the reason i came back from standing rock unscathed and unarrested is... i'm sort of good at taking calculated risks when i've decided direct action is necessary. shit, i got hurt worse at the last punk show i went to on sunday night.
wasn't my first rodeo, bud.
would *i* have done the sabotage we are discussing? probably not- but i understand why the involved parties did.
sleeve: all i have to say to you is you can suck my dick about it if you think i'm not allowed to have a voice about this. we will not be silenced.
Standing Rock vs Dakota pipeline
Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
-
there is more going on here than protesting a pipeline with decay. imho the roots of his anger aren't environment related.
and decay, i honor your service, even if you think it was for the wrong reason (oil). but to advocate willful destruction of property and perhaps innocent life makes no sense at all.
i hope you can find peace before you do something you have to live with for the rest of your lifeLeave a comment:
-
Ok, here we go.
I have been hesitant to bring the terrorist argument into this due to the fact that no one did get hurt and nothing but some pipe/fittings got damaged, though did imply that designation with the tie to the OKC bomber, may haps I should have used a Ayers/Dorn and the weather underground/SDS bombings in the late 1960's early 70's would have been far more appropriate comparison.
All that said, this sabotage/terrorist action was not an isolated incident, it happened on 3 separate valve settings in IA, so the potential for huge environmental impact was magnified 3 fold. The cost to fix those actions, somewhere in the neighborhood of 3/4-1 mill, per site. Also the people who did it are very luck they were not turned into a pink mist (smear implies there might be something left) even though the line was not loaded with product, it very well could have had a "hard pack" of Nitrogen on it that if released could have hurt or killed people not from the energy dump, but from the gas cloud. (and it likely did have 50-100 (or more) PSI of "dry air" on it). VERY VERY lucky idiots, is all I have to say on it.
Until you have been on a project like this, you can say all you want about operational safety, but until you see the terabytes of data that are collected during each phase of construction and amount of highly paid, highly experienced people. That paid to just watch to make sure the construction contractor is doing things the way they are supposed to be done and document the day to day construction activities its nothing more than that persons opinion and ass chattering in the breeze .
Decay buddy, I know what the Natives wanted....... MONEY, they were offered 10mil in lease, fees, to cross their res. The told ETP to fuck off and would take no less than 20mil, and wanted royalties for every barrel of product shipped . ETP declined that demand, and went to the FEDS, they will take the money (since they had to get Corp of Engineers approval to cross the RES and go under the lake anyway) and let the line cross federal land to the northern recognized (for well over 125 years) boarder of the res.
If your ilk and the natives really cared about protecting the water you would not have left the 1000 tons of toxic trash, human waste, and so on, all over the squatters camp to be washed into the fucking lake with the spring rains and snow melt, that camp and the way it was left posed a bigger risk to the "water" than the DAPL will likely EVERY cause. But thats ok dont worry the rest of us federal tax paying citizens will pick up the clean up and disposal tab since the Corp Of engineers had to clean up your mess for you, and that comes out of their operational budget, Your ilk would not have torched cars and equipment to allow that run off, and fumes to end up in the ecosystem either. Some water protectors you guys are, you lose sight of the water due to the fucking lake you are in.
Your defense that oh no one got hurt so its ok........ Is no different that the drunk driver that was trying to get home from the bar for the 100th time an gets pulled over wheeling into his driveway. Its not a fucking defense for trying to cause a fucking disaster of stupid proportions just so you can say I told you so, that becuase someone saw it before it was loaded with product, and no one got hurt that its just ok. I really hope they catch these tools and toss them in jail for a long while We have enough examples of old infrastructure failures from age, or mother nature as the cause, but to go out and WILLFULLY attempt to cause this kinda thing is just dumbfounding to me.
Its a small industry by # employed (across all trades involved), but every one of us works too fucking hard to do things right, and make sure we are building the rest of you a safe line to live and work around. We all take great pride in our work, even though its never seen, and the fruits are taken for granted by the rest of you. I dont take kindly to people trying take food off my table because they "think" they know better, but you are entitled to your opinions, but I dont think you would like if if a bunch of us construction hands got all uppity in your office and started telling you how you should not be doing your job. Honestly I dont think you would last 14 days in my world.
You really should just shut your mouth about pipelines I have more than made my case on more than 1 occasion, and yes there is always room to improve, you cant assume just because something can happen it will happen. You want to protest a pipeline, I suggest you look to some of the old shit thats been in the ground for 75 years and still in service not the new shit going in today.Last edited by mrsleeve; 03-29-2017, 07:25 PM.Leave a comment:
-
I cited something relative to your citizenship, decay. I'm fully aware you disagree with the law, it's still the law of the land and you're subject to it. Your nations definition of it is not unlike that of your allies. Satisfied, or do you prefer to remain in your own little bubble?
An Act to make provision about terrorism; and to make temporary provision for Northern Ireland about the prosecution and punishment of certain offences, the preservation of peace and the maintenance of order.
