Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Which wire makes the window go down?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Which wire makes the window go down?

    Car is a 91 318 sedan. Driver's side rear window will only go up, not down. I got it to go down a few times as I messed with the switch, but the problem exists regardless of which switch I use (front or rear), so I am led to believe that perhaps a wire has become compromised. I also think this could be true because a previous owner had changed the front switches to E36 switches which required some wire splicing. I'm 100% sure the motor is fine, as if I connect it to the right side for testing it goes up and down without any problem whatsoever.

    Anyhow, does anyone know how to tell which wire corresponds to UP and which one to DOWN?

    Man, I am SO close to having this debacle finished. I finally replaced the driver side rear door lock actuator and it WORKS!!! Once these windows are working, the car should be nearly 100% again! Sadly, I may then decide to sell it as I just don't have the time to keep up with it anymore, but I wanna be sure its in good shape no matter what.

    Thanks fellas!
    E30 M52B28

    #2
    Two wires are required, not one. Switching polarity will switch the window up or down.

    Download the ETM and it will help you big time.
    Owner - Bavarian Restoration
    BMW and European Electronics Repair and Restoration
    www.BavRest.com
    My Feedback Thread
    Our Facebook!
    Follow our Instagram!

    Comment


      #3
      Originally posted by Gregs///M View Post
      Two wires are required, not one. Switching polarity will switch the window up or down.

      Download the ETM and it will help you big time.
      Not sure what ETM is, but if its the same as the electical diagrams in the bentley then I have it.

      There are 2 wires coming that go from the front window switch to the back. That much I know, I just assumed that the way it works is you complete the circuit one way by pushing up which I assume sends 12 V to the window motor through one wire, or pushing down and it sends 12V to the window motor through the other wire.

      Here's a question- if the switch in the front was somehow bad, wouldn't the rear switch still work? That's why I am assuming this is a wiring thing.
      E30 M52B28

      Comment


        #4
        If one of the switches failed, the rest will continue to work.

        The ETM is the electronic troubleshooting manual, its separate from the Bentley and much better. search e30 etm.
        Owner - Bavarian Restoration
        BMW and European Electronics Repair and Restoration
        www.BavRest.com
        My Feedback Thread
        Our Facebook!
        Follow our Instagram!

        Comment


          #5
          Cool- I actually have that manual, so I guess I'm in good shape on that front. Looks like its time to bust out the multimeter. I'll post back with results.
          E30 M52B28

          Comment


            #6
            OK- Now this is REALLY perplexing.

            I took the multimeter and began by measuring voltage at the 2 wires going to the motor. When I push the switch one way, I get +12.4V, and when I push the switch the other way, I get -12.4V. So how the hell does the motor only go one way? Just to make sure I ma not going crazy, I hooked the motor up to the other side, and it goes up and down no problem. The motor is fine, and now I come to find out that the motor is seeing + and - 12V as it should, so how in the hell does it only go one way on my driver's side? I don't get it. I hate this. If it has shown like 0v on the down side, then I'd know there was something wonky going on, but now what? UGH. Seriously, this is the worst.
            E30 M52B28

            Comment


              #7
              Originally posted by rammstein View Post
              OK- Now this is REALLY perplexing.

              I took the multimeter and began by measuring voltage at the 2 wires going to the motor. When I push the switch one way, I get +12.4V, and when I push the switch the other way, I get -12.4V. So how the hell does the motor only go one way? Just to make sure I ma not going crazy, I hooked the motor up to the other side, and it goes up and down no problem. The motor is fine, and now I come to find out that the motor is seeing + and - 12V as it should, so how in the hell does it only go one way on my driver's side? I don't get it. I hate this. If it has shown like 0v on the down side, then I'd know there was something wonky going on, but now what? UGH. Seriously, this is the worst.
              What you are dealing with is called "rest on ground"

              How it works is simple but confusing. Both wires, when the circuit is "at rest" show a ground. When you push the "up" button, the "up" wire goes to +12V and the "down" wire stays on ground. Obviously, when the "down" button is pressed, the down wire goes live and the up wire rests on ground.

