the conceit of central banks

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • gwb72tii
    replied
    so the fact the SF fed economists produced an analysis that suggested QE2 had virtually no economic benefit means exactly what? that i was wrong to suggest bernanke is an egomaniac?

    Leave a comment:


  • Farbin Kaiber
    replied
    A lot of people too preoccupied with the trees to stop and realize they are in a forest.

    Leave a comment:


  • rwh11385
    replied
    Originally posted by nando
    Btw, george... how are those rising yields treating your bond portfolios? Is it ironic that the policies that you hate (or the man, i cant tell from all your hubris) are what gave you the bond run that made you money the last few years? And now that its over, the end of those same despised policies are now hurting your overweight bond strategy?


    Originally posted by gwb72tii
    actually my narrow sighted friend, we prepare for and anticipate losses. asset classes move in differnt directions all the time. its part of investing.
    and the fed has not exited.

    what lie?

    and austerity is a result of government spending
    Ironic you calling someone narrow sighted. . .

    You did a really good job preparing for and anticipating losses of your emerging market debt... [that was sarcasm, btw, since you have a hard time picking up on it] Did you also anticipate losing money last year by going long VIX and shorting the S&P500 when the opposite would have been the right call?

    The lie that all of the GOP budget plans and European austerity were based upon and a subject you have been too chicken to comment on... [See economic fools thread]

    Originally posted by BraveUlysses
    He's referring to the error in rogoff and reinhart's austerity study, pretty sure rwh pointed it out to you months ago but i'm shocked you aren't aware of it.


    http://www.newyorker.com/online/blog...umming-up.html
    Pretty much why people who run around with opinions based on biased news that sounds good to them (but is actually wrong) is dangerous. This is especially true with an uneducated populace who are misguided in economics or science by misinformation-filled media and don't know any better in regards to obtain understanding on their own. If people were actually informed, capable of basic logic, and had the care to fact check on their own, then society would be far better off instead of a bunch of closed-minded and ignorant folk.

    You'd think with a better ability to access information with the internet that more people could research subjects and be informed in this day and age... but the trouble is people who seek out opinions that mirror their own and are ingrained with bias instead of learning how to form opinions based on facts. When someone seeks out echo chambers, that is what their head becomes.

    Leave a comment:


  • rwh11385
    replied
    Originally posted by matthugie
    You know, I've read a few of your threads, and at no point in any of them have you made a coherent point. You spout out numbers like that somehow "proves" your point, but you've never stated what your point is. You aren't forming any sort of case for your argument, you're just spouting numbers that may or may not be related to each other. And if they are related they're often taken out of context and in a limited scope. Your OP here has a semblance of a point, but is by no means coherent and so oversimplified it's basically meaningless. Just because numbers are related doesn't establish correlation, especially when ignoring all other factors.

    Also, you love to bash Bernanke and the administration as a whole claiming they are "economic fools" and whatnot, but you never proffer any sort of alternative solution. You say what they're doing "wrong" but never what you think would be the appropriate action. I'm really quite curious as to what your economic theory is, since it must obviously be better than that of a large team of Ph.D. economists and use better research than the NBER. And you talk about an ego the size of Alaska and conceit...


    Nailed it.

    Leave a comment:


  • rwh11385
    replied
    So, like the global cooling thread... why the heck did you need to start a new thread? You create new one with some random, poorly composed rambling instead of continuing a prior discussion.

    Originally posted by gwb72tii
    so a seat of the pants obeservation
    I don't think you need to say that... pretty much every comment you make lacks any critical thinking.

    Originally posted by gwb72tii
    today Barclay's cut Q2 GDP estimate to 0.4%, Goldman to 1.3%
    That's interesting that you revel in bad forecasts of growth, but does your outlook change now that the 2nd look by the BEA ended up at 2.5% (the level that joshh thinks is "growing enough to be growing")?

    Originally posted by gwb72tii
    and some want to blame the "sequester" which isn't a sequester at all, its a reduction in the rate of growth of the government


    So whatever term you'd want to refer to it... (even though government spending was cut not just slowed in growth) check out its impact on GDP. Your words are worthless, try backing them up with data, facts, etc.

