Comment

                      • Mstngcobr761
                        E30 Addict
                        • Apr 2008
                        • 557

                        #12
                        Originally posted by jrdeamicis
                        Not really. No.
                        The part numbers remained the same too

                        Comment

                        Working...