Let's play the mystery noise game!

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • =======Live Fast!
    Wrencher
    • Nov 2011
    • 248

    #1

    Let's play the mystery noise game!

    So I get a knocking noise that I feel in the trans well. Its not the flex disk. Had the car up on the lift and we checked everything we could with out dropping the exhaust and it was all tight as I just had the whole car apart and all of the mounts and the whole exhaust is brand new. It doesn't make the noise all the time which is frustrating when you're trying to diagnose something. The times it WILL make noise is when I'm going highway speeds over bumpy road, highway speeds or occasionally right after I shut the car off as it's powering down. The drive shaft was replaced not that long ago from Driveline. Can a bad center support bearing make that noise? And if so why wouldn't it be doing it all the time? That's the only thing I haven't checked yet. Any ideas? Thanks everyone!
    sigpic2000 323ci
    1987 325is super etta
    1988 M5
    2000 M5
    1989 944 turbo
    1989 325is
  • mr.vang
    R3V Elite
    • May 2010
    • 4371

    #2
    I know this doesn't have anything to do with your problem but before replacing your driveshaft, do you get a clunking noise from the rear when shifting gear? I'm trying to solve mine, hopefully you can help me instead.
    Bought parts from me before? leave your feedback here

    Comment

    • andrewm
      E30 Addict
      • Apr 2010
      • 456

      #3
      Center support bearing can cause that sound, but in my experience it's going to typically be more when you are accelerating.

      Are you sure one of the exhaust hangers isnt loose?
      1987 Delphin 325e Sedan - Natalie
      1990 325i 24v
      1997 Chevrolet K1500 Crew Cab 4x4 - The Centurion

      Comment

      • Poorboyz
        R3VLimited
        • May 2012
        • 2117

        #4
        Do you guys feel this noise is external or internal to the transmission? Mr.Vang, you said you get the noise when shifting gears... all the gears?
        sigpic
        Rebuilding since 07/06/2016

        Poorboyz Parts For Sale - Updated 01/20/17 - Will be updated soon - Have many parts to post

        Poorboyz Feedback Thread

        Comment

        • =======Live Fast!
          Wrencher
          • Nov 2011
          • 248

          #5
          Originally posted by mr.vang
          I know this doesn't have anything to do with your problem but before replacing your driveshaft, do you get a clunking noise from the rear when shifting gear? I'm trying to solve mine, hopefully you can help me instead.
          Nope
          sigpic2000 323ci
          1987 325is super etta
          1988 M5
          2000 M5
          1989 944 turbo
          1989 325is

          Comment

          • =======Live Fast!
            Wrencher
            • Nov 2011
            • 248

            #6
            Originally posted by andrewm
            Center support bearing can cause that sound, but in my experience it's going to typically be more when you are accelerating.

            Are you sure one of the exhaust hangers isnt loose?
            Hangers are tight
            sigpic2000 323ci
            1987 325is super etta
            1988 M5
            2000 M5
            1989 944 turbo
            1989 325is

            Comment

            • =======Live Fast!
              Wrencher
              • Nov 2011
              • 248

              #7
              Originally posted by Poorboyz
              Do you guys feel this noise is external or internal to the transmission? Mr.Vang, you said you get the noise when shifting gears... all the gears?
              No noise when shifting.
              sigpic2000 323ci
              1987 325is super etta
              1988 M5
              2000 M5
              1989 944 turbo
              1989 325is

              Comment

              • =======Live Fast!
                Wrencher
                • Nov 2011
                • 248

                #8
                anyone? anyone? Its driving me nuts.
                sigpic2000 323ci
                1987 325is super etta
                1988 M5
                2000 M5
                1989 944 turbo
                1989 325is

                Comment

                • Thizzelle
                  R3V Elite
                  • Oct 2008
                  • 4422

                  #9
                  I bet it's CSB
                  "I wanna see da boat movie"
                  "I got a tree on my house"

                  Comment

                  • =======Live Fast!
                    Wrencher
                    • Nov 2011
                    • 248

                    #10
                    Originally posted by Thizzelle
                    I bet it's CSB
                    I'm hoping so at this point. I might drop the exhaust this weekend and I'll be able to see if it is.
                    sigpic2000 323ci
                    1987 325is super etta
                    1988 M5
                    2000 M5
                    1989 944 turbo
                    1989 325is

                    Comment

                    • ct3155
                      Wrencher
                      • May 2010
                      • 208

                      #11
                      I had a problem similar... a knocking i couldn't figure out. Only would happen over bumps! Dove me nuts!!

                      Ended up being the transmission cross brace wasn't completely tight. You know, the black bar that holds up the back of the trans??

                      Kinda a scary thought once I finally figured it out! Only a matter of time before it would fall hahaha!

                      I know you said it came apart with all new mounts... But maybe shit didn't get tightened..

                      Just my 2c


                      1988 325is - Track Toy
                      1986 325e - Daily Driver

                      Lovin the e30's

                      Comment

                      • =======Live Fast!
                        Wrencher
                        • Nov 2011
                        • 248

                        #12
                        Originally posted by ct3155
                        I had a problem similar... a knocking i couldn't figure out. Only would happen over bumps! Dove me nuts!!

                        Ended up being the transmission cross brace wasn't completely tight. You know, the black bar that holds up the back of the trans??

                        Kinda a scary thought once I finally figured it out! Only a matter of time before it would fall hahaha!

                        I know you said it came apart with all new mounts... But maybe shit didn't get tightened..

                        Just my 2c
                        Checked...it was tight
                        sigpic2000 323ci
                        1987 325is super etta
                        1988 M5
                        2000 M5
                        1989 944 turbo
                        1989 325is

                        Comment

                        • jlevie
                          R3V OG
                          • Nov 2006
                          • 13530

                          #13
                          What is the condition of the motor & transmission mounts?
                          The car makes it possible, but the driver makes it happen.
                          Jim Levie, Huntsville, AL

                          Comment

                          • =======Live Fast!
                            Wrencher
                            • Nov 2011
                            • 248

                            #14
                            Originally posted by jlevie
                            What is the condition of the motor & transmission mounts?
                            refer to my original post...they're all brand new
                            sigpic2000 323ci
                            1987 325is super etta
                            1988 M5
                            2000 M5
                            1989 944 turbo
                            1989 325is

                            Comment

                            • NoM54me
                              Advanced Member
                              • Feb 2014
                              • 158

                              #15
                              @ Vang-- your diff mount is probably loose or worn. @ LiveFast--Exhaust may seem tight but could be striking body when traversing bumps, if it's very close to the body. Sometimes, even a car that only weighs 2700 pounds can cause rattles we can't easily replicate with our hands. However, you said it also makes the noise AFTER you've turned the car off, which should eliminate any moving parts like a center support bearing.

                              Comment

                              Working...