Which photo?-Rainy 320i

[steinbachphoto]

Which of these two do you prefer? The cropped or the un cropped?

[Wishno87]

un cropped

[E30Idea]

un cropped FTW

[Stephen]

Definately uncropped. I love the vignetting effect, and there's just alot more to the first one. Hell if youve got one from that shoot even farther away

[Raxe]

Uncropped.

[steinbachphoto]

would you guys still say uncropped if the vignette wasn't there? The thing I like about the cropped is that it shows off more of the car

[Stephen]

would you guys still say uncropped if the vignette wasn't there? The thing I like about the cropped is that it shows off more of the car

Maybe, You still get the whole fence in there.

If you want visual impact uncropped definately takes the cake in my book, and is enough detail i think

[steinbachphoto]

Definately uncropped. I love the vignetting effect, and there's just alot more to the first one. Hell if youve got one from that shoot even farther away

If you want to see more here they are: http://www.r3vlimited.com/board/showthread.php?t=120997

[steinbachphoto]

Here is a non vignette version

[Stephen]

Cool, but yeah, the uncropped is the winner, at least in my book.

Good shots

Edit: w/ vignette!

[steinbachphoto]

Cool, but yeah, the uncropped is the winner, at least in my book.

Good shots

Edit: w/ vignette!

Thanks, I'm having a hard time deciding. I have enter one or the other in this little contest thing I'm involved in and you can only use basic editing so vignette is not allowed.

The theme is "play" so I'm putting in a photo of my car(I'm too lazy to go out and do a shoot with a model for it and this meet came up and I jumped on the opportunity) and I'm just wondering what a bunch of model/nature based photographers would like better(the users vote)

[Stephen]

Oh cool. I'm failry into photography [ outside cars ] but am no expert. Even if you can't use the vignette i'd still do the one farther out. Theres more to the picture, especially if this isnt a car based contest

[steinbachphoto]

Oh cool. I'm failry into photography [ outside cars ] but am no expert. Even if you can't use the vignette i'd still do the one farther out. Theres more to the picture, especially if this isnt a car based contest

Yeah thanks. I checked out your Flickr, you have a good eye for composition.


If you'd like to check out my stuff my site is http://www.steinbachphoto.ca

[Stephen]

Thank you! You're photos are quite nice. Especially since i really want to get into more unsaturated, sharp images with diffused lights with lots of detail, like cityscapes etc. And a little vignette usually helps those.

Do you do it profesionally or as a hobby?

[steinbachphoto]

Mr.

Thank you! You're photos are quite nice. Especially since i really want to get into more unsaturated, sharp images with diffused lights with lots of detail, like cityscapes etc. And a little vignette usually helps those.

Do you do it profesionally or as a hobby?

a little bit of both, it's a side income, I work with models, sometimes for pay, sometimes I will seek a model because they have the look I'm looking for. But all my landscape and nature stuff is just the hobby side that when I want to get away from everything I plug in the ipod and just go take landscape/nature all day