Intermittent Check Engine Light and Rough Idle

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • e46s54dr
    E30 Enthusiast
    • May 2008
    • 1059

    #1

    Intermittent Check Engine Light and Rough Idle

    My car has been acting up on occassion but it isn't too bad. I'd like to get her to run perfectly if I can. Any help would be deeply appreciated!

    1st Problem: Engine runs a little rough with sporatic idle on cold start ups. Once the engine warms up, all symptoms dissappear. I recently replaced the coolant tempeture sensor and it felt a smidge smoother, but my CEL is lit at idle

    2nd Problem: When I'm cruising on the freeway or any road where I'm at a constant speed/rpm, my CEL will be on. As soon as I give her more gas or let off on the throttle the CEL turns off.

    My guess is that the two problems are connected in some way but I'm not 100 percent positive.

    P.S. Will a small vacuum leak from the idle control valve boot cause the said symptoms?
  • ak-
    R3V OG
    • May 2009
    • 12422

    #2
    I have the same problem. I'm just living with it for now.

    1991 325iS turbo

    Comment

    • e46s54dr
      E30 Enthusiast
      • May 2008
      • 1059

      #3
      Yeah, it really doesn't bug me too much but it wouldn't hurt to see if anyone had the same problem and have a solution.

      Comment

      • Desaevious
        No R3VLimiter
        • Aug 2007
        • 3810

        #4
        Same as you two, subscribed, lol. I popped in a new thermostat and flushed the coolant to see if that was the cause and since I had no idea when the last thermostat was installed so it was a simple task. I'm thinking it might be some type of air intake issue?

        SC*AR (Schwarz Army)
        No longer stock ride height, rolling as low as a daily driver in New England should without worrying about breaking an oil pan. :up:

        Comment

        • e46s54dr
          E30 Enthusiast
          • May 2008
          • 1059

          #5
          Originally posted by Desaevious
          Same as you two, subscribed, lol. I popped in a new thermostat and flushed the coolant to see if that was the cause and since I had no idea when the last thermostat was installed so it was a simple task. I'm thinking it might be some type of air intake issue?
          When I had my car smogged, it passed with flying colors. I asked the mechanic what he thought about my symptoms and he said that it was most likely a vacuum leak somewhere. It just kinda sucks that the cel doesn't stay on so I can extract the code to give me some sense of direction.

          Comment

          • Desaevious
            No R3VLimiter
            • Aug 2007
            • 3810

            #6
            Originally posted by e46s54dr
            When I had my car smogged, it passed with flying colors. I asked the mechanic what he thought about my symptoms and he said that it was most likely a vacuum leak somewhere. It just kinda sucks that the cel doesn't stay on so I can extract the code to give me some sense of direction.
            Yeah the sniffer has my emissions as being good too. So then vaccum leak maybe? Issue with the idle control valve?

            SC*AR (Schwarz Army)
            No longer stock ride height, rolling as low as a daily driver in New England should without worrying about breaking an oil pan. :up:

            Comment

            • Danny
              Moderator
              • Feb 2008
              • 14217

              #7
              O2 sensor.

              Comment

              • e46s54dr
                E30 Enthusiast
                • May 2008
                • 1059

                #8
                It's not the o2 sensor in my case. Mine is brand new and I have an oem low mileage cat.

                Comment

                • e46s54dr
                  E30 Enthusiast
                  • May 2008
                  • 1059

                  #9
                  Originally posted by Desaevious
                  Yeah the sniffer has my emissions as being good too. So then vaccum leak maybe? Issue with the idle control valve?
                  I plan on swapping out my icv and resealing the known leak and any other vacuum leaks I can find sometime this week. I'll update if I see any results.

                  Comment

                  • Desaevious
                    No R3VLimiter
                    • Aug 2007
                    • 3810

                    #10
                    Originally posted by e46s54dr
                    I plan on swapping out my icv and resealing the known leak and any other vacuum leaks I can find sometime this week. I'll update if I see any results.
                    Cool. Its something I'd like to monkey around with but its not a "need to do" thing as you know. With it being my only car, embarking on even the smallest of projects on what I need to drive to work and school aren't gonna be done if they won't promise results. Let us know man!

                    SC*AR (Schwarz Army)
                    No longer stock ride height, rolling as low as a daily driver in New England should without worrying about breaking an oil pan. :up:

                    Comment

                    • Danny
                      Moderator
                      • Feb 2008
                      • 14217

                      #11
                      What motor is it?

                      Comment

                      • ak-
                        R3V OG
                        • May 2009
                        • 12422

                        #12
                        I replaced the icv, and it helped a shit ton. Not 100% still though.
                        Before the icv though, I would have to be and a constant heel-toe at stop lights to prevent my car from shutting off most of the time.

                        1991 325iS turbo

                        Comment

                        • e46s54dr
                          E30 Enthusiast
                          • May 2008
                          • 1059

                          #13
                          Originally posted by Danny
                          What motor is it?
                          Oops, totally forgot to mention it was a m20b25.

                          Comment

                          • N2MYE30
                            R3V Elite
                            • Oct 2007
                            • 5536

                            #14
                            This kinda happened to me this weekend.

                            1) I didnt drive the car for 8 days
                            2) then took a 30 mile highway drive on a near empty tank but knew I could get to my destination
                            3) After ~5 miles the CEL light comes on but goes off after I let ease off the gas
                            4) ~25 miles into the trip the light stays on no matter what
                            5) I pull into a gas station looking for my stomp test instructions but in another car (one of the negatives of having too many cars)
                            6) I filled up the car and the CEL was still on and drove away since I had no other choice and the car still ran normal...a bit of a rough idle but not bad.
                            7) 2 miles down the road the CEL goes off
                            8 ) I got to my destination and drove back 30 miles with no CEL light on.

                            Bad gas? I dunno.
                            O2 Sensor? maybe but the sensor could be detecting something legit...but what?

                            COTM

                            Comment

                            • e46s54dr
                              E30 Enthusiast
                              • May 2008
                              • 1059

                              #15
                              Definitely very odd. I wonder if my fuel pump might be the culprit. It's just a shot in the dark but im going to change it out for a new one since it's never been changed to the best oh knowledge. I'm glad that I'm not the only one expiriencing these crazy symptoms. I'll work ony car this weekend and let you guys know how things go.

                              Originally posted by N2MYE30
                              This kinda happened to me this weekend.

                              1) I didnt drive the car for 8 days
                              2) then took a 30 mile highway drive on a near empty tank but knew I could get to my destination
                              3) After ~5 miles the CEL light comes on but goes off after I let ease off the gas
                              4) ~25 miles into the trip the light stays on no matter what
                              5) I pull into a gas station looking for my stomp test instructions but in another car (one of the negatives of having too many cars)
                              6) I filled up the car and the CEL was still on and drove away since I had no other choice and the car still ran normal...a bit of a rough idle but not bad.
                              7) 2 miles down the road the CEL goes off
                              8 ) I got to my destination and drove back 30 miles with no CEL light on.

                              Bad gas? I dunno.
                              O2 Sensor? maybe but the sensor could be detecting something legit...but what?

                              Comment

                              Working...