Thumping/popping noise

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • TheWipprSnappr
    E30 Addict
    • Jul 2015
    • 477

    #1

    Thumping/popping noise

    Im currently experiencing a pretty gnarly thumping noise and feel coming from what sounds like directly under the front seats when the car is under any acceleration. I don't wanna pull anything until I get some more advice. Could this be the front driveshaft stripping and jumping splines. Or could it be something internally in the transfer case?
    1990 325iX - sterlingsilber metallic
    1991 325i - lazurblau metallic



    Originally posted by delamaize
    E30 = Lego for men.
  • Kershaw
    R3V OG
    • Feb 2010
    • 11822

    #2
    Probably stripped front driveshaft splines.
    AWD > RWD

    Comment

    • nando
      Moderator
      • Nov 2003
      • 34827

      #3
      yep.. keep those splines properly lubed! I recommend Molykote BR2-plus. However, it's too late now - hopefully the damage is only on the driveshaft, and not the output of the transfercase.
      Build thread

      Bimmerlabs

      Comment

      • TheWipprSnappr
        E30 Addict
        • Jul 2015
        • 477

        #4
        That's what im hoping as well. gonna remove the shaft this week and check the splines out. Thanks for the recommendation
        1990 325iX - sterlingsilber metallic
        1991 325i - lazurblau metallic



        Originally posted by delamaize
        E30 = Lego for men.

        Comment

        • TheWipprSnappr
          E30 Addict
          • Jul 2015
          • 477

          #5
          Trying to pull my front driveshaft and it seems pretty straight forward except for the transmission dipstick tube being wrapped around it, what's the best way to pull it out with regards to the tube?
          1990 325iX - sterlingsilber metallic
          1991 325i - lazurblau metallic



          Originally posted by delamaize
          E30 = Lego for men.

          Comment

          • TheWipprSnappr
            E30 Addict
            • Jul 2015
            • 477

            #6
            Never mind once I got that centering pin pulled it wiggled out
            1990 325iX - sterlingsilber metallic
            1991 325i - lazurblau metallic



            Originally posted by delamaize
            E30 = Lego for men.

            Comment

            • TheWipprSnappr
              E30 Addict
              • Jul 2015
              • 477

              #7
              update: I pulled the front driveshaft and the splines for the shaft and output gear looked just fine and had no signs of stripping. With the front shaft out I also drove it up the road and back and the popping noise went away. Could it possibly be due to a worn chain slipping? because with the front shaft removed it wouldn't be carrying a load, thus no slipping correct?
              Attached Files
              1990 325iX - sterlingsilber metallic
              1991 325i - lazurblau metallic



              Originally posted by delamaize
              E30 = Lego for men.

              Comment

              • nando
                Moderator
                • Nov 2003
                • 34827

                #8
                yeah, unfortunately I think you are correct. It's likely if the chain is damaged that it was run for a time with no fluid in the transfercase. The worst part is the chain is basically NLA - you *can* buy a new one, for $900, but that's almost what a new transfercase costs..

                I'd talked to a guy about running two smaller chains which are still available (from a snowmobile) but it would require some machining of the gears. The upside is they are way cheaper than the original chain.

                if there's a silver lining, it drives without the front driveshaft so at least your VC is good..
                Build thread

                Bimmerlabs

                Comment

                • TheWipprSnappr
                  E30 Addict
                  • Jul 2015
                  • 477

                  #9
                  Thanks for the info, and I really appreciate the quick feedback. And yes, second thought that came to mind was "at least the VC is good" haha
                  1990 325iX - sterlingsilber metallic
                  1991 325i - lazurblau metallic



                  Originally posted by delamaize
                  E30 = Lego for men.

                  Comment

                  • TheWipprSnappr
                    E30 Addict
                    • Jul 2015
                    • 477

                    #10
                    I also came across this because I was considering driving it around since it is my daily (I have a very short commute to work but I would have to bring it back to where I live which is a couple hours of interstate)

                    Originally posted by nando
                    your VC is good, that's why it works.

                    it's unpredictable because you don't have your front driveline hooked up.

                    I don't think you will find agreement that driving with it disconnected is bad or good. The only time it will really stress the VC is under acceleration, but it really shouldn't stress it much - it can only rotate so fast before it will lock, and then it really doesn't matter. at cruising speed, the difference between the front and rear wheels is the same regardless, so I would expect the VC to be doing very little, which is why it seems to work just fine for many people without the front shaft over a long period of time.
                    There seems to be some disagreement with this and I just wanted to double check since I don't want to do anything detrimental
                    1990 325iX - sterlingsilber metallic
                    1991 325i - lazurblau metallic



                    Originally posted by delamaize
                    E30 = Lego for men.

                    Comment

                    • Kershaw
                      R3V OG
                      • Feb 2010
                      • 11822

                      #11
                      Nando is the expert, if he says it's fine, I'd believe him.
                      AWD > RWD

                      Comment

                      • packratbimmer
                        E30 Fanatic
                        • Dec 2009
                        • 1329

                        #12
                        I have a good chain and matching gears if you need them

                        Comment

                        • packratbimmer
                          E30 Fanatic
                          • Dec 2009
                          • 1329

                          #13
                          Might want to drain the front differential to make sure it did not pop.

                          Comment

                          • 4x4_e30
                            Advanced Member
                            • Sep 2013
                            • 164

                            #14
                            Might want to check if your axle is all the way seated into the diff. The snap rings are a bitch and when I first got my car the front left wasn't snapped in all the way, and it made a similar noise.

                            Comment

                            • TheWipprSnappr
                              E30 Addict
                              • Jul 2015
                              • 477

                              #15
                              I hadnt considered that. Thanks for the tip, ill check it out
                              1990 325iX - sterlingsilber metallic
                              1991 325i - lazurblau metallic



                              Originally posted by delamaize
                              E30 = Lego for men.

                              Comment

                              Working...