some problems with gearbox...

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • mega_t2008
    Member
    • Nov 2009
    • 43

    #1

    some problems with gearbox...

    Hello guys... Problem is next... Swapped in M50B25TU few months ago... Everything was ok, and then I found some M52B28 crank and rods and swapped in 2.0 DOHC to diss/reasemble m50b25, put in 2.8 crank and engine back in the car... Now, with released clutch there is sound like something is vibrating and it really sounds bad, and when I press the clutch it stops... in both crankshafts M50B25 and M52B28 there is not pilot bearing and in crank from M50B20 it is there... Is this my problem or my tranny is f.... up??? Tranny is ZF 5-spd from E34... Thanks for answering...
  • cabin
    E30 Addict
    • Dec 2006
    • 552

    #2
    First thought would be throwout bearing.
    -Justin

    sigpic

    Current: BMWless for now... '15 Grand Cherokee & '03 Mach 1

    Comment

    • Adrian_Visser
      R3VLimited
      • Jun 2006
      • 2823

      #3
      ??????? What do you mean about no pilot bearing on the other cranks? You have a pilot bearing installed right now though right?

      Did you re-use the flywheel bolts and not put loc-tite on them by any chance?

      '89 Alpine S52 with goodies

      Comment

      • Adrian_Visser
        R3VLimited
        • Jun 2006
        • 2823

        #4
        Originally posted by cabin
        First thought would be throwout bearing.
        If it was the throwout bearing it would make the sound with the clutch pedal depressed and go away with it released.

        How did the transmission go together? It was all lined up perfectly while it went together right no possibility of the input shaft being bent or something?

        '89 Alpine S52 with goodies

        Comment

        • mega_t2008
          Member
          • Nov 2009
          • 43

          #5
          pilot bearing was on the crank on 2.0 but that engine is now out... so pilot bearing is not there anymore... gearbox is is lined up perfectly, and it went together really easy... i spent 10 secs to "connect" it with the engine... bolts, and flywheel are not the problem 100%,...

          Comment

          • gobuffs
            E30 Addict
            • Dec 2004
            • 513

            #6
            you didn't put a pilot bearing in?...and then you wonder why there is noise? seriously?

            Comment

            • 7pilot
              E30 Addict
              • Feb 2009
              • 475

              #7
              Originally posted by gobuffs
              you didn't put a pilot bearing in?...and then you wonder why there is noise? seriously?
              I realize that I am not being helpful, and I apologize,

              but:

              :shock:




              m

              Comment

              • mega_t2008
                Member
                • Nov 2009
                • 43

                #8
                I know, it doesn't make sense but before when engine was full stock M50B25TU there wasn't pilot bearing and any noise... And now, it's there... And engine was from e34 with manual gearbox... I know it's there on all m20's and I saw it on few m50 engines, but I thought that there is too much accident for me to have cranks without pilot if it's there for all engines with manual gearbox...

                Comment

                • Gnarles
                  Grease Monkey
                  • Dec 2008
                  • 342

                  #9
                  You do know that you can buy pilot bearings separate from the crank, right? Match the pilot bearing to the transmission you are using.

                  Comment

                  • 7pilot
                    E30 Addict
                    • Feb 2009
                    • 475

                    #10
                    Originally posted by mega_t2008
                    I know, it doesn't make sense but before when engine was full stock M50B25TU there wasn't pilot bearing and any noise... And now, it's there... And engine was from e34 with manual gearbox... I know it's there on all m20's and I saw it on few m50 engines, but I thought that there is too much accident for me to have cranks without pilot if it's there for all engines with manual gearbox...

                    If the gearbox got hung up on the previous engine during separation, there is a possibility that the input shaft was bent.
                    secondly:
                    During the running without the pilot bearing in the new engine, the input shaft would have a random elliptical freedom of movement. That may have done some damage.

                    I would suggest that you pull the drive train, separate carefully, and check the input shaft for straightness.
                    If you are confident it is straight, install the correct pilot/spigot bearing, and reconnect.

                    if you are using a clutch disc that is springless, make sure that it is not warped.


                    m

                    Comment

                    • mega_t2008
                      Member
                      • Nov 2009
                      • 43

                      #11
                      Thanks for good info... we are going to pull the gearbox of and see it..

                      Comment

                      • Adrian_Visser
                        R3VLimited
                        • Jun 2006
                        • 2823

                        #12
                        Originally posted by mega_t2008
                        I know, it doesn't make sense but before when engine was full stock M50B25TU there wasn't pilot bearing and any noise... And now, it's there... And engine was from e34 with manual gearbox... I know it's there on all m20's and I saw it on few m50 engines, but I thought that there is too much accident for me to have cranks without pilot if it's there for all engines with manual gearbox...
                        I find it very hard to understand what you are actually saying.

                        Is there a pilot bearing on the end of the crankshaft right now or not?

                        If there is no pilot bearing you have a MAJOR problem.

                        '89 Alpine S52 with goodies

                        Comment

                        • mega_t2008
                          Member
                          • Nov 2009
                          • 43

                          #13
                          I wrote it up in hurry so it's not easy to understand... Let's try again... There is no pilot bearing in crank now... But thing what made me to be confused is next... I bought an engine together with gearbox, put it in car, and after 4-5 months pulled it out... when I pulled out tranny,there wasn't pilot bearing in crank... But there wasn't any noise from drive train... Now it's all together and back in car but noise is so hard, that I can't believe that there wasn't any noise before... Anyway I'm pulling my tranny tonight or early in morning and going to put that crappy little bearing, and Getrag 240 if ZF is fuc... up...

                          Comment

                          Working...