    Originally posted by gwb72tii
    so, where do we go from here, with europe in a depression (Germany is merely in a recession),
    http://www.ibtimes.co.uk/articles/50...nd-quarter.htm
    Eurozone Recovery Gathers Pace as Recession Exit Confirmed

    What about some other data points?
    http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-0...6-from-56.html
    ISM August Non-Manufacturing Index Rose to 58.6 From 56
    Service industries in the U.S. expanded in August at the fastest pace in almost eight years as a pickup in demand encouraged companies to step up hiring, showing the world’s biggest economy is gaining momentum.
    The Institute for Supply Management’s non-manufacturing index increased to 58.6 from 56 the prior month, the Tempe, Arizona-based group said today. The August figure, which exceeded the median forecast of 55, was the strongest since December 2005

    U.S. August ISM Index: Manufacturing Expands at Fastest Pace in 2 Years



    http://www.business-standard.com/art...1000204_1.html
    China output data reinforces view economy has steadied
    Factory output growth hit a 17-month high and retail sales grew at their fastest pace this year in August


    In U.S., China, Europe, data points to global rebound

    Instead of gwb's idea that the EU and China would drag the US down, it seems that nando had a better vision:

    Originally posted by nando
    Europe looks pretty dang ugly to me, and china is pretty shadowy. I actually think the USA is what will pull us out of this. Assuming Washington doesn't totally screw it up.. which is a big risk, of course.
    Originally posted by nando
    There is irony in what is happening that nobody thought would happen - the rest of the world is falling behind and the USA the becoming main driver behind the global recovery (even if it's slower than ideal). Everyone expected us to stagnate and China to take over.. except 1/3rd of China's economy relies on the EU, and we all know how well it's going over there.
    And we've made strives to recover our competitiveness globally:
    http://www.businessweek.com/news/201...t-germany-gain
    Switzerland Still Most Competitive Economy as U.S., Germany Gain
    Switzerland held the top spot for a fifth year, while Germany and the U.S. rose two slots to fourth and fifth respectively in the Geneva-based organization’s 148-nation league. Singapore and Finland retained their second and third positions.
    As emerging-market economies weaken, only Russia of the so-called BRIC nations improved its standing by climbing three places to 64th. China held on to the 29th rank, Brazil fell eight slots to 56th and India slipped one place to 60th.

    Leave a comment:


  • gwb72tii
    replied
    "I worry about the effects on the long-run stability and efficiency of our financial system if the Fed attempts to substitute its judgments for those of the market. Such a regime would only increase the unhealthy tendency of investors to pay more attention to rumors about policymakers' attitudes than to the economic fundamentals that by rights should determine the allocation of capital." - Ben Bernanke, October 15, 2002

    oh really...........

    why anyone believes a word this guy says is surprising
    Last edited by gwb72tii; 07-25-2013, 11:59 AM.

    Leave a comment:


  • Fusion
    replied

    Leave a comment:


  • matthugie
    replied
    Herbivore, probably better through PM, but may I inquire as to who you're referring to? I know quite a few people from that program (assuming you're referring to the institution in University).

    Leave a comment:


  • herbivor
    replied
    My friend has a PHD in economics and is a professor at the nearby university. When asked how many economists tend to agree with each other about economic actions, he said at least 80%, most of them agree with a Kensyian type approach in times of recession. The austerity cuts in Europe was dumb, as is austerity here, according to him and the majority of economists. Unless you study economics, you really have no expertise on how it all works. Ideological positions have no merit amongst math and science.
    the GOP in NC are cutting money to education, raising taxes on the poor and lowering them for the rich, trying to kill green energy programs, opting out of the ACA benefits, and doing all the ideological things that a hard right Republican could ever want. It is a grand experiment of austerity and stupidity. We'll see how it plays out in the next few years.

