rwhp vs crank hp

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • ja burna
    replied
    Yes dynos are for tuning but I just wanted to get a number figure since my built motor is tuned.. I just needed for general knowledge in case I need to dyno it again..

    Leave a comment:


  • P Arkus
    replied
    Originally posted by Cabriolet
    na dude. bad math is bad. 1.22 is 18% (1/(1-.18)) = 1.2195
    Absolutely right. This is what happens when you try to do backwards math backwards lol

    Leave a comment:


  • LJ851
    replied
    Fixed my math issue, and nando is correct. Too many variables to make the calc anything but a wild ass guess.

    Leave a comment:


  • nando
    replied
    forget about calculating crank HP from a wheel dyno. it's totally pointless. not only does it change with ambient conditions, it changes with dynos, and the % is not linear - it changes for the same drivetrain based on how much power you put into it.

    adding a magic 20% number, guessed from something you read on the internet (or pulled out of your ass, usually), to a wheel dyno result so you can brag about your mad HPs is one of the lamest bench racing excersizes there is. Chassis dynos are a tool used to tune an engine. That's all. The only comparisons should be cars done on the same dyno in the same conditions.

    Leave a comment:


  • VinniE30
    replied
    Originally posted by ja burna
    yeah figures were using a Mustang dyno.. so I don't know if they read lower or higher
    They read lower than dynojet with the factory settings, but sometimes shops add in a correction factor to make customers happy with higher numbers, but that can be done on any dyno I believe.
    Look at this article on dynos and how much higher/lower different manufacturers' dynos can be.
    In this chassis dyno guide HOT ROD answers some frequently asked questions about dyno testing including comparing types of dynamometers and explaining what factors can impact your results - Hot Rod Magazine


    Also see this thread: http://forums.bimmerforums.com/forum....php?t=1696183

    And if comparing to a reading done on a different day or different place you have to consider how factors like temperature and altitude affect output.

    Leave a comment:


  • ja burna
    replied
    yeah figures were using a Mustang dyno.. so I don't know if they read lower or higher

    Leave a comment:


  • Cabriolet
    replied
    Originally posted by ak-
    What's his math issue? 18% vs 22%? lol
    na dude. bad math is bad. 1.22 is 18% (1/(1-.18)) = 1.2195

    Leave a comment:


  • VinniE30
    replied
    I've read it's around 15% for manual and around 20% for auto.(autos are more variable though since newer ones are more efficient.
    I would say 15% for a rear wheel drive manual BMW.
    Lets take the e36 m3 for example.
    They usually dyno 200-210WHP bone stock. (dynojet)
    They are rated at 240HP by BMW.(CHP)
    240 - 15% drivetrain loss = 205 WHP so the 15% works out perfectly for that example.

    edit:
    OP, using 15% you would have 324 x 1.15 = 372.6 crank HP.

    Also, you have to consider that different dynos typically read higher and lower than others, some are at shops to be used for tuning only, not for bragging rights, so they don't change it from the factory settings which may be conservative. So I would ask the place that it got dyno'd at (or the dyno manufacturer if they don't know) because they would know how their reading correlate to crank HP better than anyone.
    Last edited by VinniE30; 01-07-2013, 02:22 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • ak-
    replied
    Originally posted by Cabriolet
    Fixed your math issue.
    It's a ~400hp engine
    What's his math issue? 18% vs 22%? lol

    Leave a comment:


  • Cabriolet
    replied
    Originally posted by P Arkus
    ^^^This. Using your formula of 18%, it should be 324 x 1.22 = 395 Crank HP
    Fixed your math issue.
    It's a ~400hp engine

    Leave a comment:


  • P Arkus
    replied
    Originally posted by ak-
    You did it backwards.
    He was 324 wheel.
    ^^^This. Using your formula of 18%, it should be 324 x 1.18 = 382 Crank HP

    Leave a comment:


  • ak-
    replied
    Originally posted by LJ851
    15-20 percent is usually whats used on a 2wd vehicle.


    324x .82 = 265 at the crank. 18% loss.
    You did it backwards.
    He was 324 wheel.

    Leave a comment:


  • IronFreak
    replied
    Agreed, I read a car craft article a while back, they said average a manual eats about 18-20% of the power, while an auto eats upwards of 32-35% of power.

    Leave a comment:


  • 10Toes
    replied

    Leave a comment:


  • LJ851
    replied
    15-20 percent is usually whats used on a 2wd vehicle.
    Last edited by LJ851; 01-07-2013, 06:29 PM.

    Leave a comment:

Working...