If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.
thanks guys i have a 1991 318is with koni single adjustable ground control springs 16" style5, was stuck on between swapping my e30 or buying a e36 m3 and supercharging it
even the earliest S50 swapped E30's were faster than an E46 M3. I'm thinking Stu here...
A fully done S50/S52 can keep up to a point. My S50 E30, which dynos at 215ish rwhp on a dyno that is generally known for reading low, is roughly 15-20mph slower down the main straight at Summit Point. (The E46 would redline 4th and spend some time in 5th for around 150MPH.)
A well driven E46 M3 is flat out going to be faster. With the right driver, a stock E46 with DRs can get into the high 12s. And it will consistently run low 13s with competent, but normal drivers.
You won't make friends with post like that! Swapped E30 > E36
Hell, for the amount of money you'd spend supercharging an E36 M3, you could swap and supercharge/turbo your E30.
Not true. Supercharging an E36 M3 with a good kit and good parts (gauges, clutch, tune, 3" exhaust etc) costs about $4-6k. S50 swap on an E30 costs $4-6k at least and then another $4-6k on top of that for boost.
E36 M3 is also a much more stable platform for boost and easier to fit wide tires on.
RIP: Delphin '89 E30 with S50 swap and lots of goodies :'(
Then: '04 Evo 8 RS, 500 whp/420 wtq 2900 lb E85 AWD turbo shits 'n giggles
Not true. Supercharging an E36 M3 with a good kit and good parts (gauges, clutch, tune, 3" exhaust etc) costs about $4-6k. S50 swap on an E30 costs $4-6k at least and then another $4-6k on top of that for boost.
E36 M3 is also a much more stable platform for boost and easier to fit wide tires on.
Not to mention the e36 m3 has way better rear suspension.
Not true. Supercharging an E36 M3 with a good kit and good parts (gauges, clutch, tune, 3" exhaust etc) costs about $4-6k. S50 swap on an E30 costs $4-6k at least and then another $4-6k on top of that for boost.
Not true. It would even out in the end, he already has the e30, not the e36.
E30
S5x Swap: $4,000
Boost: $5,000
Total: $9k-$10k
E36
+$3-$4,000 for selling his current e30
$6-$9,000 for an e36 M3
Supercharger/Turbo: $5,000
Taking the median price for a decent E36 M3 $7,500+$5,000 for boost.
Total minus the sale of the e30 $9k-$10k
Comment