Differences in stock springs for s vs non-s cars?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Marvin_Hecht
    Wrencher
    • Jan 2005
    • 220

    #1

    Differences in stock springs for s vs non-s cars?

    OK ... I have an 86 325e with stock springs and my (for now) parts
    car is a 86 325es. Is there any use in swapping the springs over?

    Are the OEM springs from s models any different? I know they are
    the same height, but are they stiffer?
    '86 325 original owner for 20 years * SOLD *
    '86 325es * SOLD *
    '05 Honday Odyssey Minivan.
  • nando
    Moderator
    • Nov 2003
    • 34827

    #2
    no point. springs don't wear out either, unless they rust and break.
    Build thread

    Bimmerlabs

    Comment

    • Marvin_Hecht
      Wrencher
      • Jan 2005
      • 220

      #3
      I know that springs are hard to break -- despite that my car has had a broken spring not too long ago -- but what I was wanting to know for
      sure is .. did BMW put in a different OEM spring in the S model than the non-S model? They call it a "sports suspension" for the "sports package" and they had some kind of Bilsteins in there stock (I think they are HD's or stock-length sports) but are the springs "sport" springs?
      '86 325 original owner for 20 years * SOLD *
      '86 325es * SOLD *
      '05 Honday Odyssey Minivan.

      Comment

      • Bimmerfanatik
        Banned
        • May 2004
        • 5349

        #4
        Originally posted by Marvin_Hecht
        I know that springs are hard to break -- despite that my car has had a broken spring not too long ago -- but what I was wanting to know for
        sure is .. did BMW put in a different OEM spring in the S model than the non-S model? They call it a "sports suspension" for the "sports package" and they had some kind of Bilsteins in there stock (I think they are HD's or stock-length sports) but are the springs "sport" springs?
        This one is a toss up. I've heard the ES/IS springs are shorter, but haven't compared the two off the car. I will, soon, and will be able to confirm finally.

        You could also check the ETK and see if the PN's are the same...

        Here's some evidence that the rears at least may not be. From strictlyeta.net:
        Any model with an "s" suffix, such as 318is, 325es, and 325is, denotes the sport model, which only came in 2-door form...featured thicker swaybars, slightly stiffer shocks and front springs...

        Comment

        • JRowe
          Grease Monkey
          • Oct 2003
          • 352

          #5
          Don't bother. While there may be slight difference, it isn't worth the work to change them. The difference may not even be noticable given the age of the suspension. Go with some aftermarket springs and bilstein sports for a fun, streetable suspension. You see them used pretty frequently on this and other sites.

          Comment

          • Digitalwave
            is a poseur
            • Oct 2003
            • 6277

            #6
            Originally posted by JRowe
            Don't bother. While there may be slight difference, it isn't worth the work to change them. The difference may not even be noticable given the age of the suspension. Go with some aftermarket springs and bilstein sports for a fun, streetable suspension. You see them used pretty frequently on this and other sites.
            Agreed. Definately not worth the effort to switch to stock junk.

            RISING EDGE

            Let's drive fast and have fun.

            Comment

            Working...