You can get good peak numbers out of them. I've seen a '93 325is with M3 cams/valvetrain, AA intake/exhaust and a good AA tune do 195-200whp. That motor screams from just over 4000 to 7000 and does 7500 on the top. Peak torque was 151 or 152 at the wheels at close to 5000. I'd say you are right about cost/horsepower; but that's all topend. I'd venture to say that the same motor with a 328i crank would do 40-45 more ft/lbs at the wheels at a lower RPM. But...a cam/injector/intake change is much easier than pulling the motor to swap cranks and build the bottomend!
200hp out of M20
Collapse
X
-
Me and my buddy are just about done with our m50 swap with s52 cams. the m50 only cost us 900 bucks, the motor mounts, trans, brake booster, electric fan, drive shaft work, e36 calipers and rotors, oil pan, new lifters and trays for the cams and probably like two other things cost us just around 1700.
but then we also we have the head port and polished, with a 3 angle valve job, and a dinan chip to open it up. so were shooting for some were around the 200 whpComment
-
'89 325is S50 Track Montser
'04 X5 Daily/Tow Vehicle
http://www.avarestoration.com
http://www.myspace.com/brendanfiddle
Click here if you want to be my zombie slave...
http://www.youtube.com/user/Fidhle007
Comment
-
Fidhle,
Gear ratios are free, so 4.10s are a must. I'm still waiting to find out on the swap question. It might come down to a completely stock M50 or having some room for stroking/cams in an M20. Going up in displacement slightly does not cost that many points, but a 3.1 stroker wouldn't work.
It seems that everybody still thinks a stock M50 would be the way to go through.
Alex.Comment
-
I love my m50 in comparison to my m20. My 2380lb track car has a m20, the 2800lb daily driver has the m50. They are both Dinan chipped with identical headers and 2.5" exhaust. Getrag 260/3.73 LSD in both as well.
The torque down low on the m50 is awesome. It pulls stronger up top as well though. Just for comparison sake: My m50 car (remember, 400lb heavier), ran a 14.4@94. My m20 car ran a 15.4@89.
The track car will likely get an m3 cammed m50 down the road, and the DD will get M3 cams as well. The torque of the s52 isn't worth the extra initial cost of the engine IMO. I've driven an OBD-1 s52 e30, and while the power is nice, it's not THAT nice. It's still not 'fast' IMO. I'd still get blown away on the straights by anyone with 400+hp. And I'm not going to spend $3k+ on a motor and not be fast. I'd rather build a 5.0 foxbody and do a Griggs suspension and destroy any e30 :)Comment
-
The disadvantages of building a race M20 compared to a stock M50 are:
- less reliability (broken rocker arms; oil starvation)
- more maintenance (valve timing adjustments; timing belts)
- more custom work ($$$)
- narrower power-band
Overall, swapping in a complete M50 is the easy and cheap solution. Getting a race M20 to run properly isnt trivial, especially if you're stuck with crap California gas. There are lots of hidden expenses: you'll want to ditch the cap & rotor ignition; the intake manifold and AFM are highly restrictive; you'll need aftermarket engine management; etc.
Even if you can do all of this work yourself, you'll be facing lots of little problems/challenges along the way.sigpic
1987 Mercedes 190E 2.3-16: Vintage Racer
2010 BMW (E90) 335xi sedan: Grocery GetterComment
-
So if the swap moves me up to TTD, then I'm back at trying to figure out a way to get some decent power out of M20 without going too far.
PS - Jim, I know all about a built M20. Just ask me for the copy of the BRE bill...However, look at my recent lap times, almost 2 seconds better!The car makes it possible, but the driver makes it happen.
Jim Levie, Huntsville, ALComment
-
Jim,
Not sure about CMP, since it is not HP bias like some others, but I imagine you'll see at least 1 second at RA, maybe even more.
Yeah, I know about the stock rebuild of M20. Starting to lean more and more towards M50, but of course have to wait on the series director's response.Comment
-
Well, 325IS is getting bumped up for next year to TTE, so a swap will push me up to TTD, which frankly I don't want to do. So now I'm back to getting good and usable power out of M20. Plan for right now is for 284 or 288 Schrick cam and supporting boltons. At the end of the day I'm ok with less then 200hp, just would like a good 4-6K power band.Comment
-
Well, 325IS is getting bumped up for next year to TTE, so a swap will push me up to TTD, which frankly I don't want to do. So now I'm back to getting good and usable power out of M20. Plan for right now is for 284 or 288 Schrick cam and supporting boltons. At the end of the day I'm ok with less then 200hp, just would like a good 4-6K power band.Comment
-
Comment