1 Terrorism: interpretation.
(1)In this Act “terrorism” means the use or threat of action where—
(a)the action falls within subsection (2),
(b)the use or threat is designed to influence the government [F1or an international governmental organisation] or to intimidate the public or a section of the public, and
(c)the use or threat is made for the purpose of advancing a political, religious [F2, racial] or ideological cause.
In Canada, section 83.01 of the Criminal Code[1] defines terrorism as an act committed "in whole or in part for a political, religious or ideological purpose, objective or cause" with the intention of intimidating the public "…with regard to its security, including its economic security, or compelling a person, a government or a domestic or an international organization to do or to refrain from doing any act."
...given their nature or context, may seriously damage a country or an international organisation where committed with the aim of: seriously intimidating a population; or unduly compelling a Government or international organisation to perform or abstain from performing any act; or seriously destabilising or destroying the fundamental political, constitutional, economic or social structures of a country or an international organisation.Leave a comment:
-
I am pretty sure the Patriot Act isn't the only law that could be used in court. So poo-pooing it as a "defense" isn't a defense. Intellectual dishonesty is bad.Leave a comment:
-
^ That defense ought to serve well in court. You can disagree with the law all you want, but the law is the law.
Sidenote.... I had a customer of mime who gets effluent irrigation water pumped directly into his irrigation system from a plant next door to irrigate his property. Long story short, the local utility krpt dropping the ball and forgetting to turn on transfer pumps at night. This utility is separated by a chain link fence from his property and he has a good relationship with the on site manager. One night before he went home he went into the utility property to make sure their pumps were on. Next mornimg he has two fbi agents in his office telling him what he did could be viewed as an act of terrorism. The govt has a wide berth with that stuff.Leave a comment:
-
it's not the website, idiot. you're citing a law that should never have existed as justification for your argument. is it that hard for you to understand?Leave a comment:
-
So a link to any other website hosting definitions would suffice? They all point in the same direction. What took place had that line been pressurized would have resulted in the equivalent of an environmental extremist false flag, the fabrication of catastrophe to further a failing agenda.
You should probably come to terms with how irrational your stance is when you have members of this forum who are on opposite ends of the political table both chiming in to denounce your thinking on this matter.Leave a comment:
-
-
yeah, citing the fucking patriot act as justification for your argument is not likely to change my opinion.
if sabotage is a terrorist act, then violating a treaty is an act of war.Leave a comment:
-
Leave a comment:
-
Ftfy
This was criminal behavior that put lives at risk trying to initiate a catastrophic incident, this was terrorism.
The only good that would have came out of this would have been had the line been pressurized and the culprits were turned into a pink smear.Section 802 of the USA PATRIOT Act (Pub. L. No. 107-52) expanded the definition of terrorism to cover ""domestic,"" as opposed to international, terrorism. A person engages in domestic terrorism if they do an act ""dangerous to human life"" that is a violation of the criminal laws of a state or the United States, if the act appears to be intended to: (i) intimidate or coerce a civilian population; (ii) influence the policy of a government by intimidation or coercion; or (iii) to affect the conduct of a government by mass destruction, assassination or kidnapping.Leave a comment:
-
Well said.I'm definitely on sleeve and marshall's side here, decay I don't know how you can agree with this "civil disobedience" because:
Civil Disobedience is marching down the street without a permit to do so, or sitting at a lunch counter where you're not wanted. That's Civil Disobedience. The people being disobedient are proving a point while ensuring that it's done in a way that doesn't put other lives in danger.
Destruction of property isn't civil disobedience. Civil disobedience can turn into destruction of property when people forget what they are ultimately protesting for. Like marches that turn into violent riots. Looting and vandalism don't really prove that people should be treated in a more fair fashion, it just further solidifies the racism that was there to begin with because it strengthens, not diminishes the inherent prejudice.
Cutting into the pipeline in an attempt to cause a spill to prove that the pipeline poses a danger to the environment isn't civil disobedience, it's destruction of property. That destruction of property occurred because people forgot what they were protesting for in the first place, protection of the environment. In no way does harming the environment help protect it. Cut off your nose to spite your face isn't a defense in my book worthy of anything but sheer stupidity.
Honestly, this pipeline will ultimately be safer than many others that run over countless thousands of miles because of the heat that's being placed upon its building. I'm not in the industry, and I will never claim to know the ins and outs of laying pipeline such as this, however, there is a need for the pipeline to be built, the planning stages have been gone through, and now there is protest, I'd say that people are sour because they missed the boat. Until we can find a safe, reliable, and inexpensive energy source, oil and NG are it, that's the world we live in. No sense in sabotaging a pipeline that's already built.Leave a comment:
-
Sorry had to work late last night I will get a post typed up soon, I just love people talking out their ass about an industry very very few people know anything. The assume is so strong in the threadLeave a comment:

Leave a comment: