X3 or X5

[craig4ie]

We had an X5 3.0 traded in at a dealership I used to work at. It had a chip or something done to the ECU for more power and it was surprisingly responsive. I generally hate SUVs, but this one was ok...

[jflip2002]

I like the X3. I too get to drive it to the gas station when we sell one to a customer, since we fill up their tank for free. It feels like, and somewhat sporty. The X5 with the V8 just feels like a Beast. but I guess it depends on what you plan on doing with it. If you just want an SUV, I would go X3. I think they look better also... but I prefer 3s to 5s, and 5s to 7s. Plus, with the right very minor mods, like wheels, and possibly a more "Settled" suspension, I think itd be totally bad ass for a family ride.

I will probably get one within the next year, just because BMW employees get to lease one for $209 a month, so I may be biased lol =\

[Spec]

I've heard the exact opposite from a friend who works at a German repair shop. They see the X3 more often then the X5. I haven't ridden in or driven the X3, so I speak only through hearsay, but I've been told the X3 is much lower in the quaility department. The parts are cheaper, fit and finish is not so great (the newest X3's look well put together to me, though) and the like.

Again, just hearsay. Personally if I took either I'd want the real space in the X5.

[Raxe]

X3 is actually quite an enjoyable drive, I drive them every day to and from the gas station. I prefer it over any other new BMW, especially with the 6 speed. X5 is nice too, but feels its weight.

[VAPORBLADE]

Nice! Good to know! I like the more space that the X5 offers...so we will see. I will go with the V8 if I go with a X5, that is for sure. I want a car that I do not want to mess around with for maintence - so you have me really thinking about the X3. Bottom line I need to drive them both. My wife wants me to get a Volvo XC70, but...well...it is not "me". Maybe it is "her". ;)

[bimmer8604]

The x3 is overall a well built little car. very rarely do they come into the shop for service. the X5 on the other hand is a beast in its own. Depends if you are looking at E53's(first gen) or E70's(newest). I imagine if you are looking at X3's you will probably be looking at 3.0 X5's. IMO if you get an X5 get the v8.

Umm, and also try to get a car with a warranty. you'll pay more, but warranty covers just about everything. THe worst complaint I've had with an X3 is the passenger side door not opening from the outside, but on the E53 X5's i see lots of complaints due to the cars age. On the e70, go V8 or go home! Its a very badass truck!

Kyle

[VAPORBLADE]

I am going to get one of the other, I think. I am going to look at the X3's first, and there is a 2004 this week I will check out. What are you guys/girls thoughts on the X's? The 04 is a 2.5.

I need a SUV, so that is why I am looking *it snows here, and I have a family + a dog! haaha*.