Opinion on impact wrenches.

[M-technik-3]

The cheese ball electric ones from HF are not that bad in limited use. I would not recommend them to a mechanic though.

[parkerbink]

I have had crank pulley bolts that resisted the torch and my 1k lb IR air impact. There are bolts that just don't want to let go.

I stand by my no HF electric rule.

[Wiglaf]

3/8" and 1/4" don't give enough torque. Most of them are around 80 ft-lb. Guibo is torqued to ~90 ft lb and Axle Retaining Nut is ~150 ft-lb. So how does that satisfy my needs?

http://www.milwaukeetool.com/tools/cordless-tools/drilling-and-fastening/impact-wrenches

2000 in-lbs is over 160 ft-lb

[tonywonder]

LOL @ cheap electric impact.

if you dont have air and must use an electric spend some cash on it. it will be worth it in the long run. check warranty also.

did u try wd40 to help u out a bit? i would stick with the hand tools and breaker bar on this guibo job.

way to fuck up a torque wrench by bouncing on it btw.

[jdvorwe]

LOL @ cheap electric impact.

if you dont have air and must use an electric spend some cash on it. it will be worth it in the long run. check warranty also.

did u try wd40 to help u out a bit? i would stick with the hand tools and breaker bar on this guibo job.

way to fuck up a torque wrench by bouncing on it btw.

Torque wrench still works great:D
Used PB Blaster. PB > WD40. Literally don't think the bolts are coming out with hand tools. Spent over 6 hours trying various methods and didn't get one bolt out.
Why would I spend $400+ on air/impact wrench when I am probably not going to even use it that much/doing work in a apartment parking lot?

[tonywonder]

are you pushing down or pulling up? i would try using a breaker bar and putting a jack at the far end to help push it up. hopefully its not cross threaded...maybe have somebody else help you and hold the wrench in place so it doesnt slip off.

[TrentW]

Torque wrench still works great:D
Used PB Blaster. PB > WD40. Literally don't think the bolts are coming out with hand tools. Spent over 6 hours trying various methods and didn't get one bolt out.
Why would I spend $400+ on air/impact wrench when I am probably not going to even use it that much/doing work in a apartment parking lot?

Torque wrench? Seriously? You should be taken out in a field and shot in the head with a 22. Forget PB Blaster. Might as well use water. Get yourself a can of Winchester Gun Cleaner. Soak those bitches overnight. Hit them again the next day. Use a breaker bar w/six point socket and a six point closed-end wrench. Done.

You're welcome.

[jdvorwe]

are you pushing down or pulling up? i would try using a breaker bar and putting a jack at the far end to help push it up. hopefully its not cross threaded...maybe have somebody else help you and hold the wrench in place so it doesnt slip off.

Do you think how fucked up it is has anything to do with it?

[parkerbink]

Torque wrench still works great:D
Used PB Blaster. PB > WD40. Literally don't think the bolts are coming out with hand tools. Spent over 6 hours trying various methods and didn't get one bolt out.
Why would I spend $400+ on air/impact wrench when I am probably not going to even use it that much/doing work in a apartment parking lot?

You asked about impact guns. Go ahead, throw your money away on HF junk. You won't get the part off AND you will have a s*it tool.

Here is an idea. TAKE IT TO A REAL MECHANIC. You know not wtf you are doing.

[tonywonder]

LMFAO! wow. what the hell happened there. id rent the impact if you arent going to be doing this stuff a lot. is there a pepboys near you? usually the rental is free they just make u pay a core price and u get ur money back after u return it within the specified time. otherwise you end up owning it.

[TrentW]

You asked about impact guns. Go ahead, throw your money away on HF junk. You won't get the part off AND you will have a s*it tool.

Here is an idea. TAKE IT TO A REAL MECHANIC. You know not wtf you are doing.

For real.

[jdvorwe]

LMFAO! wow. what the hell happened there. id rent the impact if you arent going to be doing this stuff a lot. is there a pepboys near you? usually the rental is free they just make u pay a core price and u get ur money back after u return it within the specified time. otherwise you end up owning it.

Don't know really. Don't know if it was like when I got it from PO or not. Only driven the car once, been doing a lot of work to it. Had some vibrations when driving and when I got home jacked it up and that is what I saw.

Called the autoparts stores in the area, none of them had impacts for rent. Found one place near by that rents, but for $30.

Just figured if I rent for $30 and I can buy one for 49.99 if I only get 2 uses out of it was worth the money. Which is what I originally asked... Should I rent or buy a shitty one.

[jdvorwe]

You asked about impact guns. Go ahead, throw your money away on HF junk. You won't get the part off AND you will have a s*it tool.

Here is an idea. TAKE IT TO A REAL MECHANIC. You know not wtf you are doing.

I didn't ask about ALL impact guns. I asked if I should rent a good one or buy a shitty one. There is a difference. Maybe if you could read you would understand.

Either rent one for $30 (non refundable) or buy a cheap one 49.99 and if I only get two uses out of it, it was worth the money.

If it does not work I just return it because HF has hassle free returns. What a freaking concept.

[parkerbink]

If you had a clue that would be done but hell if you had a clue it never would have gotten that bad.

You can do it incorrectly multiple times and spend 10X as much or right once.

When you ask questions on the net you need to be prepared for responses you don't want.

Torque wrenches are for tightening to the proper torque. THEY ARE NOT BREAKER BARS.

[jdvorwe]

If you had a clue that would be done but hell if you had a clue it never would have gotten that bad.

You can do it incorrectly multiple times and spend 10X as much or right once.

When you ask questions on the net you need to be prepared for responses you don't want.

Torque wrenches are for tightening to the proper torque. THEY ARE NOT BREAKER BARS.

Wasn't my torque wrench, my friend (who owned the torque wrench) is the one who's idea it was to use it. But as I stated before, the torque wrench still works fine. Also, it has a lifetime warranty so who cares if it breaks.....

How am I spending 10x as much if I return it if it does not work?! Your intelligence amazes me.