Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Anybody caught a shop putting miles on their car?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    #31
    Originally posted by ThatOneEuroE30 View Post
    I remember when I used to be on bimmerforums a guy took like 03 or 04 5 series in to get work done and one of the techs without anyone's knowledge took it for a joy ride and totaled it.
    Do you know what happens after that? Is it the shop's responsibility to pay or the mechanic?
    BMW tech
    Umass Amherst
    05 wrx sti

    Comment


      #32
      Originally posted by e30onBBSs View Post
      Do you know what happens after that? Is it the shop's responsibility to pay or the mechanic?
      if i remember correctly the shop paid for damages and then the tech i believe was fired and sued by the shop. Don't quote me on that though I just remember that from like two or three years ago when i first got into BMW's with my e36.


      1989 325is l 1984 euro 320i l 1970 2002 Racecar
      1991 318i 4dr slick top


      Euro spec 320i/Alpina B6 3.5 project(the never ending saga)
      Vintage race car revival (2002 content)
      Mtech 2 turbo restoration
      Brilliantrot slick top "build"

      Comment


        #33
        Originally posted by Julien View Post
        Every shop pretty much does it (including the dealers). Just think if any of you worked at a shop and an s54 swapped e30 m3 came in for a/c service.. would you not take it around the block..?
        NO! Not without the owners permission, or if it was actually necessary. That's exactly what this thread is about. And if an accident occurs, that's a whole other deal.

        Working in a shop shouldn't be about joyriding a swapped car when it comes in for A/C service..
        Drive it hard. Maintain it well.


        Convertible Technical & Discussion
        A Topless Memorandum

        Comment


          #34
          And then there's this

          Debbie and John Hooper took their cherished Chevy Camaro ZL1 to the dealer under warranty to fix a minor paint problem. Then they allege they got a call from the dealer saying they'd wrecked the car. Now they've offered a replacement, but it might not be enough.


          1989 325is l 1984 euro 320i l 1970 2002 Racecar
          1991 318i 4dr slick top


          Euro spec 320i/Alpina B6 3.5 project(the never ending saga)
          Vintage race car revival (2002 content)
          Mtech 2 turbo restoration
          Brilliantrot slick top "build"

          Comment


            #35
            I had a shop put 250 miles (tank of gas) on my mom's car and they broke several things in the interior. The shop owner covered everything. I'm still friends with the owner but its the last time I ever went there..

            I've always had good luck with the owners of the shops i go to, sadly their employees always seem to be retarded. Most recently I've taken my cars to a shop I wont name, and every time they fix something, I take the car home with a new problem, and I've gotten kind of suspicious.

            Comment


              #36
              While joyriding a car is inexcusable, a good shop is going to test drive every car, albeit safely and responsibly.

              Most car owners are not enthusiasts. Most will notice a broken wiper, or a flat tire, but may not notice an alignment change due to a worn bushing that causes the car to pull under heavy braking. It is the repair shops responsibility to discover and document potential problems above and beyond what the customer complains about. Most customers bring their car to a shop "to get fixed"... And that's it. They don't come to have the one thing they noticed attended to and everything else ignored. They recognize that they may not be aware of every problem.

              At every shop/dealership I worked at, every car was test driven, and received a thorough inspection. It helps the customer, and yes, it helps the shop make money. Mostly, though, it makes sure that at the end is the transaction that the customer has a safe car, and the shop isn't taken on liability by being the last responsible party to work on a death trap. If they come in for only a headlight bulb, the car never even goes on a lift, and a wheel falls off on their way home, they are going to blame the shop. They are going to sue, and are probably going to win.

              Again, however, this only accounts for a responsible < 3 mile test drive. Not joyriding, not running errands, not abusing the car. But to think your car is only going to move from the parking spot to a garage bay, and back, is just silly.
              Last edited by Andy.B; 01-21-2015, 04:57 AM.

              Comment


                #37
                Originally posted by Andy.B View Post
                While joyriding a car is inexcusable, a good shop is going to test drive every car, albeit safely and responsibly.

                Most car owners are not enthusiasts. Most will notice a broken wiper, or a flat tire, but may not notice an alignment change due to a worn bushing that causes the car to pull under heavy braking. It is the repair shops responsibility to discover and document potential problems above and beyond what the customer complains about. Most customers bring their car to a shop "to get fixed"... And that's it. They don't come to have the one thing they noticed attended to and everything else ignored. They recognize that they may not be aware of every problem.

                At every shop/dealership I worked at, every car was test driven, and received a thorough inspection. It helps the customer, and yes, it helps the shop make money. Mostly, though, it makes sure that at the end is the transaction that the customer has a safe car, and the shop isn't taken on liability by being the last responsible party to work on a death trap. If they come in for only a headlight bulb, the car never even goes on a lift, and a wheel falls off on their way home, they are going to blame the shop. They are going to sue, and are probably going to win.

