What's wrong with Bosch +4 Platinum plugs?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • u3b3rg33k
    R3VLimited
    • Jan 2010
    • 2452

    #16
    Originally posted by dnguyen1963
    Not sure if this is true, but when I observed the spark plug outside of the engine, the spark moved around the prongs randomly. Not all 4 prongs received spark at the same time.
    Nor will they ever. Having 4 gaps just gives more room for the combustion to spread outward.

    Ich gehöre nicht zur Baader-Meinhof Gruppe

    Originally posted by Top Gear
    Just imagine waking up and remembering you're Mexican.

    Every time you buy a car with DSC/ESC, Jesus kills a baby seal. With a kitten.


    Comment

    • priapism
      E30 Enthusiast
      • Mar 2010
      • 1182

      #17
      Originally posted by bernzpeed
      It's all hear say. I'm using them on 2 e30s, absolutely no problems at all.


      Sent from my HERO200 using Tapatalk

      I don't think it's so much about "problems" as it is about how they affect combustion.
      sigpic
      -Sean : 91 Calypso 325i : Castro Motorsports SoCal Spec E30 #33

      Comment

      • xwill112x
        Θέλησα έναν τίτλο συνήθειας, απορροφώ για να είμ&#
        • Jan 2009
        • 4237

        #18
        Originally posted by priapism
        I don't think it's so much about "problems" as it is about how they affect combustion.
        If your engine is healthy how could it affect it? A blue spark is a blue spark, and it all ignites the same.
        sigpic

        Comment

        • dnguyen1963
          R3VLimited
          • Nov 2011
          • 2648

          #19
          Originally posted by priapism
          I don't think it's so much about "problems" as it is about how they affect combustion.
          Well, if it affects the combustion...let's say incomplete combustion...would you not observe hesitation during acceleration? Gasoline is extremely combustible, a single spark will ignite the gas and burn it all. I do not see how it would affect combustion. Truly, I have not seen any difference whatsoever since I switched to +4 four months ago.

          Comment

          • xwill112x
            Θέλησα έναν τίτλο συνήθειας, απορροφώ για να είμ&#
            • Jan 2009
            • 4237

            #20
            Originally posted by dnguyen1963
            Well, if it affects the combustion...let's say incomplete combustion...would you not observe hesitation during acceleration? Gasoline is extremely combustible, a single spark will ignite the gas and burn it all. I do not see how it would affect combustion. Truly, I have not seen any difference whatsoever since I switched to +4 four months ago.
            But thats not even the case, the fact that it has 4 places to arc from, gives it so much chance to have a better spark than a plug with only 1 prong. Even stock OEM plugs for a m50 is 2 pronged. So how could more chance for a better arc equal up to incomplete combustion?
            sigpic

            Comment

            • dnguyen1963
              R3VLimited
              • Nov 2011
              • 2648

              #21
              Originally posted by xwill112x
              but thats not even the case, the fact that it has 4 places to arc from, gives it so much chance to have a better spark than a plug with only 1 prong. Even stock oem plugs for a m50 is 2 pronged. So how could more chance for a better arc equal up to incomplete combustion?

              qft.

              Comment

              • u3b3rg33k
                R3VLimited
                • Jan 2010
                • 2452

                #22
                that's what the marketing says, but if you believe everything marketing tells you, you're running pulse-stars.

                Ich gehöre nicht zur Baader-Meinhof Gruppe

                Originally posted by Top Gear
                Just imagine waking up and remembering you're Mexican.

                Every time you buy a car with DSC/ESC, Jesus kills a baby seal. With a kitten.


                Comment

                • xwill112x
                  Θέλησα έναν τίτλο συνήθειας, απορροφώ για να είμ&#
                  • Jan 2009
                  • 4237

                  #23
                  Not marketing, Those are solid facts I have pointed out in this thread. Not something someone told me.
                  sigpic

                  Comment

                  • kamotors
                    R3V OG
                    • Nov 2007
                    • 7102

                    #24
                    I had them for 4 years w/ zero issues, only fouled when I turbo-ed the car.


