Possibly odd wheel fitment/spacer question...

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Jand3rson
    Banned
    • Oct 2003
    • 37587

    #1

    Possibly odd wheel fitment/spacer question...

    Ok, so I've got Apex ARC-8s, which are direct E30 fitment. I wanted to push them out a bit in the rear, so Andrew (who is a machinist) made me a set of 10mm spacers. I should note that I also have a stud conversion, shown in the pic below.

    So here's what we're looking at, the rear hub with the spacer mounted, and the backside of the Apex wheel.



    The spacer only leaves just a hair of hub sticking out, about 1/4" or so. The centerbore of the spacer is perfect, fits nice and snug around the hub, I had to kind of smack them on. I bolted the wheels to the car/torqued them down with the wheels off the ground, and with a few short drives up to about 50-60 mph, I felt no vibrations at all. So I'm pretty confident that the wheels are being held straight to the hub. In fact, I think in the pic, that the spacer isn't even actually sitting totally flush against the face of the hub.

    For peace of mind and a little extra "proper fit/centering", I'm wondering if it's possible, or if anyone makes a hub centering ring that will fit the E30 hub, and fit into the flanged-area of the female part of the wheel, shown in the bottom pic. I'd be willing to bet that the amount of hub still sticking past the spacer, and the height of that flanged-area on the wheel hub are pretty damn close, if not the same. It would be nice to have something just to fill the gap.

    Or, and I just overthinking this, like I have a tendency to do with just about everything on my car.
  • acolella76
    R3VLimited
    • Apr 2010
    • 2950

    #2
    This is why most spacers over 8mm thick have hub-centric rings on them. a la:


    Looks like you're now in the market for some hub extenders. Unfortunately, not many people (if any) make them in E30 fitment.
    -Alex

    Comment

    • Todd Black 88
      No R3VLimiter
      • Oct 2007
      • 3449

      #3
      You need hub centric 10mm spacers, or hub extenders as said above.

      Turner sells extenders for 72.6mm, maybe the sell them in e30 size. Or, have your machinist friend make some up.
      Originally posted by codyep3
      I hope to Christ you have looks going for you, because you sure as fuck don't have any intelligence.
      2001 silver/Blk 325 cabby. SOLD
      1988 Blk/Blk e30 factory wide body kit car SOLD
      1992 DS/BLK 325 m-tech II apperance pack cabby SOLD!
      2002 325xit Sil/blk. SOLD
      2012 328i xdrive touring. Wht/blk. SOLD
      2009 135 cabby. monacoblue/blk leather SOLD
      2007 Z4m coupe. Silver grey/black/ aluminum. 1of50
      2010 F650gs twin
      2016 M235i cabby. Mineral grey/Red leather

      Comment

      • Jand3rson
        Banned
        • Oct 2003
        • 37587

        #4
        Originally posted by Todd Black 88
        Or, have your machinist friend make some up.
        That was my first idea, but he's unsure about getting the measurement correct, to meet the angle of hole in the wheel. It would have to be exact, because too small, and they wouldn't be doing anything. Too large, and there would be a gap.

        Comment

        • bmwguy325is
          E30 Fanatic
          • May 2011
          • 1262

          #5
          I have put 80k plus miles on a set up just like yours. Studs and spacers. Things are good no shakes or anything.
          sigpic"If one does not fail at times, then one has not challenged himself." -Ferdinand Porsche
          The ugly car: http://www.r3vlimited.com/board/showthread.php?t=209713

          Comment

          • MR 325
            Moderator
            • Oct 2003
            • 37827

            #6
            I was thinking about spacing mine out too. I had 12-15mm in mind for the rear though. What do you think josh?
            BimmerHeads
            Classic BMW Specialists
            Santa Clarita, CA

            www.BimmerHeads.com

            Comment

            • acolella76
              R3VLimited
              • Apr 2010
              • 2950

              #7
              Originally posted by Hugo Stiglitz
              That was my first idea, but he's unsure about getting the measurement correct, to meet the angle of hole in the wheel. It would have to be exact, because too small, and they wouldn't be doing anything. Too large, and there would be a gap.
              No need to bevel the hub extender. Just look at other hub extenders and make the same thing in a 57.1mm diameter. You are really over thinking the whole situation.
              -Alex

              Comment

              • LJ851
                R3V OG
                • Nov 2010
                • 7918

                #8
                Originally posted by acolella76
                No need to bevel the hub extender. Just look at other hub extenders and make the same thing in a 57.1mm diameter. You are really over thinking the whole situation.

                That's the truth!

                Do what Alex says, he is correct.
                Lorin


                Originally posted by slammin.e28
                The M30 is God's engine.

                Comment

                • Todd Black 88
                  No R3VLimiter
                  • Oct 2007
                  • 3449

                  #9
                  Originally posted by Hugo Stiglitz
                  That was my first idea, but he's unsure about getting the measurement correct, to meet the angle of hole in the wheel. It would have to be exact, because too small, and they wouldn't be doing anything. Too large, and there would be a gap.
                  No, no need to "fit" them to the wheel. I made some up for my m3 when I was running style 5's. I had to run 5mm spacers up front to clear the caliper clips with fresh pads, but with the back side of the wheel the same as your wheels, it let me with no hub lip left to center the wheel.

