Opinions on s52, m54, or s54 swap touring

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Shftr8
    E30 Addict
    • Aug 2014
    • 530

    #1

    Opinions on s52, m54, or s54 swap touring

    Ok I just picked up a clean right hand drive touring and I need everyones opinion and thoughts on a motor swap. I have three options a S52 (have), M54B30 (have), or a S54 (dont have). My father and I run a salvage yard and I have plenty of BMW engines and harnesses and ecu's etc etc laying around. So I need to know if it is worth it to do the extra work and money to put a M54 or S54 in. I have a good lead on a S54 that needs piston rings but its just the motor so I would need everything else (ecu, wiring, air box, etc). I have a M54B30 with everything but there is extra cost in getting the ECU to work and seems a bit harder then the S52 engine that has been done a thousand times but the S52 doesnt seem to have that mush more power over the M54. opinions welcome.
  • *freshm3
    Advanced Member
    • Aug 2008
    • 174

    #2
    S54.

    My friend built his S54 touring and it is a beast. Do it. Take your time. Gather your parts and build your dream. We used Bimmerworld/EPIC motorsports for DME reflash and tune purpose.

    I have an S54 E30 M3 FYI. Any questions...feel free to ask away. Both cars have been running off of the stock DME since Nov-2011.
    If looks could kill:::

    Comment

    • nando
      Moderator
      • Nov 2003
      • 34827

      #3
      I can flash the S54 ECU for $300

      a brand new plug and play wiring harness for anS54 E30 is around $750 I think from Andrew325is, or you can make your own.

      you can get used DMEs cheap if you look. it can be any version, as long as it's from an E46 M3. I've typically paid $100-$300 at most.
      Build thread

      Bimmerlabs

      Comment

      • D-rock
        Mod Crazy
        • Mar 2009
        • 714

        #4
        Originally posted by *freshm3
        S54.

        My friend built his S54 touring and it is a beast. Do it. Take your time. Gather your parts and build your dream. We used Bimmerworld/EPIC motorsports for DME reflash and tune purpose.

        I have an S54 E30 M3 FYI. Any questions...feel free to ask away. Both cars have been running off of the stock DME since Nov-2011.
        I have an M50 in my car, I don't see much of a point going s52. How hard is the S54 these day (2014) ?

        Thank you

        Also didn't mean to thread jack

        Comment

        • mr2peak
          R3VLimited
          • Aug 2008
          • 2388

          #5
          Sorry to bump an old thread, but

          Originally posted by D-rock
          I have an M50 in my car, I don't see much of a point going s52.
          You saw the point of an M50, which is 25hp over an M20. An S52 is 50hp+ over the M50... Why do you not see the point?
          Drive it hard. Maintain it well.


          Convertible Technical & Discussion
          A Topless Memorandum

          Comment

          Working...