                    7speedshop.com

                    Comment

                    • nando
                      Moderator
                      • Nov 2003
                      • 34827

                      #25
                      Originally posted by xwill112x
                      But thats not even the case, the fact that it has 4 places to arc from, gives it so much chance to have a better spark than a plug with only 1 prong. Even stock OEM plugs for a m50 is 2 pronged. So how could more chance for a better arc equal up to incomplete combustion?
                      facepalm
                      Build thread

                      Bimmerlabs

                      Comment

                      • smooth
                        E30 Mastermind
                        • Apr 2005
                        • 1940

                        #26
                        Originally posted by xwill112x
                        But thats not even the case, the fact that it has 4 places to arc from, gives it so much chance to have a better spark than a plug with only 1 prong. Even stock OEM plugs for a m50 is 2 pronged. So how could more chance for a better arc equal up to incomplete combustion?
                        the material is different though. platinum has different characteristics than silver or copper so when most people talk about incomplete combustion I believe the concern is more about what it's made from rather than the shape/design of it. Not being able to gap the plugs also concerns some people.

                        You'll get a lot of interesting commentary, though, if you don't follow conventional wisdom. Apparently even things like pointing out that multi-pronged plugs are non-indexed (they're actually *self* indexing) pass muster to some people because, you know uh, marketing :|
                        Das ist nicht nur nicht richtig, es ist nicht einmal falsch!

                        Comment

                        • u3b3rg33k
                          R3VLimited
                          • Jan 2010
                          • 2452

                          #27
                          Originally posted by xwill112x
                          But thats not even the case, the fact that it has 4 places to arc from, gives it so much chance to have a better spark than a plug with only 1 prong. Even stock OEM plugs for a m50 is 2 pronged. So how could more chance for a better arc equal up to incomplete combustion?
                          No. Chance is not related to potential surfaces to arc to. in theory, you could arc from the electrode to the top of the piston - but you won't, electricity takes the shortest, easiest path possible every time. if they're all perfectly spaced from the center, at best the path will be random.

                          If anything, the benefit of the +4 style might be that if it's perfectly centered in the bore, the flame front can propagate down towards the piston - or is it out towards the walls - or is it yes?

                          Maybe. Or it can propagate outwards radially more easily.

                          But what's best? Who really knows? probably the team that designed the engine - if they bothered at all. I'm sure F1 cars have expensive plugs.



                          some of that engineery stuff:
                          Last edited by u3b3rg33k; 02-02-2012, 08:47 PM.

                          Ich gehöre nicht zur Baader-Meinhof Gruppe

                          Originally posted by Top Gear
                          Just imagine waking up and remembering you're Mexican.

                          Every time you buy a car with DSC/ESC, Jesus kills a baby seal. With a kitten.


                          Comment

                          • 0000000000
                            E30 Addict
                            • Nov 2006
                            • 473

                            #28
                            formula one cars use these http://www.f1-2000.co.uk/index.php?f=ignition_system

                            From first hand experience having brand new Bosch +4 is vs used denso coppers. The difference is in gas mileage, the denso that were in my m20 ran better gas mileage. When I stuck the +4s in it wend down about 2 to 5 mpg. I went back and immediately bought some new denso coppers and changed them and mileage was a noticeable difference.

                            Friend of mine on E30tech used them on his 16PSI M20. He had the same set up he started with old denso coppers and when he went to the bosch +4 it tended to flood the car. I told him to go back and buy new denso coppers or any kind of copper that isn't that cheap (aka meaning brand wise, like fuck ac delco or champions or any of that bull shit noise. He also bought the same ones I did and gaped it and the car ran like a champ.


                            This is my experiece for bosch +4 or any kind of platinum in car.
                            after this experience... I will never stick any kind of platinum anything in cars. My .02

                            Comment

                            • u3b3rg33k
                              R3VLimited
                              • Jan 2010
                              • 2452

                              #29
                              Here's a more relevant vid than I posted before:

                              Ich gehöre nicht zur Baader-Meinhof Gruppe

                              Originally posted by Top Gear
                              Just imagine waking up and remembering you're Mexican.

                              Every time you buy a car with DSC/ESC, Jesus kills a baby seal. With a kitten.


                              Comment

                              • Vtec?lol
                                No R3VLimiter
                                • Dec 2009
                                • 3278

                                #30
                                It's more so about the core and the gap. Forget how many prongs it has. The M20 will run superb on copper cores and I'm guessing that;s because the coil and ecu were designed for the copper cores.
                                I had platinum 2 prong plugs and my car sucked balls at idle, went back to cheapo champion coppers and it's smooth!

                                Comment

                                Working...