"Pass this jobs bill!"

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • klavender1
    replied
    How is taxing the rich "fair"? I work my ass off to get rich only to have the govt. steal (let's not kid each other cause that's what it is) to support people that vote for them. And thus keep them in power. BTW, I'm probably considered low middle class but I work for my money and don't expect a handout. Even growing up poor, I never expected a handout and was taught to work for what I want. 47% of people in this country don't pay taxes and that's fair? A guy I work with (whom I actually like personally) got back more in taxes than he paid in. Why? Because he has 2 kids and doesn't make much money. Is that my fault? I have to pay more because HE made the decisions he made? He's young and didn't really see the fault in that. That's the mentality in this country today. It's not "fair" that you make more money than me. It doesn't matter that you work harder and are probably smarter than me. Why can't I afford a turbo build for my E30? That's not fair! A turbo in every pot is what I say!


    On a complete side note, why do all the hippies love Apple even though it's an "evil" corporation that uses chinese slave labor?

    Leave a comment:


  • mrsleeve
    replied
    ^

    Again put your money where your ideals and yap are. Pay double or triple what your official tax bill is and then you have room to talk. I work way too hard for my money to give even more than I have too to the govt.


    The "rich" already pay what 9?% of the tax burden in this country really that is not enough?? As far as a flat tax the IRS goes away, and EVERYONE pays 10% no matter who you are or what you make 10% you want fair taxation on the income there it is.

    We should not be taxing productivity in the 1st place its a unnecessary burden, and hampers it. CONSUMPTION is where we need to be placing the burden of taxiation. This way each dollar spent is only taxed 1 fucking time not 5. Eliminate the IRS gas taxes, SSI, Use, severance, and all the other hidden taxes on every thing, and place 9-11% VAT on all retail transactions, other than food. You keep all the money you earn each week, and when you buy shit it GETS EVERYONE, from the drug dealers to the under the table illegals. The VAT will only be at the retail level not each step of supply for the production of products. The feds still get the 12ish % of GDP, the economy will take off, and thrive, the IRS can no longer be used as a weapon against individuals and business unpopular to the powers that be, its a win fucking win. But sadly it will never happen mostly due to the last thing I mentioned.



    To take from one because it is thought that his own industry and that of his father’s has acquired too much, in order to spare to others, who, or whose fathers, have not exercised equal industry and skill, is to violate arbitrarily the first principle of association—the guarantee to every one of a free exercise of his industry and the fruits acquired by it. - Thomas Jefferson
    Last edited by mrsleeve; 09-14-2011, 05:16 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • Schnitzer318is
    replied
    Originally posted by mrsleeve
    Herbie. The. IRS dose accept donations. If you feel as if your not taxed enough you are more than welcome to pay more than you need too.

    I say to all of you that think taxes should be higher put your fucking money wher your yap is a cut the IRS a check for an extra 20k a year.
    If I made $200,000 or more I'd be more than happy to. Unfortunately you are asking a household with a gross income of $70,000 to pay more than the 12% we already do. LOL that would seriously affect our standard of living, which is already plenty modest. ;)

    It's not that we don't think WE (middle class) aren't taxed high enough... it's that we don't think the RICH are taxed high enough.

    I do agree a fair tax is the way to go and abolishing the IRS all together would be a wonderful thing to see in my lifetime. I don't however think our numbers for those brackets would be close at all. We'd probably disagree. ;)

    Historically... taxing the rich does work. The rich stay rich and continue to operate their businesses as usual.

    Leave a comment:


  • gwb72tii
    replied
    Originally posted by herbivor
    Agreed, why don't we go ahead and put the tax rates back to Reagan Era tax rates?
    if congress had some sort of specific law, such as spending being limited to a % of GDP, you could probably lower the rates further

    Leave a comment:


  • herbivor
    replied
    Originally posted by gwb72tii
    all true, but the point you miss is the take the federal government took from GDP was about 19%, where it has been thru the years REGARDLESS of tax rates.
    this was the genius of reagan, that lower tax rates expanded the economy and 19% from a bigger economy resulted in higher rev's to the govt. congress refused to honor its pledge to control spending.
    Agreed, why don't we go ahead and put the tax rates back to Reagan Era tax rates?

    Leave a comment:


  • gwb72tii
    replied
    Originally posted by Morrison
    I'd really miss 20k coming out of my checking account.....I am on R3V after all. On the other hand, if I made 5 million a year, the equivalent of 96 "me's", I doubt I'd even realize it was gone. The top marginal tax rate from 1951 to 1964 was 91% and applied to married couples bringing in more than $400,000. That would be $3,506,864 adjusted for inflation. They also had 25 tax brackets. And the economy was trucking right along.

    My income, adjusted for inflation would have put me in the 20.02% bracket in 1951, about 5% less than I currently owe each year.