    Leave a comment:


  • nando
    replied
    Originally posted by z31maniac
    http://www.theaustralian.com.au/opin...-1226642391718

    There are plenty more stories of how Estonia took the beating up front, got it over with, and now are back on the path to growth.
    and Iceland and Ireland. there are certainly times when it has worked.

    What about the rest of the EU? how many consecutive quarters has Greece been shrinking now?

    George is arguing that it would have worked here, that allowing our economy to fall into a deflationary death spiral would have been better. because obviously, the conservatives would have come in and saved the day with lower taxes for the 1%. :p

    Leave a comment:


  • BraveUlysses
    replied
    Originally posted by gwb72tii
    actually my narrow sighted friend, we prepare for and anticipate losses. asset classes move in differnt directions all the time. its part of investing.
    and the fed has not exited.

    what lie?

    and austerity is a result of government spending
    He's referring to the error in rogoff and reinhart's austerity study, pretty sure rwh pointed it out to you months ago but i'm shocked you aren't aware of it.


    In one of life’s little ironies, last Friday’s disappointing G.D.P. figures, which reflected a sharp fall in government spending, appeared on the same …

    Leave a comment:


  • z31maniac
    replied
    Originally posted by nando
    but the fed exit is what cost you money, and is in reality why you are so pissed.

    hey, how is all that austerity working for the EU? oh, they're in a depression you say? and it turns out the theory it was based on was a lie? oops..

    still waiting for the grand republican jobs/economy plan...
    http://www.theaustralian.com.au/opin...-1226642391718

    There are plenty more stories of how Estonia took the beating up front, got it over with, and now are back on the path to growth.

    Leave a comment:


  • gwb72tii
    replied
    Originally posted by nando
    but the fed exit is what cost you money, and is in reality why you are so pissed.

    hey, how is all that austerity working for the EU? oh, they're in a depression you say? and it turns out the theory it was based on was a lie? oops..

    still waiting for the grand republican jobs/economy plan...
    actually my narrow sighted friend, we prepare for and anticipate losses. asset classes move in differnt directions all the time. its part of investing.
    and the fed has not exited.

    what lie?

    and austerity is a result of government spending

    Leave a comment:


  • nando
    replied
    but the fed exit is what cost you money, and is in reality why you are so pissed.

    hey, how is all that austerity working for the EU? oh, they're in a depression you say? and it turns out the theory it was based on was a lie? oops..

    still waiting for the grand republican jobs/economy plan...

    Leave a comment:


  • gwb72tii
    replied
    Originally posted by nando
    Still waiting for the collapse of the dollar, double digit inflation, and $2500 gold.

    Wont hold my breath...

    Btw, george... how are those rising yields treating your bond portfolios? Is it ironic that the policies that you hate (or the man, i cant tell from all your hubris) are what gave you the bond run that made you money the last few years? And now that its over, the end of those same despised policies are now hurting your overweight bond strategy?

    Yet you're arguing against it? You are the definition of the word "irony".

    We're all still waiting for the Republican plan on jobs and the economy. I guess we'll see thatwhen the double digit inflation, that was supposed to happen 2 years ago, finally materializes? Or maybe when they are done shooting themselves in the foot on immigration and legislating women's private parts...
    with a 65% bond correction the bond side of our accounts have lost about 1.7%
    and yes i argue the fed should exit. there is no irony in that. the fed has perverted ALL asset prices with its misguided policies.
    the fact the bond market has corrected should make you less inclined to own stocks. google the schiller p/e of the s&p if you want some insight into where stocks trade today versus history, and then come back and argue why anyone should consider switching from one less overvalued asset (bonds) into a grossly overvalued asset (stocks). sorta like dating the least ugly woman in the room?

    and yes, bear sterns should have been allowed to blow the f**k up, live with the resulting aftermath, and move on. the fed made it's first mistake bailing out Long Term Capital in 1998, and now large financial institutions know the fed will come to the rescue. GM is another example of a company that should have declared bankruptcy on its own without the government coming in to make the unions rich at the expense of the bondholders, many of whom are older fixed income types

    Leave a comment:

Working...