S50 or S52

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • BimmerScreamer
    replied
    Originally posted by nando

    an ix drivetrain in good condition can handle hundreds of drag launches in the 200-300hp range. you aren't going to break something driving to the grocery store unless it was broken already.

    can I quote you on that, haha

    Leave a comment:


  • nando
    replied
    it's about 145lbs heavier. the weight varies by year, earlier cars were actually heavier than later ones (this is true of all E30s). no trunk tar in '91, for example.

    an ix drivetrain in good condition can handle hundreds of drag launches in the 200-300hp range. you aren't going to break something driving to the grocery store unless it was broken already.

    Leave a comment:


  • BimmerScreamer
    replied
    i saw some where that the iX weights 2988lbs, i dont know what the weight is of the RWD. The weak links seem to be the splines of the front shaft going into the transfer case, these seem to get rusty and than round off. I have also heard that the front diff doesn't like torque. Keeping this in mind I'm not going to punch it off the line and wait till I'm rolling to get on it, much like any car with power. The stress on those parts is a lot more if I accelerate from a low speed than mat it at a higher speed.

    Leave a comment:


  • rThor432
    replied
    Originally posted by Widm3r
    A swapped e30 with a 3.0 should not have any issues taking out an e46 m3
    I just said "probably" because he's talking about an iX, which I'm not terribly familiar with. I dont know how the extra weight and the spline-stripping components affect it compared to a standard rear wheel drive E30.

    Leave a comment:


  • BimmerScreamer
    replied
    I have never considered an M50 and I don't see why I would, if I'm putting out this money I want a S5x motor. I also figure if and when my iX awd dies I can just buy a RWD and through the motor in there if I want. I'm pretty sure this motor will out last the car.

    Leave a comment:


  • MDryVur
    replied
    Originally posted by nando
    at a cost of about $700 from the dealer, and you'd need to use a 525ix diff (which doesn't have compatible E30 ratios), haflshafts, hubs, etc. I wish this would die, along with the 525ix 5-lug swap. None of the drivetrain or parts are the same, they're rarer than hens teeth used and cost a fortune new.

    it would cost about $200 to modify the ix oil pan, it's uncomplicated and you should be able to use the E36 pick up tube.

    if it were me, I'd go with the S52 - wider power band, torquier, just a better motor all around.

    an M50 ix would be a complete waste of time.
    ahhh .... thats why i did the rwd conversion...

    thanks nando.

    Leave a comment:


  • nando
    replied
    Originally posted by MDryVur
    if im not mistaken you should be able to get a factory oil pan off an e34 525ix.... i remember this from e3024v.com the guys up in UK were telling me this
    at a cost of about $700 from the dealer, and you'd need to use a 525ix diff (which doesn't have compatible E30 ratios), haflshafts, hubs, etc. I wish this would die, along with the 525ix 5-lug swap. None of the drivetrain or parts are the same, they're rarer than hens teeth used and cost a fortune new.

    it would cost about $200 to modify the ix oil pan, it's uncomplicated and you should be able to use the E36 pick up tube.

    if it were me, I'd go with the S52 - wider power band, torquier, just a better motor all around.

    an M50 ix would be a complete waste of time.

    Leave a comment:


  • gazellebeigem3
    replied
    s50s are for assholes

    Leave a comment:


  • MDryVur
    replied
    if im not mistaken you should be able to get a factory oil pan off an e34 525ix.... i remember this from e3024v.com the guys up in UK were telling me this

    Leave a comment:


  • MDryVur
    replied
    Originally posted by Jesse30
    s52 obd 1 is a much better route. please dont tell me you're going to be like the last tool on here and convert your IX to rear wheel drive too.

    ayy thats me.... lol parts went to good use...

    Leave a comment:


  • Widm3r
    replied
    Originally posted by rThor432
    Meh I'd go with an OBD-1 converted M52. They are plenty fast, and have great torque. If your E46 M3 is the "fast car" I'd just go with the M52 for the iX.

    An S50 iX will probably be faster than the E46, which might make the E46 disappointing to drive
    :D.
    A swapped e30 with a 3.0 should not have any issues taking out an e46 m3

    Leave a comment:


  • e30polak
    replied
    Originally posted by e30s52
    /\ Thats what e30this did and from the videos I looked like his car was a really good bang for your buck.
    No his was an m50 with s52 cams, 540 hfm, 21.5 injectors, and a tune. And yes that car pulled really hard for what it was!

    the thread:

    Leave a comment:


  • e30s52
    replied
    /\ Thats what e30this did and from the videos I looked like his car was a really good bang for your buck.

    Leave a comment:


  • e30polak
    replied
    Originally posted by rThor432
    Meh I'd go with an OBD-1 converted M52. They are plenty fast, and have great torque. If your E46 M3 is the "fast car" I'd just go with the M52 for the iX.

    An S50 iX will probably be faster than the E46, which might make the E46 disappointing to drive :D.
    A properly tuned obd1 m52 with s52 cams would be on par with an s50. :p

    Leave a comment:


  • rThor432
    replied
    Meh I'd go with an OBD-1 converted M52. They are plenty fast, and have great torque. If your E46 M3 is the "fast car" I'd just go with the M52 for the iX.

    An S50 iX will probably be faster than the E46, which might make the E46 disappointing to drive :D.

    Leave a comment:

Working...