    Today our top rate is 35% and applies to all married couples making more than $379,150. We currently have 6 tax brackets. Would it be so bad to add on a few more tax brackets with higher percents that apply to the millionaires and billionaires of our time? And you want to take that down to a single "flat tax" for everyone? What is the correct percentage you feel should apply to everyone?
    all true, but the point you miss is the take the federal government took from GDP was about 19%, where it has been thru the years REGARDLESS of tax rates.
    this was the genius of reagan, that lower tax rates expanded the economy and 19% from a bigger economy resulted in higher rev's to the govt. congress refused to honor its pledge to control spending.

    Leave a comment:


  • Morrison
    replied
    I'd really miss 20k coming out of my checking account.....I am on R3V after all. On the other hand, if I made 5 million a year, the equivalent of 96 "me's", I doubt I'd even realize it was gone. The top marginal tax rate from 1951 to 1964 was 91% and applied to married couples bringing in more than $400,000. That would be $3,506,864 adjusted for inflation. They also had 25 tax brackets. And the economy was trucking right along.

    My income, adjusted for inflation would have put me in the 20.02% bracket in 1951, about 5% less than I currently owe each year.

    Today our top rate is 35% and applies to all married couples making more than $379,150. We currently have 6 tax brackets. Would it be so bad to add on a few more tax brackets with higher percents that apply to the millionaires and billionaires of our time? And you want to take that down to a single "flat tax" for everyone? What is the correct percentage you feel should apply to everyone?
    Last edited by Morrison; 09-14-2011, 04:52 AM.

    Leave a comment:


  • mrsleeve
    replied
    Herbie. The. IRS dose accept donations. If you feel as if your not taxed enough you are more than welcome to pay more than you need too.

    I say to all of you that think taxes should be higher put your fucking money wher your yap is a cut the IRS a check for an extra 20k a year.

    Leave a comment:


  • gwb72tii
    replied
    Originally posted by herbivor
    And here is Elmendorf's opinion of extending the Bush Era Tax cuts:
    “The problem is that if those tax cuts are not accompanied by SUBSTANTIAL FEDERAL SPENDING REDUCTIONS,” the borrowing “crowds out other private investment in productive capital -- in the sorts of equipment, the computers, the machinery, the buildings -- that are the source of long-term economy growth,” Elmendorf told the Senate Budget Committee today according to Bloomberg.
    fixed

    Leave a comment:


  • herbivor
    replied
    And here is Elmendorf's opinion of extending the Bush Era Tax cuts:

    According to the head of the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office, a permanent extension of the Bush-era tax cuts may provide a temporary boost to the U.S. economy, but would then lessen growth by pushing up interest rates.

    Douglas Elmendorf said extending breaks that are supposed to expire at the end of this year would increase demand in the coming years by putting more money in consumers’ pockets, but over the long term the tax cuts would hurt the economy because the government, in their need to finance the loan, would be forced to borrow so much money that it would begin competing with private companies, inevitably driving up interest rates.

    “The problem is that if those tax cuts are not accompanied by other changes in the government budget and are simply funded through borrowing,” the borrowing “crowds out other private investment in productive capital -- in the sorts of equipment, the computers, the machinery, the buildings -- that are the source of long-term economy growth,” Elmendorf told the Senate Budget Committee today according to Bloomberg.

    Unfortunately, Elmendorf said lawmakers cannot avoid this long term issue simply by extending the tax cuts only for individuals whose income is less than $200,000 or $250,000 for couples filing jointly, as President Barack Obama has recommended.

    The President's proposal which covers 97 percent of Americans only reduces the deficit by about 25 percent more than the Republican counterpart.

    “Extending all the tax cuts except for those higher-income people has three-quarters or four-fifths, roughly, of the positive effects and the negative effects of extending all of the tax cuts,” he said.

    Elmendorf said lawmakers could only avoid higher interest rates in the future if the tax cuts were paired with reduced spending or higher tax revenue from another source. Any large increases in government spending would have the same long term effect on interest rates.

    The United States is in the midst of a budget crisis. The spending cuts being proposed by the Republicans would have drastic effects on many Americans and fails to even come close to reducing the budget as much as this administration's proposal. Despite this, Obama's plan still falls short of solving the problem.

    America needs major tax reform whose sole purpose is to fix the budget. The best way for America to achieve this goal is by implementing a “national sales” or value-added tax. A VAT would not only go a long way toward balancing our budget and reducing America's debt, but would serve the further purpose of partially balancing America's trade deficit and increasing the rate of savings. Furthermore, a VAT would have a less detrimental effect on the U.S. economy when compared to the income tax. Major tax reform is necessary and a VAT provides the “least worst solution.” We may not like it, but it's really the only choice we have at this point.

