So I've been looking at my power steering system again. I always felt that the steering was a bit lighter than it should be (both before and after the AN conversion), especially compared to the e46 330 which has the same steering rack (my dad used to have that car, I drove it a lot and always loved the steering feel). At first I thought maybe I just mis remembered the steering feel of that car, but after KI4UJO posted in his thread the same thing, it got me thinking again.
My logic is that as long as the system on my car is functionally equivalent to what was on the e46, the feel should be reproduced. So I found a couple of things...
First I double checked that my PS pump and the e46 pump are rated for the same pressure.
E36 ZF pump - standard OEM - (what I have) 110 bar

E46 pump - also OEM - 110 bar

So now I can confirm both pumps are making the same pressure, on to the next pieces of the puzzle. Hoses.
After reading KI4UJO's post, it got me thinking and I started looking for more info on e36 forums. Apparently on some of the e36s (not really sure when it started) there is a restrictor inside the return hose. My thought is that this is to help slow the fluid entering the reservoir and prevent aeration/spillover. I had a conversation with chase bays about their PS kit and he alluded to some restrictor inside the return line on their kit as well for the same reason, so this makes sense. I couldn't definitively say whether or not this is part of the e46 return hose because I didn't have one on hand to take apart and couldn't tell from photos. It might be integrated into par of the hardline. Either way, aeration/spillover was one of the issues I had previously so to me this seems like a good detail to include.
I found some pictures of said restrictor someone else took since I didn't have one of these hoses on hand to take apart. It also seems like only the oem hose included it, so if you want one go to a junkyard and cut one out of an e36, or find/make some sort of restriction to the same dimensions.
The critical dimension is the ~4mm orifice.



And here is the OEM hose, you can see the hose clamp in the return rubber portion holding the restrictor in place.

Here is another part that I didn't know about that KI4UJO posted. It's a banjo bolt with some sort of check valve/restrictor in it. The e46 system has this banjo bolt connecting the output end of the high pressure hose to the steering rack. Unfortunately I can't currently use it since I converted to AN. Well, technically I could, but I'd have to change that end of the high pressure hose I made to a banjo fitting. I'll do this as "last resort" if the other changes don't totally work.
PN for this is 32416781261

So now is probably the most critical part. The high pressure hose. Both the e36 and e46 have some restrictor in the hose. Interestingly, the e30 doesn't appear to have one (after I pulled the hose off my car, I stuck a stiff wire through it to see if it would get stuck, it didn't, though I still want to cut one up at a yard next time I go because it LOOKS like there is one)
Anyway. Here is the e36 hose

And e46 hose

Since I happen to have an e36 project sitting in my garage, and I intended to replace the high pressure hose, I pulled it off to dissect it. The restrictor was quite a bit more involved than I initially anticipated.
I tried to lay it out so you can see how it went together.








I will either try to put the restrictor + inner hose into my line, or will make the same sort of assembly from aluminum and stick it in there. I think that metal barb restrictor may be too big to fit inside the AN high pressure hose.
I will be testing all this tonight/tomorrow ahead of the autox I am attending sunday. Also replacing a leaky fitting.
My logic is that as long as the system on my car is functionally equivalent to what was on the e46, the feel should be reproduced. So I found a couple of things...
First I double checked that my PS pump and the e46 pump are rated for the same pressure.
E36 ZF pump - standard OEM - (what I have) 110 bar

E46 pump - also OEM - 110 bar

So now I can confirm both pumps are making the same pressure, on to the next pieces of the puzzle. Hoses.
After reading KI4UJO's post, it got me thinking and I started looking for more info on e36 forums. Apparently on some of the e36s (not really sure when it started) there is a restrictor inside the return hose. My thought is that this is to help slow the fluid entering the reservoir and prevent aeration/spillover. I had a conversation with chase bays about their PS kit and he alluded to some restrictor inside the return line on their kit as well for the same reason, so this makes sense. I couldn't definitively say whether or not this is part of the e46 return hose because I didn't have one on hand to take apart and couldn't tell from photos. It might be integrated into par of the hardline. Either way, aeration/spillover was one of the issues I had previously so to me this seems like a good detail to include.
I found some pictures of said restrictor someone else took since I didn't have one of these hoses on hand to take apart. It also seems like only the oem hose included it, so if you want one go to a junkyard and cut one out of an e36, or find/make some sort of restriction to the same dimensions.
The critical dimension is the ~4mm orifice.
And here is the OEM hose, you can see the hose clamp in the return rubber portion holding the restrictor in place.

Here is another part that I didn't know about that KI4UJO posted. It's a banjo bolt with some sort of check valve/restrictor in it. The e46 system has this banjo bolt connecting the output end of the high pressure hose to the steering rack. Unfortunately I can't currently use it since I converted to AN. Well, technically I could, but I'd have to change that end of the high pressure hose I made to a banjo fitting. I'll do this as "last resort" if the other changes don't totally work.
PN for this is 32416781261

So now is probably the most critical part. The high pressure hose. Both the e36 and e46 have some restrictor in the hose. Interestingly, the e30 doesn't appear to have one (after I pulled the hose off my car, I stuck a stiff wire through it to see if it would get stuck, it didn't, though I still want to cut one up at a yard next time I go because it LOOKS like there is one)
Anyway. Here is the e36 hose

And e46 hose

Since I happen to have an e36 project sitting in my garage, and I intended to replace the high pressure hose, I pulled it off to dissect it. The restrictor was quite a bit more involved than I initially anticipated.
I tried to lay it out so you can see how it went together.
I will either try to put the restrictor + inner hose into my line, or will make the same sort of assembly from aluminum and stick it in there. I think that metal barb restrictor may be too big to fit inside the AN high pressure hose.
I will be testing all this tonight/tomorrow ahead of the autox I am attending sunday. Also replacing a leaky fitting.
Comment