                Again, however, this only accounts for a responsible < 3 mile test drive. Not joyriding, not running errands, not abusing the car. But to think your car is only going to move from the parking spot to a garage bay, and back, is just silly.
                ^ Well said. There is a balance to be had ... I get irked if a shop fails to test drive my car thoroughly; as certain things can be easily overlooked if a proper test drive isn't done before giving me the keys and sending me on my way.

                Comment


                  #38
                  The guy who built my car smoked the tires as he left his workshop on the test drive. Granted, I was present and encouraging him. If my car need to go in for something I always ask him not to hold back. Rather it breaks with him, than with me driving in the middle of the night. When he test drives I tell him: "Drive it like I would."
                  92 Opel Monza CLi 200i8v Exec
                  92 Opel Rekord 380GSiV6
                  87 BMW E30 335i (M30B35)
                  91 BMW E34 520i (M50B20) with Mtech Turbines
                  95 Hyundai Elantra with Mitsu 4G63
                  Three Aircooled VW Beetles
                  17.8Litres, 38cylinders, 10Cams and 84valves

                  Comment


                    #39
                    Originally posted by Tino-m30b35 View Post
                    The guy who built my car smoked the tires as he left his workshop on the test drive. Granted, I was present and encouraging him. If my car need to go in for something I always ask him not to hold back. Rather it breaks with him, than with me driving in the middle of the night. When he test drives I tell him: "Drive it like I would."
                    you Cape colored people sure are a crazy bunch aren't ya!

                    ;)
                    If it's got tits or tires, it's gonna cost ya!

                    Comment


                      #40
                      Originally posted by Tino-m30b35 View Post
                      The guy who built my car smoked the tires as he left his workshop on the test drive. Granted, I was present and encouraging him. If my car need to go in for something I always ask him not to hold back. Rather it breaks with him, than with me driving in the middle of the night. When he test drives I tell him: "Drive it like I would."

                      In other words drive it like ya stole it.


                      1989 325is l 1984 euro 320i l 1970 2002 Racecar
                      1991 318i 4dr slick top


                      Euro spec 320i/Alpina B6 3.5 project(the never ending saga)
                      Vintage race car revival (2002 content)
                      Mtech 2 turbo restoration
                      Brilliantrot slick top "build"

                      Comment


                        #41
                        Originally posted by ThatOneEuroE30 View Post
                        W/happy end for Hooper
                        Delaware resident John Hooper is getting a new Camaro ZL1 from Berger Chevrolet after he kicked off an Internet firestorm after an employee of his local Chevrolet dealership wrecked his car.
                        sigpic
                        Reich und Roll!

                        Comment


                          #42
                          Originally posted by george graves View Post
                          Lmfao. Bought M5 E34 mirrors off Vlad. Did not fit. True story.

                          Originally posted by Cabriolet View Post
                          make it 2.
                          I live in the bay area, shop rates are 140/hr. it has become cheaper for me to learn and buy my own tools. that said. a shop doesn't need to ever put more than 10 miles on any car EVER. This goes for the work I now do for other. The only time I do more than 10 miles is for fresh engine break in. that does require a 35 minute drive and I do asked the owner first and report the exact about of time the car was on the road. I'm just a local guy. If a shop doesn't do at least the same write them negative reviews on yelp and google.
                          I have a garage and tons of tools, maybe I'm getting old but I rather drop the car off now for big jobs .vs breaking my back late at night after work/weekends.

                          This is after doing everything you can think off during 8PM-2/3AM shifts after work for 2-3 months.


                          Founder @ Maintenr. Take control of your vehicle maintenance.

                          Comment


                            #43
                            Originally posted by mr2peak View Post
                            NO! Not without the owners permission, or if it was actually necessary. That's exactly what this thread is about. And if an accident occurs, that's a whole other deal.

                            Working in a shop shouldn't be about joyriding a swapped car when it comes in for A/C service..
                            Just saying it happens.
                            Build Threads:
                            Pamela/Bella/Betty/325ix/5-Lug Seta/S60R/Miata ITB/Miata Turbo/Miata VVT/951/325xi-6

                            Comment


                              #44
                              As an auto shop, I will be putting a minimum of 6 miles on your car. I test drive before and after repairs. If its a tricky diagnosis I will put as many miles on the car as necessary to duplicate the problem. I've put 50 miles on a car trying to get a failure.
                              By the way, if the customer brings their car in needing diag. with no fuel I charge labor time to put fuel in.

                              Comment


                                #45
                                Back when I had my 335i, it was understood by me that my car was taken for a joyride no matter the reason for a trip to the shop. I always received my car back with my spare tire kit slung to the back part of the trunk (I kept it tucked up against the rear seats.) I guess BMW techs never had the opportunity to drive a manual 335i? After I installed my dashcam I would either receive the car back with sporadic missing files during its visit or the last video recorded is me dropping it off. The service managers always had fun trying to explain that one away.

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X