    Leave a comment:


  • herbivor
    replied
    Doug Elmendorf, head of the CBO, gave some advice to the super committe today. The full article is below with highlights of his recommendations in quotes.



    “There is no commonly agreed upon level of federal debt that is sustainable or optimal,” Elmendorf said, according to prepared remarks. “At a minimum, federal debt cannot continually increase as a share of the economy because the interest payments on that debt would then continually grow relative to the size of the tax base that would be available for generating revenues to cover those payments and all of the other activities of the government.”

    The “supercommittee” has been charged with cutting the deficit by $1.2 trillion to $1.5 trillion by Thanksgiving or risk automatic cuts to agencies and entitlement programs. But some lawmakers, business leaders and others have urged it to be more ambitious. Elmendorf said if the committee achieves its $1.2 trillion goal, public debt would drop from 67 to 61 percent of the gross domestic product by 2021.

    To reduce the public debt to 50 percent of the nation’s total economic output, the same level recorded in the mid-1990s, the committee would have to find $3.8 trillion instead.

    Elmendorf told the group that their choices for achieving deficit reduction, as has been widely agreed, include raising federal tax revenues significantly, making major changes to benefits to older Americans or substantially reducing the size of the government relative to the size of the economy.

    “The nation cannot continue to sustain the spending programs and policies of the past with the tax revenues it has been accustomed to paying,” he said, according to prepared remarks. “Citizens will either have to pay more for their government, accept less in government services and benefits, or both.”

    Leave a comment:


  • joshh
    replied
    This is a good spot for this.


    http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/...deral-revenue/


    By 2003, Mr. Bush grasped this lesson. In that year, he cut the dividend and capital gains rates to 15 percent each, and the economy responded. In two years, stocks rose 20 percent. In three years, $15 trillion of new wealth was created. The U.S. economy added 8 million new jobs from mid-2003 to early 2007, and the median household increased its wealth by $20,000 in real terms.

    But the real jolt for tax-cutting opponents was that the 03 Bush tax cuts also generated a massive increase in federal tax receipts. From 2004 to 2007, federal tax revenues increased by $785 billion, the largest four-year increase in American history. According to the Treasury Department, individual and corporate income tax receipts were up 40 percent in the three years following the Bush tax cuts. And (bonus) the rich paid an even higher percentage of the total tax burden than they had at any time in at least the previous 40 years. This was news to theNew York Times, whose astonished editorial board could only describe the gains as a “surprise windfall.”

    Unfortunately, Mr. Bush allowed Congress to spend away those additional tax revenues. The fact is that the increase in tax revenues that flowed from the ‘03 tax cuts could have paid for the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq and then some but for rampant discretionary domestic spending.

    Ironically, Mr. Obama is in danger of repeating Mr. Bush’s early economic missteps, albeit on a grander scale. Like Mr. Bush in 2001, Mr. Obama based much of his ill-fated stimulus package on tax rebates but compounded this error by sending checks to Americans with no tax liability and by adding in costly government make-work projects. He also increased discretionary spending in his first year in office faster than Mr. Bush, all the while proposing a trillion-dollar health care plan and a financially ruinous cap-and-trade bill. He is now calling for a “jobs bill,” which is the White House’s new lingo for a second Keynesian-style stimulus (or third, counting Mr. Bush’s 2008 stimulus), pushing the 2010 deficit to an all-time record level.

    Worse still, Mr. Obama’s $3.8 trillion budget for 2011 would allow the Bush tax cuts to expire, imposing new prosperity-killing taxes on businesses, investors and individuals. The president would do better to follow his predecessor and embrace the winning strategy of supply-side tax cuts. He even might find that Americans would welcome this new story line. After all, liberal economic fairy tales are growing tiresome, even for Massachusians.

    Taxation is not the answer for this economic situation. Stop the ridiculous spending is. That includes the wars of course.

    Leave a comment:


  • gwb72tii
    replied
    Originally posted by mrsleeve
    ^

    by decreasing spending and stop threatening and regulating industry/business to beat hell you will increase revenue without having to do shit to the to the tax code up or down.

    All though I think it needs a huge reform to the point of eliminating the IRS and going to a Fair tax or Flat tax and getting rid off the income taxes in totality
    agreed and correct
    higher tax rates have never resulted in more revenue to the fed
    lower rates have
    and the good thing about a consumption tax is everyone will have skin in the game

    Leave a comment:


  • mrsleeve
    replied
    I know you do ;)

    Leave a comment:


  • Vedubin01
    replied
    Originally posted by mrsleeve
    ^

    by decreasing spending and stop threatening and regulating industry/business to beat hell you will increase revenue without having to do shit to the to the tax code up or down.

    All though I think it needs a huge reform to the point of eliminating the IRS and going to a Fair tax or Flat tax and getting rid off the income taxes in totality

    I concur :)

    Leave a comment:

Working...