redline 75w 90 or shockproof???

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • e30 gangsta
    No R3VLimiter
    • Jul 2004
    • 3877

    #1

    redline 75w 90 or shockproof???

    I was wondering what yall suggest?? I have heard shockproof locks up harder and faster. We are talking about final drive gear oil btw.
  • Charlie
    kid tested, administrator approved
    • Oct 2003
    • 6686

    #2
    Unless you're talking a fresh, rebuilt diff, I wouldn't run shockproof in a 150k+ mile rear end.

    -Charlie
    Swing wild, brake later, don't apologize.
    '89 324d, '76 02, '98 318ti, '03 Z4, '07 MCS, '07 F800s - Bonafide BMW elitist prick.
    FYYFF

    Comment

    • DanGillan
      R3V Elite
      • Mar 2004
      • 4061

      #3
      even in freshly rebuilt diffs, diffsonline suggests redline 75w90 with an lsd additive. we've had the best results with it.
      Dan

      Comment

      • Charlie
        kid tested, administrator approved
        • Oct 2003
        • 6686

        #4
        Originally posted by DanGillan
        even in freshly rebuilt diffs, diffsonline suggests redline 75w90 with an lsd additive. we've had the best results with it.
        Why would you add a LS additive to the regular 75w90? The NS varient, maybe.

        -Charlie
        Swing wild, brake later, don't apologize.
        '89 324d, '76 02, '98 318ti, '03 Z4, '07 MCS, '07 F800s - Bonafide BMW elitist prick.
        FYYFF

        Comment

        • DanGillan
          R3V Elite
          • Mar 2004
          • 4061

          #5
          yea, i just meant to make sure it has lsd additive in it, not to add more
          Dan

          Comment

          • DaN
            E30 Fanatic
            • Dec 2003
            • 1265

            #6
            [threadjack]
            How would shockproof work in a noisy 235k gearbox? Would it quiet it signficantly, when compared to synthetic 75w-140?

            Comment

            • Charlie
              kid tested, administrator approved
              • Oct 2003
              • 6686

              #7
              Originally posted by DaN
              [threadjack]
              How would shockproof work in a noisy 235k gearbox? Would it quiet it signficantly, when compared to synthetic 75w-140?
              It would hasten putting it out of its misery.

              -Charlie
              Swing wild, brake later, don't apologize.
              '89 324d, '76 02, '98 318ti, '03 Z4, '07 MCS, '07 F800s - Bonafide BMW elitist prick.
              FYYFF

              Comment

              • DaN
                E30 Fanatic
                • Dec 2003
                • 1265

                #8
                So you're saying it would wear it out sooner? Why?

                Comment

                • trent

                  #9
                  You guys should be running a non-detergent 50W. I have found that works best. :up:

                  Comment

                  • Charlie
                    kid tested, administrator approved
                    • Oct 2003
                    • 6686

                    #10
                    Originally posted by DaN
                    So you're saying it would wear it out sooner? Why?
                    Shock proof is very light, it's intended for qualifying laps and drag racing, not normal street or race usage. It certainly wouldn't quiet a diff, and I'm sure wouldn't be good for a higher mileage unit.

                    -Charlie
                    Swing wild, brake later, don't apologize.
                    '89 324d, '76 02, '98 318ti, '03 Z4, '07 MCS, '07 F800s - Bonafide BMW elitist prick.
                    FYYFF

                    Comment

                    • e30 gangsta
                      No R3VLimiter
                      • Jul 2004
                      • 3877

                      #11
                      so basically return the shockproof?

                      Comment

                      • Mot
                        45 toting redneck
                        • Jul 2004
                        • 4018

                        #12
                        ya, get redline... unless you hate your diff.

                        Comment

                        • Charlie
                          kid tested, administrator approved
                          • Oct 2003
                          • 6686

                          #13
                          Originally posted by e30 gangsta
                          so basically return the shockproof?
                          I personally would not run it in an older diff, but have not actually tried it. YMMV. I would actually love to see a dyno pull between "conventional" fluid and the shockproof in an e30 diff.

                          -Charlie
                          Swing wild, brake later, don't apologize.
                          '89 324d, '76 02, '98 318ti, '03 Z4, '07 MCS, '07 F800s - Bonafide BMW elitist prick.
                          FYYFF

                          Comment

                          • mspiegle
                            E30 Enthusiast
                            • Oct 2003
                            • 1026

                            #14
                            don't mean to question your knowledge, but the redline website makes it sound like it is a very high viscocity fluid that prevents breaking gears in high-torque applications. Where is your info from?
                            Michael Spiegle

                            '01 Ford Escape / Daily Driver
                            '99 M3 / Track Car
                            '87 325is bronzit / wtf car
                            '06 Daytona Triumph 675 / Daily Rider

                            Comment

                            • Charlie
                              kid tested, administrator approved
                              • Oct 2003
                              • 6686

                              #15
                              Originally posted by mspiegle
                              don't mean to question your knowledge, but the redline website makes it sound like it is a very high viscocity fluid that prevents breaking gears in high-torque applications. Where is your info from?
                              Unless this is a different "shockproof" (could be), it's typically a very light gear oil designed for minimum driveline loss for drag racing and qualifying applications.

                              Gimme a link to what you're seeing.

                              -Charlie
                              Swing wild, brake later, don't apologize.
                              '89 324d, '76 02, '98 318ti, '03 Z4, '07 MCS, '07 F800s - Bonafide BMW elitist prick.
                              FYYFF

                              Comment

                              Working...