Coding plug headaches

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Misko78
    replied
    Originally posted by Gregs///M
    Since you have the clock, you do not need one. Coding plug is for engine speed translation for the tach and mpg gauge.

    Again I'm sorry for another resurrection.

    I have E30 316i M40, previous owner installed old type VDO board which had green line tacho (Alpina maybe?) with coding plug behing it (it has 04 on it), he traded original cluster for it. It gave me nothing but troubles, tacho worked well, but i had brake warning blinking all the time, right turn light sometimes worked sometimes not, handbrake light also, jumping fuel and temperature gauges...

    My mechanic gave me for free, like new, Motometer cluster with clock, he could not remember from which car it was. It has a BMW 18 (1 385 364) coding plug. I bought new Sanyo lithium batteries, replaced them, drove like that for few weeks, everything was working like charm. But I wanted tacho so bad, and i bought beaten Motometer cluster, so i salvaged from it tacho with econometer, SI board and coding plug BMW 22 (1 394 110).

    I switched clock with tacho, and it was dead, even when i switched coding plugs. I checked SI boards and boards were different. One from clock cluster is missing two chips, dozen of resistors and one capacitor, those components where not installed by factory, nobody did a work on it. So I switched SI boards (again bought new lithiums) and now tacho+econometer works perfectly fine.

    All of that got me into repair an old VDO and i changed NiCd batteries and retraced broken traces, someone did a "blow torch" job on it, and also cluster board was full of broken solder points. Now that cluster is fully operational and now i have a spare.

    Finally the questions:

    1. Which coding plug should i use 18 or 22?
    2. Can tacho be used with SI board that has missing components. ( I want to give it to my friend but he also would like to have a tacho).
    Last edited by Misko78; 06-23-2015, 04:19 PM. Reason: typo

    Leave a comment:


  • kevpatts
    replied
    Thanks man, that's a lot of info, but I don't think it's the same problem as mine. He says that his error is proportional to his speed, and he tweaks the scaling pot ("The trim pot (potentiometer) controls a scaling factor").

    My error is 7Km/h when I'm going 20 and 120, so a scaling correction won't fix that.

    I'll have a good search for similar problems, just thought I'd mention it while you were giving me your time.

    Thanks a million for your help.

    Leave a comment:


  • Gregs///M
    replied

    Leave a comment:


  • kevpatts
    replied
    Is there any way to correct/adject this? It was accurate a year ago before it went off the road for a restoration work.

    Leave a comment:


  • Gregs///M
    replied
    Gross incorrect speed reading is probably because the speedo is not matched to the sensor in the rear differential. The k=xxxx reading at the very bottom is the calibration factor, which is associated with the sensor in the diff.

    Leave a comment:


  • Gregs///M
    replied
    5 or so MPH over the reading is normal on most BMW's.

    Leave a comment:


  • kevpatts
    replied
    Gregs,

    I love ya man! While I have your attention, one more cluster related question: My speedo always says I'm going 7Km/h faster than I'm actually going (compared to speedo app on iPhone and speed warning signs on the street). The storage thing is that it's the same 7Km/h error no matter what speed I'm going, so it's not a linear error. My old cluster always said I was doing 15Km/h more than I was doing (it was in Mph though, new one only shows Km/h), so I don't think the problem is in the cluster.

    Any ideas how to fix?

    Leave a comment:


  • Gregs///M
    replied
    1377 361 is the M10 4 cylinder coding plug. So yea you would use it if your spare tach is the original redline used on your car.

    Leave a comment:


  • kevpatts
    replied
    Okay, another question. I have a tach dial spare somewhere. If I put it in, which coding plug should I use for a 316? I found another one I have BMW01 (1377 361)

    Leave a comment:


  • Gregs///M
    replied
    Originally posted by kevpatts
    Hey, sorry to resurrect an old topic here, but this is the closest I've seen on the Internet to what I need.

    A long time ago I swapped the original cluster out of my 316 (not 316i!) with a 2nd hand one but I never swapped my original coding plug in.

    Anyway, my cluster is the 316 one with the clock instead of tach, so does it need a plug at all?

    Now I'm swapping in another new cluster and don't know which plug to use. I have BMW18 (1385 364) and BMW02 (1377 362).

    Seeing as I have no tach, does it matter? If not, why are they in there in the first place? Is it possible my original one didn't have one at all (I've seen some online without this port at all).

    Kevpatts
    Since you have the clock, you do not need one. Coding plug is for engine speed translation for the tach and mpg gauge.

    Leave a comment:


  • kevpatts
    replied
    Hey, sorry to resurrect an old topic here, but this is the closest I've seen on the Internet to what I need.

    A long time ago I swapped the original cluster out of my 316 (not 316i!) with a 2nd hand one but I never swapped my original coding plug in.

    Anyway, my cluster is the 316 one with the clock instead of tach, so does it need a plug at all?

    Now I'm swapping in another new cluster and don't know which plug to use. I have BMW18 (1385 364) and BMW02 (1377 362).

    Seeing as I have no tach, does it matter? If not, why are they in there in the first place? Is it possible my original one didn't have one at all (I've seen some online without this port at all).

    Kevpatts

    Leave a comment:


  • Gregs///M
    replied
    Gregg,

    Since the speed works and the odometer does not, you can assume that the problem lies in the cluster itself. I assume you have newer odometer gears. Try loosening the plastic cover plate over the gears, when those two screws are tightened too much, it will prevent the odo gears from turning. If you never replaced the gears, definitely the problem. I have the gears in stock.

    Your tach problems could be coding plug related but I rarely see coding plugs fail. However, its not impossible. Also, the "nicks" on the coding plug do look intentional. Damaged main cluster board could also be a culprit.

    If you want to pull the cluster and drop it off at my place sometime, I'll take a look at it for you. I have tons of spare coding plugs that I can swap out and let you have. I can get the cluster working, or at least find exactly what is wrong with it.

    You can see my new cluster tester in action!

    Greg

    Leave a comment:


  • jlevie
    replied
    The issues you have will be caused by a bad speedometer and a bad tachometer. A bad SI board could render the tach inop and a bad coding plug could result in an inop tach or one that display correct engine speed.

    Leave a comment:


  • Spyke
    replied
    Wouldn't a problem with the input result in no signal? Tach being stuck at 2000 RPM seems like far too specific of a problem. [With the coding plug removed, the tach reads zero, and there's no movement on the econometer]

    Speedometer works, the odometer is stuck. I have been told repeatedly that the odometer and tach issues I have are linked to one of the three following:

    1) SI board - refurbished and checks out
    2) Coding plug - ???
    3) Cluster ground - confirmed good
    Last edited by Spyke; 09-14-2013, 03:01 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • AndrewBird
    replied
    First off, the tach and speedo are completely separate units. One not working has nothing to do with the other not working. The coding plug has nothing to do with the speedo.

    The tach stuck at 2000 rpm sounds a like a short somewhere on the tach input wire.

    The speedo not working could be a bad sensor in the diff or broken wires near the sensor. The wires often get brittle and break.

    Leave a comment:

Working...