              Now, here is the confusing part: if you press the up button and the ground is disconnected, the down wire will go live too, because it feeds back (complete the circuit) through the window motor.

              Pull the switches, refer to the ETM for color codes and test continuity to ground at the switches first. I bet its a broken ground under the center console...hope its that easy!

              Luke

              Closing SOON!
              "LAST CHANCE FOR G.A.S." DEAL IS ON NOW

              Luke AT germanaudiospecialties DOT com or text 425-761-6450, or for quickest answers, call me at the shop 360-669-0398

              Thanks for 10 years of fun!

              Comment


                #8
                Originally posted by StereoInstaller1 View Post
                What you are dealing with is called "rest on ground"

                How it works is simple but confusing. Both wires, when the circuit is "at rest" show a ground. When you push the "up" button, the "up" wire goes to +12V and the "down" wire stays on ground. Obviously, when the "down" button is pressed, the down wire goes live and the up wire rests on ground.

                Now, here is the confusing part: if you press the up button and the ground is disconnected, the down wire will go live too, because it feeds back (complete the circuit) through the window motor.

                Pull the switches, refer to the ETM for color codes and test continuity to ground at the switches first. I bet its a broken ground under the center console...hope its that easy!

                Luke
                OK- Here is where I play my moron card- what do you mean when you say test continuity to ground at the switches? I have the ETM so that's a start. What makes me suspicious is previous owner did a swap to e36 switches in front, and I already years ago had an issue where I ended up redoing a lot of the soldering up there.
                E30 M52B28

                Comment


                  #9
                  Interestingly, if I hook up the multimeter to the two wires going to the motor and measure AMPS, now its doing what I would expect- it shows a reading for UP but 0 for down. I have no idea about the science of what is happening here, but at least now I have confirmation that for whatever reason the down button isn't juicing the motor with AMPS.
                  E30 M52B28

                  Comment


                    #10
                    OK I used google and what checking continuity to ground means is hooking black to the chassis and red to the various spots on the window switch and making sure I get a beep. I'll report back.
                    E30 M52B28

                    Comment


                      #11
                      Yep, exactly. Make sure the brown wires are solid ground..the hackery is another story.

                      Post some pics of the carnage if you must...LOL

                      Best of luck, and I hope the explanation helped.

                      Closing SOON!
                      "LAST CHANCE FOR G.A.S." DEAL IS ON NOW

                      Luke AT germanaudiospecialties DOT com or text 425-761-6450, or for quickest answers, call me at the shop 360-669-0398

                      Thanks for 10 years of fun!

                      Comment


                        #12
                        Well THAT was fascinating. So I started trying to disassemble the front window switch to get at the ends of the wires for testing. I popped off the switch rocker and two metal clips went flying. After spending 45 minutes trying to find them, then using a magnet to get one of them out from the under my seat, I started trying to put it back together. Something strange happened then- I pushed on the window button and the sucker worked. WTF?!?! worked in both directions. Tried it from the back, it worked there too. So then I clicked the switch all back together, and BOOM, no more window down. I pried it apart, and I can get it to work again. SO this means, I'm gonna go ahead and guess, that the window front window switch is somehow bad. This perplexes me a bit as I thought that even if that switch was bad, the rear would still work, but apparently I am mistaken. I think this means I need to get a replacement switch for the front.

                        Here is the offending switch:


                        What's weird is there is this slider component to it that appears like you would slide it to eject the top, but it only slides like a mm or two and barely starts to pop apart, then that's it. No amount of force seems to work as far as getting it apart more.

                        So I need to find a white-backed e36 window switch, right?
                        E30 M52B28

                        Comment


                          #13
                          IT WORKS!!! So I looked up white-back e36 switches on EBAY and it turned out there were a pair listed from a guy in Ft. Lauderdale. I took a shot in the dark and wrote him, told him I was a forum member in case he was too, and as it turns out he is and I drove the 35 miles to his house, got the switches, came home, and everything works now. My window goes up, and down, and up again. It is incredible. Awwwwwwright!!!! Now I just have to put everything back together and fix a few more nagging things and the car should be 100%. Awesome!
                          E30 M52B28

                          Comment

                          Working...
                          X