                  I used some thick aluminum piping with an OD a little larger then my hub OD. Turned the OD down to match exactly. Turned one end down to match the inner diameter of the front hub, with a tight,tap in fit. Cut it to length(thickness of the spacer I used 5mm). Turned the inside of the outer side down just enough to hammer in some large GM frost plugs as end caps. Done.
                  Originally posted by codyep3
                  I hope to Christ you have looks going for you, because you sure as fuck don't have any intelligence.
                  2001 silver/Blk 325 cabby. SOLD
                  1988 Blk/Blk e30 factory wide body kit car SOLD
                  1992 DS/BLK 325 m-tech II apperance pack cabby SOLD!
                  2002 325xit Sil/blk. SOLD
                  2012 328i xdrive touring. Wht/blk. SOLD
                  2009 135 cabby. monacoblue/blk leather SOLD
                  2007 Z4m coupe. Silver grey/black/ aluminum. 1of50
                  2010 F650gs twin
                  2016 M235i cabby. Mineral grey/Red leather

                  Comment

                  • einstein57
                    R3V OG
                    • Jun 2007
                    • 10780

                    #10
                    They are pretty cheap on ebay.



                    I sent the company who machines my coilover sleeves and asked them about making me hub centric spacers
                    Last edited by einstein57; 02-15-2013, 09:32 AM.
                    Your signature picture has been removed since it contained the Photobucket "upgrade your account" image.

                    www.gecoils.com
                    My euro 316 project Transaction Feedback

                    Comment

                    • Todd Black 88
                      No R3VLimiter
                      • Oct 2007
                      • 3449

                      #11
                      Yep, only issue is it's not possible to make hub centric spacers under 10mm due to the length of the regular hub. That's where hub extensions come in to play.
                      Originally posted by codyep3
                      I hope to Christ you have looks going for you, because you sure as fuck don't have any intelligence.
                      2001 silver/Blk 325 cabby. SOLD
                      1988 Blk/Blk e30 factory wide body kit car SOLD
                      1992 DS/BLK 325 m-tech II apperance pack cabby SOLD!
                      2002 325xit Sil/blk. SOLD
                      2012 328i xdrive touring. Wht/blk. SOLD
                      2009 135 cabby. monacoblue/blk leather SOLD
                      2007 Z4m coupe. Silver grey/black/ aluminum. 1of50
                      2010 F650gs twin
                      2016 M235i cabby. Mineral grey/Red leather

                      Comment

                      • AndrewBird
                        The Mad Scientist
                        • Oct 2003
                        • 11892

                        #12
                        I'm the one who made the spacers. I took some measurements of E30 rear hubs and the thinnest hubcentric spacers that would work are 15mm. Any thinner and it is impossible to make the hole in the backside (for the hub) deep enough for the hub, but still have a centering hub on the spacer.

                        As far as hub extenders, am I correct in thinking that all it is is a plug that fits into the center of the hub, then sticks out and is the same diameter as the outside of the hub? Does the inside bore of the hub run true enough to the outside? I'm trying to remember, but aren't the inside of the hubs just cast and unmachined?

                        Comment

                        • Todd Black 88
                          No R3VLimiter
                          • Oct 2007
                          • 3449

                          #13
                          Originally posted by codyep3
                          I hope to Christ you have looks going for you, because you sure as fuck don't have any intelligence.
                          2001 silver/Blk 325 cabby. SOLD
                          1988 Blk/Blk e30 factory wide body kit car SOLD
                          1992 DS/BLK 325 m-tech II apperance pack cabby SOLD!
                          2002 325xit Sil/blk. SOLD
                          2012 328i xdrive touring. Wht/blk. SOLD
                          2009 135 cabby. monacoblue/blk leather SOLD
                          2007 Z4m coupe. Silver grey/black/ aluminum. 1of50
                          2010 F650gs twin
                          2016 M235i cabby. Mineral grey/Red leather

                          Comment

                          • Todd Black 88
                            No R3VLimiter
                            • Oct 2007
                            • 3449

                            #14
                            Originally posted by NitroRustlerDriver
                            I'm the one who made the spacers. I took some measurements of E30 rear hubs and the thinnest hubcentric spacers that would work are 15mm. Any thinner and it is impossible to make the hole in the backside (for the hub) deep enough for the hub, but still have a centering hub on the spacer.

                            As far as hub extenders, am I correct in thinking that all it is is a plug that fits into the center of the hub, then sticks out and is the same diameter as the outside of the hub? Does the inside bore of the hub run true enough to the outside? I'm trying to remember, but aren't the inside of the hubs just cast and unmachined?
                            Yes
                            Originally posted by codyep3
                            I hope to Christ you have looks going for you, because you sure as fuck don't have any intelligence.
                            2001 silver/Blk 325 cabby. SOLD
                            1988 Blk/Blk e30 factory wide body kit car SOLD
                            1992 DS/BLK 325 m-tech II apperance pack cabby SOLD!
                            2002 325xit Sil/blk. SOLD
                            2012 328i xdrive touring. Wht/blk. SOLD
                            2009 135 cabby. monacoblue/blk leather SOLD
                            2007 Z4m coupe. Silver grey/black/ aluminum. 1of50
                            2010 F650gs twin
                            2016 M235i cabby. Mineral grey/Red leather

                            Comment

                            • Jand3rson
                              Banned
                              • Oct 2003
                              • 37587

                              #15
                              Originally posted by Todd Black 88
                              I used some thick aluminum piping with an OD a little larger then my hub OD. Turned the OD down to match exactly. Turned one end down to match the inner diameter of the front hub, with a tight,tap in fit. Cut it to length(thickness of the spacer I used 5mm). Turned the inside of the outer side down just enough to hammer in some large GM frost plugs as end caps. Done.
                              That's brilliant. Andrew could knock those out in no time flat.

                              Comment

                              Working...